Ufology Notebook Vol 3 No 6

Magazine Overview

Title: UFOLOGY NOTEBOOK
Issue: 3/6
Volume: 3
Date: Summer, 1977 Edition
Editor and Publisher: Allen H. Greenfield
Publisher: ARBETSGRUPPEN FÖR UFOLOGI

This issue of UFOLOGY NOTEBOOK delves into the subjective aspects of the UFO phenomenon, exploring theoretical concepts and the evolving landscape of UFO conventions. It is dedicated to Dr. C. Louis Wiedemann and Curt Sutherly.

Editorial Notes

Allen H. Greenfield, in his editorial, addresses the state of "middle ufology" and the "bad blood" within the community. He expresses cautious optimism about the 1977 National UFO Conference in San Francisco, endorsing it despite lingering doubts about the organization's effectiveness. The issue heavily features a discussion of Dr. C. Louis Wiedemann's ("Uncle Lou's") subjective theory, which Greenfield finds compelling due to its alignment with premises in theoretical physics, parapsychology, and Jungian psychology. He notes that while the evidence for this theory is largely deductive and intuitive, it offers a more plausible explanation than "hard" theories when they appear to fall apart. Greenfield also mentions another version of subjectivism involving repressed psychic need projection.

Middle UFOLOGY and the Future of UFO Conventions

In a special report, Greenfield discusses the "ufo convention season" during the thirtieth anniversary of the modern UFO mystery. He traces the history of UFO conventions from early contactee gatherings to the more organized "official" groups. Greenfield observes that ufology is becoming "big business," with potential for larger, better-financed conventions sponsored by major publications. However, he warns of the danger of "watered-down" presentations and "safe" speakers, and the potential for increased elitism and WASP-like atmosphere. To counter these trends, UFOLOGY NOTEBOOK proposes three measures: withholding endorsement from conventions charging excessive fees, establishing a Task Force on Racism in UFOlogy, and creating a joint watchdog committee to ensure fair representation of opinions at conventions.

A Brief Comment on the "New Wave" UFO Skeptics

Greenfield recounts his evolving perspective on "new wave" UFO skeptics. Initially dismissive, he began to take them more seriously after encountering case studies that seemed to offer insights. However, his view shifted back to a modified skepticism after reviewing a case study by a major new skeptic, which he found to offer no new knowledge and to devolve into character assassination. His correspondence with some new skeptics revealed a lack of depth, narrow views, and questionable tactics. He concludes that while individual variations exist, many new skeptics are not serious thinkers and are locked into a false dichotomy, potentially acting as a "rear guard" as ETH advocates gain prominence.

Allen H. Greenfield Answers Recent Comments and Criticisms

Greenfield responds to several criticisms:

• "Vanity Publications": He defends his work as part of the "grassroots press" and contrasts it with "commercial exploitation publications" of the major media.
• Field Researcher Experience: He asserts that while field experience is valuable, it is not the sole determinant of a ufologist's worth. He states he has participated in about fifteen on-site field investigations, including the Pascagoula case and Brown Mountain lights, refuting claims of limited experience.
• Yonah Fortner Allegation: He expresses surprise at Fortner's claim of being ignored, stating he has been a champion of Fortner's "ancient astronaut" concept and cited him positively in his book "Saucers and Saucerers."
• Subjective Theory Misinterpretation: He clarifies that his subjective theory does not imply that anything one wishes becomes real in an objective sense. Instead, it focuses on why people want what they want, and in more complex versions, explores "psychic projections" with modifying factors like conscious/unconscious belief and societal consensus.

Correspondence

Letter from Dr. C. Louis Wiedemann (Uncle Lou): Dated February 12, 1977, Wiedemann thanks Greenfield for prominently featuring his letter and expresses anticipation for future issues. He suggests expanding the "Comments by Greenfield" section. He also recommends that Tom Bearden and Tom Pawlicki receive the Notebook, highlighting their theoretical contributions.

