SPI Enigmas - no 40

Magazine Overview

Title: ENIGMAS
Subtitle: THE JOURNAL OF STRANGE PHENOMENA INVESTIGATIONS
Issue: 40
Date: May-June 1995
Price: £2.00
Editor: Malcolm Robinson

Editorial

The editorial for this issue, dated May-June 1995, highlights a strong focus on UFOs. Editor Malcolm Robinson addresses the ongoing debate and skepticism surrounding the Bonnybridge UFO 'window area' in Scotland. He expresses a desire to put the matter to rest after this issue, stating that no further correspondence or discussions will be entered into regarding the 'murmurings' of skeptics. Robinson also mentions recent contact from Caledonia Television regarding the possibility of producing a 'docu-drama' on Scotland's famous poltergeist case from 1960, which he believes could be invaluable in showing the public what these phenomena are truly about. He recounts SPI's February skywatch at the scene of a UFO abduction in West Lothian, noting the challenging weather conditions. Robinson also touches upon the frequent requests he receives to write a book on UFOlogy in Scotland, particularly the Bonnybridge saga, but cites a lack of time due to his work, family, and SPI commitments. He expresses hope that the next issue will not be late, as he anticipates a potential house move.

SPI Visit Edinburgh Airport

This report details a visit by SPI members to Edinburgh Airport to investigate UFO sightings. The purpose was to clarify whether observed phenomena were indeed aircraft or helicopters, thereby eliminating mundane explanations. SPI had been frequently contacting airports due to the high volume of UFO reports in Stirlingshire Central Scotland. Edinburgh Airport suggested a face-to-face meeting, leading to a visit by Stan Brown, Garry Wood, Helen Walters, and the editor. A gentleman in the control tower, whose name was not to be divulged, answered questions with conviction. The visit confirmed a high amount of air traffic in the region and revealed that while Air Traffic Control generally had explanations for reported UFO sightings, they had not personally encountered any.

SPI Assist T.V. Show

This article describes how SPI assisted Anglia Television with their show 'The Time And The Place,' which was seeking information on ghost sightings. The editor contacted individuals who had witnessed ghosts, and several agreed to appear on the show. The report details the experience of attending the Scottish Television Studios in Glasgow, meeting other researchers, and witnessing the filming. It recounts Patricia and Derek Canavan sharing their experiences with ghosts in their Kilsyth home. Professor Max Hammerton offered a psychological perspective, while Professor Archie Roy firmly stated that ghostly manifestations are real and not tricks of the mind.

Strange and Unknown

This section features personal accounts of unusual experiences. The first is from a woman who claims to be a spiritual medium and recounts encounters with 'three little space beings' and a dream about Wellington, New Zealand, depicting a city hit by a bomb. She also describes seeing a mothership with smaller craft and experiencing a 'throbbing vibration noise' and sulphur smell. The second account is from Tracey Walsh, who describes experiencing an 'incubus' phenomenon, involving paralysis and a sense of presence, which she initially dismissed as nightmares until reading a book by Jenny Randles and Peter Hough.

UFO Talks Bid Blocked

This news item reports that the Ministry of Defence (MoD) refused to meet with local councillor Billy Buchanan and UFOlogist Malcolm Robinson to discuss UFO sightings over Falkirk District. The MoD stated there was no evidence of defence significance and a meeting would not serve a useful purpose. Councillor Buchanan expressed disappointment, while the MoD suggested sending additional information. SPI is continuing its petition to urge the British Government to acknowledge the UFO sightings in Central Scotland.

Billy's unidentified flying 'circus'

This section delves into the controversy surrounding the Bonnybridge UFO sightings and Councillor Billy Buchanan's involvement. Two Scottish UFOlogists, Ken Higgins and Ron Halliday, are quoted as criticizing Buchanan's handling of the situation, calling it a 'circus' and a publicity stunt. Halliday suggested that some sightings might be explained by a Scottish Power helicopter. Councillor Buchanan denied using the sightings for publicity, stating he was acting as a buffer for his constituents. Malcolm Robinson of SPI defended Buchanan, emphasizing that SPI tackled the sightings professionally and that Halliday was making sweeping statements without full knowledge. Robinson also noted that SPI's checks confirmed no Scottish Power helicopters were in the area during the relevant times.

