UFO Brigantia issue 30

Magazine Overview

Title: UFO BRIGANTIA
Issue: No. 30
Date: March/April 1988
Publisher: IUN. PUBLICATION.
Type: A Journal of UFO Investigation.

This issue of UFO BRIGANTIA, the journal of the Independent UFO Network (IUN), is a bi-monthly publication priced at £1.25 for single copies. The IUN itself was formed in September 1987 from a merger of the West Yorkshire UFO Research Group (WYUFORG) and the Yorkshire UFO Network (YUFON), along with other independent investigators. The network emphasizes a non-dogmatic approach, freedom of information, and witness anonymity, and maintains an open policy regarding its case files. It operates a 24-hour UFO Hotline and is involved in Project Pennine, a study of anomalous light phenomena in the UK.

Editorial

The editorial, titled "EDITORIAL", discusses the issue's focus on the Kenneth Arnold sighting of June 24, 1947. The editor expresses concern that ufology has become overly fixated on this single event, treating it as a "ufological Book of Genesis" and a "Creationist ufology" with little room for earlier or evolving phenomena. The article argues that Arnold's sighting, while significant historically, has been over-analyzed and re-interpreted, and that its modern significance lies more in its place within the development of ufological belief systems rather than the event itself. The editor notes that the name 'Flying Saucer' predates Arnold's sighting and that the event was unsubstantiated, suggesting that in contemporary times, it might only receive a brief mention.

Articles and Features

Humberside Happenings

This article, by Gary Anthony & Philip Mantle, investigates a series of UFO sightings reported over North Humberside on December 9, 1987. Local police and military authorities, including RAF Binbrook, were initially baffled. Approximately 50 witnesses reported seeing large objects with numerous red and white lights moving slowly and making noise. One witness, a former RAF member, suggested it was a military refuelling exercise. After extensive investigation, including appeals via the UFO Hotline and checks with the Ministry of Defence, the sightings were confirmed to be USAF KC-135 tanker aircraft with up to seven F-11 aircraft in trail, exercising over the North Sea. The article questions why the police did not identify this sooner and notes that other UFO groups were also adamant that aircraft were not responsible.

Restoring Arnold's Good Name

Authored by Regina Cullen, this article is a response to a previous piece by Hans Van Kampen titled "Case #17 Revised" (published in UFO BRIGANTIA 28, Nov/Dec '87). Cullen criticizes Van Kampen's analysis of the Kenneth Arnold sighting, calling it "breathtakingly cavalier" and full of "errors and irresponsible assumption." The article refutes specific points made by Van Kampen, including interpretations of Arnold's statements about the objects' dimensions, speed, and flight path. Cullen highlights that Arnold's original drawings did not include the "squiggle" presented by Van Kampen and argues that Van Kampen misrepresented Arnold's account of the objects' movement and altitude. The article also touches upon the work of J. Allen Hynek and Donald Menzel, suggesting Hynek's interpretations were influenced by a desire to debunk and that Menzel was involved with MJ-12. Cullen concludes that Van Kampen's analysis is specious and designed to fit a theory rather than the facts, and that his efforts are an attempt to obfuscate rather than clarify the Arnold myth.

Conspiracy, Cover-Up, Or Cock-Up?

By Jenny Randles, this article examines the reaction of the British UFO media to the "conspiracy plot" of 1987, particularly in contrast to the American media. Randles notes that while the USA has been heavily focused on cover-up theories, Britain has perhaps been too dismissive. She clarifies that her own book, "UFO Conspiracy," contracted in 1985, was intended for a mass market audience and not specifically for ufologists, aiming to provide a fact-rooted account rather than a potboiler. She contrasts this with the timing of Tim Good's "Above Top Secret" and the leak of the MJ-12 documents, which occurred around the same period.

Other Content

The issue also includes a "Letters" section and "Reviews," though their content is not detailed in the provided pages. The table of contents lists articles such as "Is Your Neighbour A Space Alien?" by Andy Roberts, "OSEAP Resources Centre" by David Rees, and "Fly-By-Night" by David Wilbur Clarke.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue revolve around critical analysis of UFO phenomena and the history of ufology. There is a strong emphasis on questioning established narratives, particularly the significance of the Kenneth Arnold sighting as the origin point of modern UFO belief. The magazine also engages with contemporary UFO topics like conspiracy theories and the MJ-12 documents, advocating for a balanced and fact-based approach. The editorial stance appears to be one of rigorous investigation, skepticism towards sensationalism, and a commitment to uncovering the truth, even when it challenges popular beliefs within the UFO community. The critique of Hans Van Kampen's analysis of the Arnold sighting exemplifies this critical and evidence-based approach.