Letter from Paul Christiansen: Dated February 18, 1977, Christiansen raises several questions regarding Wiedemann's subjective theory, including the nature of other realities, the ability to alter reality, and the possibility of being figments of another intelligence's imagination. He notes the current trend of UFO investigation is on surer footing, with mind projection potentially explaining conflicting evidence. He also discusses time displacement in case histories and Keel's theory involving electromagnetic wavelengths.

Letter from Joseph Kerrick: Dated March 3, 1977, Kerrick praises the "new wave" of UFOLOGY NOTEBOOK, appreciating its metaphysical focus over "saucer-chasing." He finds Wiedemann's letter about the government suppressing the idea that the world is an illusion "fantastic." Kerrick discusses the concept of "Awakening" and the potential for a race of god-like beings. He apologizes for his previous criticism, acknowledging that he had not fully appreciated Greenfield's perspective. He finds Greenfield's examples of UFO manifestation interesting, suggesting a higher sentient power might be projecting both UFOs and humans. Kerrick's primary interest lies in how the Space Age and mysticism can combine to produce new human development frontiers.

Letter from Tom Bearden: Dated March 2, 1977, Bearden expresses enjoyment of the UFOLOGY NOTEBOOK samples and requests to be added to the mailing list. He appreciates the focus on the subjective side of UFOs and paranormal phenomena, finding it refreshing compared to conventional "nuts-and-bolts" approaches. He references his work in Brad Steiger's "Gods of Aquarius" and encloses his analytical theory on how mental images can become objective phenomena, as well as a paper on "An Approach to Understanding Psychotronics." Bearden believes the subjective/objective approach to UFO phenomena can be put into solid scientific format with a new physics/logic/mathematics paradigm.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue revolve around the subjective nature of the UFO phenomenon, the role of consciousness and psychic projection in understanding UFOs, and the future direction of ufology as a field. The editorial stance, as articulated by Allen H. Greenfield, is one of critical engagement with various theories and trends within ufology. While open to exploring subjective interpretations and acknowledging the significance of the UFO problem, Greenfield maintains a cautious and analytical approach, advocating for rigorous standards, ethical considerations, and a broad spectrum of viewpoints within the community. He appears to favor a more nuanced understanding of UFOs that moves beyond simplistic explanations and embraces the complexities of consciousness and perception.

This issue of UFOLOGY NOTEBOOK, dated February 5, 1977, is presented as a collection of letters and articles exploring complex concepts related to reality, consciousness, and unexplained phenomena. The publication appears to be a compilation of photocopied letters, fostering a sense of ongoing dialogue and shared exploration among its contributors.

Key Articles and Discussions

The Nature of Multiple Realities and Quantum Mechanics

A central theme is the exploration of multiple realities, challenging the human tendency to assume a single, concrete 'world.' The author, writing from Huntsville, AL, argues that physics itself does not claim to describe a possible real world underlying its equations, but rather constructs theoretical models that are useful if they correspond to observations. A key requirement for a theory is that it must be falsifiable. Quantum electrodynamics is cited as an example of a successful model that employs both observable and nonobservable (virtual) realities. Virtual entities are described as being governed by the principle that the product of their energy change (delta E) and time change (delta T) must be less than Planck's constant divided by four pi. This condition makes them non-measurable by ordinary instruments, though their time dimension is real and modulated by these virtual changes.

The author posits that quantum mechanics inherently contains two types of realities: observable and nonobservable (virtual). The boundary between them is defined by quantum statements, such as Delta A (change in action) equaling h/4 pi. This implies that entities existing in a nonobservable reality can occupy the 'real observable universe' for brief fractions of time. The analogy is made to virtual entities being like minute dots within an observable picture.

