Swamp Gas Journal - 1983 Volume 2 Number 9

Magazine Overview

Title: The Swamp Gas Journal
Issue: Volume 2, Number 9
Date: March, 1983
Publisher: Chris Rutkowski
ISSN: 0707-7106

This issue of The Swamp Gas Journal, dated March 1983, presents a collection of articles, reviews, and discussions centered around ufology, cryptozoology, and other paranormal phenomena. The content reflects a period of perceived inactivity in UFO reports, prompting the editor to explore various related topics.

Dim Sum: Epistemology and UFO Theology

The lead article, "Dim Sum," discusses the challenges of ufology, particularly the lack of concrete proof for extraterrestrial intervention. The author recounts giving talks on the "Epistemology of Ufology" and UFO theology. The epistemology talk uses the analogy of believing in Australia to illustrate how belief systems function, noting that while UFOs are not reproducible at will like Australia, this is a major drawback to their scientific credibility. The author also touches upon the similarities between UFO-based religions and traditional philosophies, highlighting their shared tenets against violence and spiritual detachment, and the concept of "space brothers" as a modern interpretation of divine figures.

Two other lectures given by the author are mentioned: one on the UFOs of Manitoba to the Knights of Columbus, and another for Celebration '83 at the University of Manitoba. Both were poorly attended but well-received.

WITS: Sasquatch Discussions

A meeting of the "Winnipeg Independent Thinkers" is described, where attendees discussed UFO sightings, sasquatch, parapsychology, and Indian legends. A significant portion of this section is dedicated to the debate surrounding the reality of sasquatch. Two main viewpoints are presented: one that views sasquatch as a flesh-and-blood, intelligent creature, and another that finds it difficult to reconcile the numerous reports with a physical animal, citing instances of quick disappearances and hiding in sparse vegetation.

The article draws a parallel between the sasquatch and UFO research, noting the "nine-tenths law" (90% of reports are likely garbage) and the difficulty in weeding out credible accounts. The issue of funding for research is also highlighted, comparing it to the struggles of early scientists like Columbus and Edison. The section concludes with a note about the journal being copyrighted by Chris Rutkowski and thanks to Guy Westcott for printing assistance.

Book Reviews

UFO's: A Pictorial History from Antiquity to the Present by David C. Knight

This book is reviewed as an accurate pictorial history that chronologically orders UFO photos. It is described as an excellent introduction to the field, potentially serving as a companion to Jacob's 'UFO Controversy in America'. The text is noted as humorous but not sarcastic, with the author oscillating between pro and con stances. A major flaw identified is the lack of color photographs, though this may have lowered the cost. The reviewer recommends the book.

Article Review: "Geophysical Variables and Behavior: IV. UFO Reports and Fortean Phenomena: Temporal Correlations in the Central UFO" by M. A. Persinger

This review discusses Michael Persinger's research into the effects of geomagnetic and geoelectric forces on the natural environment. His latest paper suggests that increased geophysical strain leads to EM radiation, UFO displays, and "poltergeist-like episodes."

LoCs (Letters of Comment)

This section includes a note of thanks to those who responded to a query about Canadian ufology, with Bonnie Wheeler encouraging persistence. Ritchie Benedict provides a short note and a book review. The editor laments the decline of glossy UFO magazines but notes Saga's 1982 UFO Annual as a good read. Concerns are raised about the use of stock UFO photos, many of which are fakes, in publications. Other ongoing publications mentioned include Britain's Probe, the new OSEAP Journal, Notizaro UFO, and the Journal of UFO Studies.

The Andreasson Affair - Phase Two by Raymond E. Fowler

Reviewed by W. Ritchie Benedict, this book is presented as a continuation of the Andreasson case. The review highlights how such a detailed and fantastic account, which would have been difficult to publish years ago, is now more readily accepted. The book is described as similar to science fiction but is given weight by the author's reputation as an objective investigator. The review details Betty Andreasson's abduction experiences, including the removal of an eyeball and the use of hypnosis to uncover new facts. The reviewer notes similarities to other abduction cases, such as the 1976 Danville, Kentucky incident. The book explores the theological and psychic aspects of the phenomenon, suggesting that understanding it requires delving into the human mind. The reviewer concludes that the book is an excellent addition to ufologist libraries and is highly puzzling.

Manlike Monsters on Trial (Edited by M. Halpin & M. Ames)

Reviewed by the editor, this book is described as a landmark in cryptozoology, stemming from a conference on sasquatch. It is a collection of papers covering sociological, zoological, and biological aspects of the sasquatch. The book is divided into three parts: belief and interpretation, historical and legendary aspects, and rigorous scientific articles. The review quotes co-editor Michael Ames, who states that evidence for sasquatch is scattered and mythological, leading to epistemological debates. The reviewer agrees that physical evidence is largely absent, comparing the situation to ufology. The book includes a comprehensive bibliography.

Reading Matter: Psychic Fair and Article Review

Psychic Fair in Winnipeg

The editor attended a large Psychic Fair in Winnipeg, noting the sociological aspect of forteana. Despite some initial expectations, the fair was described as having few displays and no huckster tables. Activities included iridology, healing, reflexology, and astrology. The attendees were predominantly female, with a wide age range. A significant lack of skepticism was observed among attendees.

Article Review: "Magnetism and the Standing Stones" by C. Brooker

This review discusses an article in New Scientist that suggests ley lines and dowsing have a basis in fact. The article, by a BBC engineer, compares magnetometer readings with a psychic's impressions of forces at a megalithic ring, finding a "perfect correlation" and detecting magnetic gradients. The author also detected ley lines with his magnetometer, forming a "Stone Age Faraday cage." The reviewer notes the lack of calibration details and the author's admission of not knowing how to use a magnetometer prior to the experiment.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are the challenges of proving paranormal phenomena, the role of belief versus evidence, and the interdisciplinary nature of research in ufology and cryptozoology. The editorial stance appears to be one of open inquiry, acknowledging the limitations of current scientific understanding while critically examining the evidence presented in various reports and publications. There is a clear interest in the sociological and psychological aspects of belief in the paranormal, as well as a desire to apply scientific methods where possible, even when dealing with unconventional subjects.