This issue of UFO BRIGANTIA, dated March/April 1988, features a critical examination of UFO conspiracy theories, particularly focusing on the controversial MJ-12 documents and the concept of government disinformation. The magazine presents a strong argument that the MJ-12 papers, while appearing to offer proof of alien visitation, are in fact a carefully orchestrated hoax designed to discredit genuine UFO research and distract from official archives.

The MJ-12 Fiasco and Disinformation

The lead article delves into the author's personal experience with the publication of his book, 'UFO Conspiracy,' and his subsequent rereading of it in light of the MJ-12 controversy. He posits that the MJ-12 documents, rather than being genuine evidence of alien presence or government cover-ups of crashed spacecraft, are a deliberate fabrication. The author suggests that these documents were strategically released to provide ufologists with something they desperately wanted to believe – proof of dead aliens and secret government projects. This, in turn, allows authorities to control the narrative, seeding doubt and discrediting the entire field by association with a likely hoax. The article criticizes the media's focus on the MJ-12 saga, arguing it overshadows more substantive UFO evidence.

The author dismisses accusations that researchers like William Moore and Stanton Friedman faked the documents, believing they are committed to the Extraterrestrial Hypothesis (ETH) and would not risk their credibility. Instead, he points to the possibility of a sophisticated disinformation campaign originating from high-level sources with access to national archives. The article notes that similar documents were offered to the author in 1986, suggesting a pattern of covert approaches.

Media and UFO Coverage

Another section, "IS YOUR NEIGHBOUR A SPACE ALIEN?" by Andy Roberts, chronicles media exposure of UFOs and related myths over the preceding two months. It highlights various instances, including the advertising campaign for Whitley Streiber's book 'Communion,' the 'Face on Mars' phenomenon reported in the Daily Star, and the enduring 'War of the Worlds' broadcast hoax. Roberts expresses skepticism towards sensationalized UFO claims, emphasizing the need for critical analysis and caution against gullibility.

The issue also discusses the changing odds on the reality of UFOs, citing a Q magazine article that contrasts government acknowledgment probabilities with other unlikely events. Radio One DJ Steve Wright's 'Space Alien Day' is mentioned as an example of popular media saturating the public with bizarre UFO and alien stories, potentially influencing perceptions.

Book Reviews

Several books are reviewed, offering insights into the ufological landscape of the time:

• 'PHENOMENON: From Flying Saucers to UFOs- Forty Years Of Facts And Research' edited by John Spencer and Hilary Evans is described as a comprehensive and balanced work, suitable for both casual readers and enthusiasts. It is praised for covering major topics critically, offering counter-arguments, and avoiding rabid debunking or naive belief. The review highlights the importance of the chapters 'The Case For Scepticism' and 'The Case For Scientific Study' for understanding the direction of ufology in the 1980s.
• 'GODS SPIRITS COSMIC GUARDIANS: Encounters With Non-Human Beings' by Hilary Evans is presented as an essential read for the open-minded. It explores man's encounters with various non-human beings, suggesting that these encounters might represent higher aspects of the self rather than purely alien visitations. The book is characterized as 'Humanist ufology' and aims to provoke deep thought.

Letters to the Editor

The 'Letters' section features correspondence from readers:

• Anthony R. Brown critiques David Clarke's article 'Seeing The Lights,' arguing that religious 'visionary' experiences, often attributed to divine inspiration, can be explained by psychological and physiological factors such as fasting, exhaustion, hyperventilation, and mind-altering drugs, drawing parallels to manipulation and brainwashing techniques.
• Steven Hobbs expresses surprise and support for UFO BRIGANTIA's critical approach, contrasting it with what he perceives as 'maniacal conspiracy rubbish' in other publications like QUEST.
• Christopher Low comments on an article about the Kenneth Arnold case, questioning the assertion that an F-84 Thunderjet would look significantly different from other jet fighters at a distance, suggesting this particular case may not be as close to a solution as presented.