Puzzling events

This letter to the editor, from Malcolm Robinson, defends Councillor Billy Buchanan against Ron Halliday's accusations of turning Bonnybridge UFO sightings into a 'circus' and a publicity stunt. Robinson states that Halliday has never met or spoken with Buchanan and has no firsthand knowledge of the situation. He highlights that over 200 people attended a lecture on the sightings and many witnesses have come forward, emphasizing SPI's professional approach.

Courageous councillor

This letter commends Councillor Billy Buchanan for his courage in addressing his constituents' UFO sighting reports and assisting SPI with research. It also mentions his hospitality to a Japanese TV crew filming a world UFO documentary. The writer praises Buchanan for acting in the interests of his constituents, despite facing criticism and 'mickey taking' from fellow councillors.

Response by the Editor to Jenny Randles' Letter

Malcolm Robinson responds to Jenny Randles' letter regarding the book 'STRANGE BUT TRUE?' and the Bonnybridge UFO chapter. He clarifies that he did not infer that Jenny or Peter Hough 'harrassed' Bob Taylor, but was referring to journalists. Robinson addresses the 'window area' concept, stating that such areas must start somewhere and that SPI is researching the historical background of sightings in Bonnybridge, with evidence suggesting reports go back to 1982. He defends the establishment of UFO hotlines as a means to gauge activity. Robinson also clarifies that SPI never claimed Bonnybridge was the 'biggest' UFO 'window area' but rather a 'window area,' a distinction he feels the press has blurred. He agrees with many points in Randles' letter and aims to clear up misconceptions about the Bonnybridge issue.

Have you seen lights in the sky?

This letter to the editor, from Malcolm Robinson, seeks information from elderly residents of Bonnybridge and Falkirk regarding any UFO sightings they may recall from their childhoods, specifically in the 1930s, 40s, and 50s. The aim is to gauge how far back these sightings have gone and to aid his research. All letters will be treated in confidence.

Recommended books

This section reviews several books:

• INCEPTION by W.A. Harbinson: Described as a fascinating terrestrial explanation for UFOs, interweaving fiction with historical fact. The reviewer, Marina Jones, found it compelling.
• GUIDELINES FOR TESTING PSYCHIC CLAIMANTS by Richard Wiseman & Robert L. Morris: This booklet provides methods for identifying genuine psychics and advises researchers to consult magicians. The reviewer, Malcolm Robinson, recommends it as a valuable tool for serious researchers.
• MARY'S MESSAGE TO THE WORLD by Annie Kirkwood: This book centers on Annie Kirkwood's alleged messages from the Virgin Mary about future global events, including volcanic activity, earthquakes, and UFO sightings. The reviewer, Malcolm Robinson, finds it fascinating but notes it relies on channeling.
• STAR CHILDREN by Jenny Randles: This book explores the concept of 'Star Children' who feel they don't belong on Earth. It discusses UFO sightings, alien encounters, and the possibility of human-alien interbreeding. The reviewer, Malcolm Robinson, praises the book's insights into alien environments and recommends it.
• THE COMPLETE BOOK OF UFOS by Jenny Randles and Peter Hough: This is a paperback version of a previously reviewed book, detailing new research into unexplained phenomena, major UFO cases, and government investigations.