Mental Objects and Consciousness

Expanding on this, the concept of 'mental changes' or 'mental objects' is introduced. Using the example of a mental image of a chair, it is argued that a mental chair exists simultaneously with a physical chair in the same time dimension. However, it does not occupy the spatial dimensions of the physical chair. The discrete action changes representing a mental chair must be of a magnitude less than Planck's constant divided by four pi, making it real but unobservable and undetectable by instruments. If these mental subquanta could be coherently collected or superposed to reach the quantum level, the mental chair would become as real as its physical counterpart, vanishing if the coherence were lost.

The author references their own work, "The One Human Problem, Its Solution, and Its Relation to UFO Phenomena," specifically Appendix I: The Holographic Hyperchannel Effect, as a theoretical analysis of this concept. The idea of 'higher dimensions' is linked to infinite-dimensional frames, where sets of three spatial dimensions, removed from the observer's frame and sharing the fourth dimension (time), fulfill the conditions for mental frames. These higher dimensional frames are described as mental worlds with their own 'concrete' reality, subtly interacting with the ordinary frame through virtual changes.

The Collective Unconscious and Archetypes

Coherent crosstalk between these mind frames is suggested to correspond to the collective human unconscious, with common groupings of these changes constituting archetypes. A living biological system is seen as a direct association between phenomena in a mind frame and the ordinary frame, with death being the loss of this coherent crosstalk channel. The author asserts that the mind can be modeled physically, and that arguments about such models should be based on their fit with observed data, not on personal belief.

Fit with Modern Physics and Fortean Phenomena

This model is claimed to be consistent with the experimental basis of modern physics, citing Everett's work. It is also presented as providing explanations for ESP, teleportation, psychokinesis, UFOs, Fortean phenomena, the mind, the collective unconscious, thought photography, spook lights, cryptids (sasquatches, fairies, elves, Loch Ness monsters, yetis), and enabling engineering applications like radionics and psychotronics. The author emphasizes that this is a working hypothesis, to be examined for its fit with data and theoretical predictions.

Challenges in Ordinary Physics

Ordinary physics, as currently interpreted, is criticized for its limitations. The concept of 'observable phenomena' is defined, and ordinary physics' attempt to represent them through probabilities and DeBroglie waves is discussed. The interpretation for a single observer at a time is seen as problematic, leading to the mysterious and contradictory 'collapse of the wave function.' The author highlights several limitations: only one observer exists at a time; the observer is external but interacts with the event; two types of reality (observable and virtual) exist; and an inexplicable effect collapses the wave function. The role of the mind, which is not describable by physics, is also brought into question, suggesting it lies outside the ordinary physics realm and interacts with physical changes.

The publication argues that ordinary physics cannot solve the problem when the observer is part of the observed system or explain the necessity of wave function collapse. Everett's work is presented as the only apparent resolution, though its implications of multiple realities and universes are considered too strange for most physicists.

The Need for Extraordinary Physics

For Fortean phenomena, which are described as 'alien reality,' 'extraordinary physics' is deemed necessary. The author suggests that the only candidate for explaining multiple kinds of reality is Everett's many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics. The author clarifies their background as a nuclear engineer, not a physicist, which they see as an advantage, allowing them to think outside conventional physics paradigms without being 'hidebound.' They also note their independence from the physics establishment due to being retired and working in computerized wargames, though this means their research is self-funded and proceeds slower.

Book Reviews and Recommendations

The issue includes reviews of several books. "The Cosmic Pulse of Life" by Trevor Janez Constable is highly praised. "Gravity and Levity" by Alan McGlashan is also recommended as a wise book. "The Space-Gods Revealed" by Ronald Story, a critique of Erich von Däniken, is considered biased toward orthodox science but includes an interesting appendix by Robert S. Ellwood, Jr.

Quotes are included from Leonora Carrington's surrealist novel "The Hearing Trumpet" and George Sims' mystery novel "The End of the Web." The quotes touch on themes of life, death, perception, and boredom with the universe.