Other Mentions

Brief mentions are made of other UFO-related material, including an episode of the TV series 'Dynasty' featuring an abduction recollection and the New Musical Express's 'Booby Moore's Mysterious World' section, which the magazine suggests is working with the government. Jenny Randles' article 'Flying Saucers Are Not A Mugs Game' in The Guardian is highlighted as a good representation of ufology.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue revolve around the critical analysis of UFO evidence, the skepticism towards sensationalized claims, and the examination of how media and disinformation campaigns can shape public perception. The magazine's editorial stance appears to be one of cautious investigation, advocating for a rational and evidence-based approach to ufology, while acknowledging the existence of the phenomenon itself. There is a clear emphasis on distinguishing between genuine research and what the magazine deems as 'rubbish' or manipulative tactics. The issue champions a more sober and scientific approach to understanding UFOs, looking towards the future direction of the field.

This issue of UFO BRIGANTIA, dated March/April 1988, features a significant focus on UFO sightings in South Yorkshire during early 1988, alongside an in-depth look at the importance of ufological archives and resources.

Media Influence and Public Perception

The lead article on page 21 discusses the impact of media coverage on the public's understanding of UFO phenomena. It critiques a television programme, possibly 'Dynasty', for its handling of UFO witnesses and its focus on UFOs as spaceships. The author notes that 'bad' images of UFOs, often sensationalized, tend to outweigh more credible reports because they sell papers. This media influence, where speculation is presented as fact, shapes public beliefs and the nature of sighting reports. The article highlights an 'abduction' case that occurred on the same night the programme aired, suggesting a connection between media exposure and witness experiences. The author concludes that ufologists often struggle to counter the 'crap' the media disseminates and that their role may increasingly be to chronicle the interplay between media input and witness output.

The OSEAP Resources Centre

Pages 22-25 detail the OSEAP Resources Centre, authored by David L. Rees. The article defines 'resources' as something to turn to for help or support. It posits that UFO literature, or 'UFO-lit', is a distinct body of work, with magazines and newsletters forming its backbone. OSEAP believes that sightings are secondary to the accumulated knowledge and theories surrounding them. The article laments the lack of progress in ufology, noting that material from the 1950s could easily be reprinted today. The OSEAP Resources Centre was formed in April 1981 (initially as MAPIT) to provide a comprehensive collection of reference material, accessible to all without prejudice. The author criticizes individual researchers who hoard their collections, citing examples of extensive libraries kept inaccessible. He quotes Robert Morrell, who stated that ufology, despite claiming status, lacks elementary research facilities, particularly comprehensive access to main ufological journals.

OSEAP has been indexing since 1981, and the article notes that the national group BUFORA's archives are in a 'disorganised shambles'. The centre aims to create an archival collection and a historical record. The author expresses fascination with the diverse titles of UFO periodicals. OSEAP's indexing system involves cross-referencing by subject headings, names, and themes, initially focusing on British publications but open to overseas material, slides, photographs, and other ephemera. The centre relies on donations and hopes for future funding to acquire a computer system for more efficient indexing.

South Yorkshire UFO Odyssey 1988

Pages 26-30 present a detailed investigation by David Clarke into a series of UFO sightings in South Yorkshire during February 1988, which was part of a new wave of sightings beginning in August 1987. The article highlights a 'Daily Mirror' report about two police officers in Ecclesfield who saw a 'V-shaped machine' with flashing red lights hovering low, accompanied by a whirring noise.

Clarke investigated the Ecclesfield sighting, finding that newspaper reports were inaccurate. He learned that PC Sue Johnson and PC John Baxter observed the object, which appeared as a large arrow-head or V-shaped formation moving from Rotherham towards Ecclesfield. It was described as flying very low, making a strange whirring, groaning, vibrating noise, and was definitely not an aeroplane or helicopter. The object was estimated to be around 150 mph at under 1000ft altitude and was compared in size to a Boeing 737.

Further sightings were reported across South Yorkshire, with some observers linking them to a mail-carrying plane or a commuter aircraft. The article notes that the MOD confirmed no RAF/NATO exercises were taking place in the area. Flight Lieutenant Hamilton of RAF Finningley suggested the sightings could be explained by a turboprop commuter aircraft, citing standard civil aircraft lighting patterns.

However, many witnesses were emphatic that the objects were not aircraft, citing their low altitude, brilliant lights, and unusual maneuverability. The article details multiple sightings of triangular, diamond, and oval-shaped objects with rotating lights, some described as soundless. One witness described the noise as 'like a cross between a heavily burdened diesel engine and the sound that the little flying saucer makes in the Arcade game 'Invaders''.

Another significant event occurred on February 10th, 1988, with reports of a 'huge' diamond or pyramid-shaped object seen over Wombwell and Hoyland, near Barnsley. This object was described as flying very low, surrounded by colored lights, and making a whirring noise.