Magazine Review

This section reviews the magazine ANNALS, No. 24, April/June 1995. The review notes the change in format to a larger A4 size and praises the editor, Gerry Lovell, for his use of desktop publishing. Articles mentioned include Bob Lazar's UFO knowledge, Near Death Experiences and UFO abductions, and Contactees And Spontaneous Invisibility. Subscription details are provided.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue of ENIGMAS are UFOs, particularly the Bonnybridge phenomenon, and psychic phenomena. The editorial stance, as expressed by Malcolm Robinson, is one of open-minded investigation, seeking evidence, and informing the public. While acknowledging the need for scientific rigor and addressing skepticism, the magazine appears to lean towards validating the reality of these phenomena. There is a clear emphasis on collecting witness accounts and conducting research, even while acknowledging the role of media and public perception in shaping narratives around these events. The magazine also promotes a collaborative approach among researchers, urging them to work together rather than against each other.

This issue of ENIGMAS magazine, dated May-June 1995, delves into a variety of paranormal and unexplained phenomena, with a significant focus on UFO sightings and encounters. The magazine presents a mix of investigative reports, personal testimonies, and reviews of relevant books and videos, aiming to inform and engage readers interested in these subjects.

Book Reviews

Two books are reviewed: "UFO The Complete Sightings Catalogue" by Peter Brookesmith, published by Blandford Press, is described as an ideal introduction for novices and a useful reference for enthusiasts, covering a wide range of topics from ancient folklore to modern abductions. Despite some photographic fakes, it is recommended as a starting point. "Doomsday 1999 AD" by Charles Berlitz, published by Souvenir Press, is presented as a book that suggests humanity has the power to avert future disasters, drawing on prophecies and scientific warnings.

Video Reviews

"The Science of Eternity" is reviewed, focusing on the work of Michael Roll and his research into life after death and reincarnation. The review highlights Ron Pearson's theories on explaining paranormal phenomena through physics and mentions interviews with Tom Harrison, who claims to have witnessed over 1,500 materializations, and Gwen Byrne, whose son communicated after his death. The video is recommended for those with open minds.

"The Pleiades Legacy" is reviewed with significant criticism for its production quality, described as a "mess" with disconnected visuals and a "somnambulistic voice." While acknowledging the theory of ancient alien visitation, the reviewer found the presentation boring and difficult to follow, suggesting a multi-viewing approach.

Witness Testimonies and Investigations

The issue features several detailed accounts of UFO sightings:

• Steven Rutherford's Statement (Case 1, Paxton South Mains, Near Allanton, Berwickshire): Rutherford describes seeing a white light moving slowly across fields, which later stopped and illuminated the ground with spotlights. The object then moved away at considerable altitude.

• George Niedzwiedz's Statement: Niedzwiedz recounts seeing a black object that turned bright red, moving very fast and quietly over the River Tweed. He notes the object was about the size of a Ford Sierra and caused a wave in the water. He also mentions a triangular object with bright lights seen over Craigwalls Farm.

• Dr. D. Johnson's Statement: Dr. Johnson, a medical practitioner, reports multiple UFO sightings from Seahouses. A specific sighting on November 28, 1994, involved two objects, one of which was blurred and appeared to rotate, bearing similarities to space exploration equipment. His wife also reported seeing stationary silver objects.

• Larbert UFO Shot Down - UFO Really a Plane!: This section details an alleged UFO sighting by the Rogers family in Larbert, Scotland, filmed on video. Independent tests by Dr. T.J. Moir and Mr. C. Smith from the University of Paisley, and Jeff Sainio from MUFON, concluded that the object was likely an aircraft, possibly a private one, with the appearance of a cylinder due to misfocused wing and landing lights.

• Henry Gray (Duns/Chirnside Road A6105, 1983): Gray describes seeing a bright light in the sky, which resolved into a three-storey high grey object with bright lights, observed for 30 minutes before vanishing.

• Fireside Tales (but true)! - TERRIFIED BY UFO: A personal account from Diane McKenna describes seeing a massive UFO with a row of lights hovering near her home in Abingdon, England, on October 15, 1992. She also reports seeing nine lights moving fast over Oxford City. The UFO moved closer to her house before ascending rapidly. She also recounts a brief sighting of a figure with a pointed head.