Personal Correspondence and Reflections

Several letters form a significant part of the issue:

• Letter from Tom (February 5, 1977): This letter, addressed to Lou, discusses the development of multiple realities and their connection to quantum mechanics. It highlights the limitations of ordinary physics in explaining phenomena like ESP and UFOs, advocating for the many-worlds interpretation. The author also mentions their personal research and the need for funding.
• Letter from Dave Reissig (February 12, 1977): Dave Reissig writes to Allen Greenfield, praising the format of UFOLOGY NOTEBOOK as a 'giant conversation.' He discusses subjective idealism, the concept of absolute proof, and the idea that reality might vanish as a dream when its support is withdrawn. He recommends subscribing to "Fortean Times" magazine.
• Letter from Dave Reissig (February 25, 1977): In this letter, Reissig discusses ideas from "UFOLOGY NOTEBOOK" and "Werner Erhard's est" training. He finds est more valuable than psychedelics and discusses its controversial aspects. He also mentions meeting Robert Anton Wilson and hearing about his contactee experiences and UFO sightings.
• Letter from Janice (February 12, 1977): Janice writes to Allen, liking the cover and new format of UN. She reports her UFO study club is growing and mentions co-authoring a book. She urges readers to form small UFO study groups and announces plans for interviews with Larry Stephens on Denver radio.
• Letter from Bort (January 20, 1977): Bort writes to Al, expressing enjoyment of UFOLOGY NOTEBOOK. He recounts visiting the Pascagoula abduction site and meeting individuals involved. He reflects on the 'Pascagoula River' legend and a coincidental radio broadcast about a UFO abduction, suggesting a connection between his subconscious and the event. He also shares poems.

Other Mentions

• The publication mentions a libertarian magazine called "Libertarian Connection" and "Green Egg's Forum."
• The "P.E.T. (Parent Effectiveness Training)" course is mentioned.
• The "Village Voice" is cited for an exposé.
• The "Boskone" event and a discussion group on "Evolution of Planetary Consciousness" are noted.
• Yoga lessons and swimming are mentioned as personal activities.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

This issue of UFOLOGY NOTEBOOK strongly advocates for exploring unconventional ideas that challenge the mainstream scientific paradigm. The recurring themes include the nature of reality, the limitations of current physical theories, the role of consciousness, and the investigation of unexplained phenomena (UFOs, Fortean events). The editorial stance appears to be open-minded and critical of established scientific dogma, encouraging readers to consider alternative models like Everett's many-worlds interpretation. There is a clear emphasis on personal experience, subjective exploration, and the potential for a more comprehensive understanding of the universe that integrates both the physical and the mental, or even the 'paranormal.' The publication seems to function as a platform for disseminating and discussing these ideas through correspondence and shared intellectual inquiry.

This document appears to be a collection of correspondence and announcements related to ufology, centered around the Fourteenth Annual National UFO Conference held on August 6, 1977, in San Francisco. The content includes personal letters, a supplement with UFO illustrations, and official conference details.

Correspondence and Personal Reflections

The issue features several letters from individuals sharing their thoughts and experiences. Gene Steinberg writes about his busy schedule, upcoming articles for 'UFO Report' on the UFO/Star Trek connection and an interview with Yonah. He also offers typesetting services and mentions his brother-in-law's gold coin investments. Steinberg expresses interest in a proposed Middle Ufology convention and laments the 'orphaning' of subscribers from 'Probe-The Unknown,' suggesting 'Crossroads Quarterly' might help fill subscription gaps.

Steinberg also reflects on UFO projections and the nature of reality, suggesting that collective belief can shape perceived reality, drawing parallels to historical beliefs in supernatural creatures. He posits that the early UFO era's focus on physical phenomena might have stemmed from the assumption of extraterrestrial visitation.

