Swamp Gas Journal - 1985 Volume 3 Number 7 and 8

Magazine Overview

Title: SWAMP GAS JOURNAL
Issue: Volume 3, Numbers 7/8
Date: June/July 1985
Publisher: Chris Rutkowski
Country: Canada
ISSN: 0707-7106

This issue of the Swamp Gas Journal delves into several controversial topics within ufology and paranormal research, featuring critical analyses, comparative studies, and a provocative proposal regarding Halley's Comet.

Editorial: Pebble in the Sky

The editorial, titled "Pebble in the Sky," addresses the author's involvement in a controversy surrounding the Tectonic Strain Theory (TST). The author, while acknowledging the TST is not entirely without merit, expresses concerns about its oversimplification of the universe and the statistical methods used to support it. The piece recounts the author's interactions with researchers like Michael Persinger, Jerry Clark, Brian Brady, and John Derr, highlighting disagreements and the challenges of validating the TST. The author notes that Persinger's work often relies on self-citation and that geophysicists and psychologists have been hesitant to engage with his theories.

Critiques of the Tectonic Strain Theory (TST)

Several articles and references within the journal critically examine Michael Persinger's Tectonic Strain Theory (TST), which posits that geophysical conditions, particularly tectonic strain and electromagnetic activity, can explain UFO phenomena. Chris Rutkowski, in his critique, contends that Persinger's statistical correlations are weak and that the theory fails to account for other variables. He also points out that Persinger's work is often cited by other proponents of the TST, such as Derr and Devereux, creating a closed loop of support.

Paul Devereux, whose work is also referenced, proposes a piezoelectric theory of UFOs related to rock stress, citing Persinger and Brady. However, Rutkowski questions the methodology, particularly when there is no clear one-to-one correspondence between UFO reports and seismic events.

The journal also references Rutkowski's own criticisms of the TST, published in "Perceptual & Motor Skills," and Persinger's subsequent "Reply to Rutkowski." The author notes the difficulty in publishing counter-arguments due to the 'pay-to-publish' nature of some journals, contrasting it with Persinger's ability to publish extensively due to his academic position.

UFO and PSI Parallels

Roy Bauer's article, "UFO and PSI Parallels," draws comparisons between the unexplained phenomena of UFOs and paranormal (PSI) events, such as extrasensory perception (ESP) and psychokinesis (PK). Bauer argues that both fields share similarities, including the apparent defiance of known physical laws, the reliance on anecdotal evidence that is often dismissed by mainstream science, and the difficulty in providing repeatable, scientifically verifiable proof. He notes that UFO evidence often consists of photographs or physical traces, while PSI evidence involves processes rather than objects. Bauer also highlights the common characteristic of influencing matter or gravity, citing examples like levitation and materialization in PSI, and poltergeist activity in UFO-related cases. The article suggests that both UFOs and PSI phenomena point to flaws in our current understanding of reality and that humans may possess undeveloped abilities, such as ESP, to communicate nonverbally.

Stop that Comet

An article from "The Economist" (March 30, 1985) proposes a radical solution to the potential threat posed by Halley's Comet. Titled "Stop that comet," it argues that the comet, which has historically been associated with disasters, must be stopped, preferably by a pre-emptive nuclear strike. The article cites historical instances where Halley's Comet was seen as a harbinger of doom, including its association with the extinction of dinosaurs and the defeat of King Harold in 1066. It also mentions the fear surrounding the comet in 1910, leading to extreme reactions like women boarding themselves in their homes. The author suggests that stopping the comet would not only prevent potential disasters but also provide a psychological boost for arms control talks and offer a real-world "star-wars" experience. The article concludes by urging statesmen to take the first step towards a comet-free future.

The Quantavolution Books

This section introduces Alfred de Grazia's "Quantavolution Series," which explores the idea that catastrophic planetary collisions have shaped Earth's surface and human history. The series challenges the conventional geological timescale, suggesting a much shorter cultural lifetime for humankind. The article promotes the ten-volume series, offering discounts for Canadian readers through Metron Canada.

Other Articles and Sections

Yet Another Controversy: This section discusses an argument regarding the evolution of science fiction literature and fandom, noting a shift from traditional SF to a more "pop"-oriented culture that includes fantasy, gaming, and D&D.

Ufology Today: This section provides brief updates on ufology-related events, including Stanton Friedman's visit to Winnipeg, Michael Persinger's reply to a criticism, and the formation of the Manitoba Mysteries Group.

LoCs: A list of individuals who have contributed letters or reviews to the journal.

Articles Recently Added to the UFOROM Library: A bibliography of recent articles and publications relevant to ufology and paranormal research, including works by Rutkowski, Persinger, Derr, Michaud, Hynek, Hartwell, Bova, Zimmer, Jones, Clark, Bord, and Henker.

Zines Received: A list of recently received fanzines and newsletters related to ufology and paranormal topics.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue revolve around critical examination of UFO theories, particularly the Tectonic Strain Theory, and the exploration of connections between seemingly disparate phenomena like UFOs and paranormal events. The editorial stance appears to be one of skepticism towards unsubstantiated theories, advocating for rigorous scientific testing and a cautious approach to endorsing new ideas. There is a strong emphasis on questioning established narratives and encouraging further research and debate within the ufological community. The inclusion of the "Stop that Comet" article, while provocative, also reflects a willingness to engage with unconventional and even extreme ideas related to potential threats.