Letters to the Editor

• Andrew Collins thanks the magazine for a review of "Alien Energy" and discusses the Bob Taylor trouser case, noting a similarity between alleged physical traces and animal hoof imprints.

• Mrs C. Hutchison shares her experience as a Spiritualist medium for 25 years, suggesting that sightings of lights and balls of fire might indicate something waiting to make contact.

• Mrs G. Caston recounts a childhood experience in Reading where she and a group of friends saw two round, hazy lights moving rapidly across the sky.

• A Weekly News Reader from Glasgow comments on the prevalence of strange sightings, linking them to biblical prophecies of signs and wonders in the last days.

Other Features

• SPI Statement to Members: This statement announces that SPI is dropping plans to set up a new committee and will be solely run by Malcolm Robinson and Billy Devlin. They emphasize that SPI is continuing its aims of seeking answers to UFO and paranormal questions.

• 8th International UFO Congress: Information is provided about an upcoming congress in Sheffield, featuring speakers from various countries and a screening of the Roswell UFO crash film.

• Magazine Reviews: Several other magazines are reviewed, including "Dead of Night No 4," "Space Poltergeist," "World UFO Journal," "Skylink," "Paranormal Investigations Newsletter," "Ghost Trackers Newsletter," "Ghostwatch," "Contact Forum," "Fortean Times," "Nessletter," "Animals and Men," "Annals," "UFO Times," "The Psi Report," "Spectral," "3rd Stone," "The Skeptic," "Southampton UFO Group Newsletter," "Promises & Disappointments," "The Steady Signal," "The UFO Debate," "The UFO Reporter," and "The Noah's Ark Society Newsletter." These reviews cover a range of topics from UFOs and ghosts to cryptids and spiritualism.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are UFO sightings, the nature of reality concerning life after death and reincarnation, and the investigation of paranormal phenomena. The magazine appears to maintain an open-minded yet critical stance, presenting witness accounts and expert analyses, while also acknowledging the possibility of misidentification or hoaxes. The editorial stance encourages readers to explore these subjects with an open mind and to engage in critical thinking, as evidenced by the detailed reviews and the inclusion of both believers and skeptics' viewpoints. The emphasis on ongoing research and the pursuit of answers to unexplained questions is a consistent thread throughout the publication.

Title: ENIGMAS
Issue: MAY-JUNE 1995
Volume: 40-41
Publisher: SPI
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English

This issue of ENIGMAS magazine, published by SPI, focuses on UFO and paranormal research, featuring several case reports from Scotland and an update on the controversial Roswell film acquisition.

The Santilli Roswell Film

The issue begins with a report on Ray Santilli, managing director of the Merlin Group, who claims to have purchased alleged film footage of the UFO crash at Roswell, New Mexico, in 1947. Santilli states that a veteran cameraman, previously employed by the U.S. military, was tasked with filming the crash and later provided him with 14 canisters of 16mm black and white film, approximately 7 minutes each, without sound. Santilli is attempting to authenticate the film and plans to go public. BUFORA (British UFO Research Association) is not yet in a position to authenticate or dispute these claims, though two officers have viewed some footage. BUFORA plans to offer photographic analysis by trained specialists.

S.P.I. Case Research Work

The magazine then details several case reports investigated by SPI:

Case 1: Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland

Date: 11th March 1995, 8:50pm
Witness: Mary Roy

Mary Roy reported seeing a brilliant light in the sky, followed by another object that appeared straight ahead. This object had a line of coloured lights that flicked forward, resembling Christmas tree lights. One object moved at great speed to hover over Westerglen Transmitting Station, with another object joining it. They then moved back towards the transmitters, and subsequently moved to the right, one ahead of the other. They then took off at great speed and disappeared. Her grandson also witnessed the event. The Falkirk Herald persuaded her to contact SPI.

Investigation: Standard UFO research procedures were followed, including contacting airports, police, and Met Stations, but no definitive answer has surfaced.