Similar sightings were reported in Uttoxeter, where a large pie-shaped object with rotating lights hovered near electricity pylons. The article questions whether these are 'standard' UFO types and notes the growing number of reports of triangular-shaped objects since August 1987.

Books and Magazines

The issue concludes with sections on 'Books for Sale', listing titles such as 'Operation Trojan Horse' by John Keel and 'Flying Saucers Have Landed' by D. Leslie & G. Adamski, and 'Magazines', offering Flying Saucer Review duplicates for sale.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are the prevalence of UFO sightings in the UK, particularly in South Yorkshire, the significant impact of media coverage on public understanding and reporting of UFO phenomena, and the critical need for organized archival resources and research facilities within ufology. The editorial stance appears to be one of critical investigation, acknowledging both credible witness testimony and the potential for misidentification or conventional explanations, while also highlighting the challenges posed by media sensationalism and the lack of systematic research infrastructure in the field. The magazine champions the work of organizations like OSEAP that are dedicated to preserving and cataloging UFO-related information.

Title: UFO BRIGANTIA
Issue: MAR/APR
Date: 1988-03
Type: Magazine Issue

This issue of UFO Brigantia, dated March/April 1988, is primarily focused on upcoming events and calls for contributions within the ufology community.

Back Issues of END TIMES BULLETIN

A section details the availability of back issues for END TIMES BULLETIN. These are offered as a job lot for £50, including postage and packing. The listing specifies numerous volumes and issue numbers from Vol 9 through Vol 27, along with a Case History supplement and 42 additional copies, totaling 42 copies in all.

END TIMES BULLETIN: Kevin McClure

Kevin McClure announces the relaunch of END TIMES BULLETIN, a news and comment journal, after a five-year hiatus. He aims to create a participative readership and solicits contributions such as news clippings, rumors, religious tracts, prophecies, threats, stories of doom and gloom, new age information, geological disasters, disease, the Antichrist, Armageddon, and other components of the '20th Century Apocalyptic Vision.' Contributions will be credited, and those who help may receive free copies of the first issue. Submissions should be sent to Kevin McClure at 20 Trembear Road, St Austell, Cornwall, PL25 5NY.

OPERATION SKYWATCH

BUFORA is organizing sponsored skywatches in conjunction with the entire ITV network's 27-hour charity telethon event scheduled for May 29/30. These events will invite the public to observe the sky, talk to ufologists, and learn about ufology and local cases, with donations going to charity. The IUN will also hold a skywatch, with the venue to be determined. Subscribers who cannot attend can support the event by obtaining a sponsor form from the editorial address. Further details will be released via the media in April/May.

MAGONIA CONFERENCE

The Magonia 20th Anniversary conference is scheduled for May 1st and 2nd, 1988, at the Sheen Lane Centre, London SW14. The conference aims to provide an in-depth look at twenty years of Magonia and the past forty years of ufology, with ample time for socialising. The cost is £7.00 for one day or £12.00 for two, which includes a hot buffet lunch, morning coffee, afternoon tea, full documentation, and a free copy of the proceedings, with potential additional freebies. John Rimmer is seeking speakers and lecturers for the event. Those interested in attending or contributing can contact John Rimmer at 5, James Terrace, London SW14 8HB.

HELP!

Philip Mantle, an IUN and BUFORA researcher, is compiling information on British abduction cases, particularly obscure and little-documented ones, and from older UFO magazines. He requests that anyone with relevant information, material, thoughts, or theories contact him. His contact details are available on the inside front page of the magazine.

Cover Art and Theme

The cover of this issue features a prominent 'WANTED' poster design with an alien face, posing the question, 'ISN'T IT TIME YOU CONSIDERED YOUR FUTURE?' The surrounding artwork includes cartoon panels depicting alien abduction scenarios and text snippets like 'DO YOU BELIEVE SPACE ALIENS EVER KIDNAP PEOPLE WITH POWERFUL TRACTOR BEAMS?' and 'STEVE'S BEEN NABBED BY ALIENS!', along with a humorous proposal for a two-mile-square concrete landing pad for UFOs by Tom Weber of Elmwood Village, Wisconsin.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue revolve around UFO sightings, alien encounters, and the organization of community events and publications within the ufology field. The editorial stance appears to be one of active engagement, encouraging reader participation through contributions to journals and attendance at conferences, as well as promoting awareness through media events like Operation Skywatch. There is a clear emphasis on historical aspects of ufology, as highlighted by the Magonia conference, and on the ongoing collection of data, particularly concerning abduction cases.