Steve Elliott responds to a previous letter, agreeing with thoughts on personal freedom and praising the format of the publication for printing letters as received. Barry Greenwood comments on a letter by Richard Heiden concerning the Pascagoula witnesses and a test run using a Psychological Stress Evaluator. He notes that while NICAP's 'UFO Quarterly Review' published results of such a test, the analysis was inconclusive due to the lack of a structured interview, though high stress was observed during television interviews.

Peter dedicates an article to 'Dr. Fu-Manchu,' humorously discussing current UFO sightings and the concept of 'Big Macs' as attack shelters. He also comments on Samuel R. Delaney's novel 'The Fall of the Towers,' touching on themes of civilization, technology, and alien interference. Peter suggests that the 'two-dimensional world' might relate to the 'shadowiness of fairyland' and the parasitic nature of its inhabitants, and encourages a consideration of the spiritual world, contrasting it with abstract metaphysics.

Clark 318 writes to Mr. Greenfield, asserting that UFOs are futile subjects of study, attributing sightings to hallucinations and natural phenomena. This letter advocates for the preservation of the United Nations, the Federal Reserve System, and a World Order favored by Mr. Kissinger, emphasizing the need for discrete speech if energy and money systems are threatened. The letter also mentions the Alaskan Project for mental health care and the possibility of internment for maintaining order.

UFO Supplement

A visually rich supplement illustrates various UFO concepts and types, including a 'basic cigar shaped device,' a 'basic landed ufo,' and a 'common flying device often mistaken for ufos by mystics.' It also depicts a 'Big M.A.C.' and 'Swamp gas,' along with whimsical drawings of a 'blood sucking Turnip' and a 'crude fairy pavilion.' The supplement includes a drawing of a 'monster, often seen in distance over China' and mentions 'Vega, seat of Stellan Empire hostile to earth' and 'Mars, home of ufo nauts.' It concludes with a note about 'VICTIMS who follow swamp gas never to return.... were really after FAIRLY LIGHTS a-k-a.'

Fourteenth Annual National UFO Conference

The core of this issue is the announcement and details of the Fourteenth Annual National UFO Conference, held on Saturday, August 6, 1977, at the PSA Hotel in San Francisco. The conference featured both a 'Closed Session' and a 'Public Session.'

Closed Session

The closed session, scheduled for 1:00 pm, was designed for personal exchange of information among participants, including presentations and talks on various aspects of the UFO phenomenon. The policy of open participation, without excluding any group or individual, was highlighted. A tentative list of participants included Allen Greenfield, R.F. Haines (speaking on 'What do UFO witnesses and non-witnesses think UFOs look like?'), Curt Sutherly, Gray Barker (discussing the Flatwoods monster), John Musgrave (on 'Occupants and Critters North of the 49th Parallel'), Rick Hilberg, and Bob Easley. James W. Moseley, editor of 'Saucer News,' was the chairman. The event was sponsored by California UFO Research. Registration for the closed session was free, with options to reserve a seat or a room at the hotel.

Public Session

The public session began at 8:00 pm and featured presentations by Stanton T. Friedman, a nuclear physicist discussing 'Flying Saucers Are Real,' and Allen H. Greenfield, presenting on 'UFO's and the Crisis of Consciousness.' Friedman's lecture focused on evidence for extraterrestrial visitation, while Greenfield's explored the nexus between UFOs and paranormal phenomena. The session also included representation from various UFO research organizations and the sale of books and publications. Tickets for the public session cost $3.00, with advance tickets available from California UFO Research.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue revolve around the nature of UFO phenomena, the perception of reality, and the organization of ufological communities. There's a clear division in perspectives, from those who believe in extraterrestrial visitation (Friedman) to those who attribute sightings to psychological phenomena or hallucinations (Clark 318). The conference itself represents an effort to foster community and information exchange within the ufology field, despite acknowledged personality disputes. The inclusion of diverse viewpoints, from scientific inquiry to speculative fiction and personal reflections, highlights the multifaceted nature of the UFO subject as presented in this publication.