Case 2: Boness, West Lothian, Scotland

Date: 30th October 1994, 6:25pm
Witness: Stan Pearce

Stan Pearce observed a large circular object with red lights, positioned approximately 200ft from the ground and slightly South/West. The object remained stationary for about two minutes before gradually fading and disappearing into a mist. Following this, a smaller object appeared from where the circular object had been and moved off towards the golf course, then eastward, returning multiple times at approximately 40mph. Pearce shone a powerful light at the craft, and on its second pass, it stopped and emitted a sharp, gritty light that lasted for a minute. He then used a telescope to observe it.

Investigation: Letters were sent to Scottish Airports, Police, and the British Ministry of Defence. SPI is also investigating potential helicopter activity from the B.P. Chemical plant.

Case 3: Dornoch, Sutherland, Scotland

Date: Summer 1993 (exact month unsure), 3:00pm
Witness: Daphne Flowers

Daphne Flowers saw a large triangle hovering silently over the water. It was described as very bright silver, like highly polished silver. She watched it for about a minute and regretted not trying to take a photograph. A few days later, she overheard a man on Moray Firth Radio discussing multiple sightings of a UFO over the North-East of Scotland on the same day she saw it.

Investigation: Phone calls and letters to various agencies have yielded little explanation. SPI is closely monitoring reports of triangular-shaped objects due to a perceived rise in such sightings.

Case 4: Polmont Reservoir, Stirlingshire, Scotland

Date: 12th November 1991, 9:30pm
Witness: Peter Muir

While photographing the B.P. Chemicals Plant, Peter Muir and a friend noticed two dim flashing lights near pylons at Kincardine Bridge. They initially thought it was a helicopter. The object flew slowly towards Grangemouth Stadium and hovered for about five minutes. They then noticed it was silent, unlike a helicopter. The craft turned to face them, was roughly 2000ft above the ground, and then dipped and increased speed dramatically. At the point of photograph, it was about 200-300ft directly above, emitting a 'pulsing' hum. Muir's friend was shaken but excited. Muir later destroyed the negative of the photograph, though he now regrets it.

Investigation: SPI has contacted Scottish Airports to inquire about aircraft or helicopter activity and the Falkirk Police regarding similar UFO reports. They have also written to the British Ministry of Defence and the B.P. Chemical plant. The photograph itself, taken with a Halina 35mm camera, shows a circular object with a concave centre and bright white lights creating a halo effect. SPI notes that the destruction of the negative makes the authenticity questionable.

News Desk

This section provides various updates and announcements:

• Videos for Sale: Information on purchasing 'The Science Of Eternity' and 'The Pleiades Legacy' videos.
• First International Conference of Spirit: Scheduled for June 24th-25th, 1995, in Glasgow, featuring speakers on the science, philosophy, and religion of spirit.
• Seminar in Scotland?: Alf Winchester of the Noah's Ark Society is keen to stage a seminar in Scotland, potentially including spirit survival demonstrations.
• ENIGMAS Price Increase: The magazine's price will increase to £15.00 per year, which includes SPI Membership.
• SPI Busy with Media: SPI has been actively engaged with the press, television, and radio, including assistance with Anglia Television, BBC Radio 4, The Weekly News, The Scotsman, and The Daily Record.
• Quest International Conference in Scotland: Talks are underway with Graham Birdsall of UFO MAGAZINE to stage a conference in Falkirk Town Hall, possibly on January 6th, 1996. Quest members have also conducted sky-watches in Bonnybridge.
• SPI Case Reports: SPI plans to present findings from their research work.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are UFO sightings and investigations, particularly focusing on cases within Scotland. The magazine highlights witness testimonies and the efforts of research organizations like SPI to gather and analyze evidence. There is a clear interest in unexplained aerial phenomena, with a willingness to explore controversial claims, such as the Roswell film. The editorial stance appears to be one of open inquiry, presenting cases and investigations while acknowledging the need for authentication and the possibility of misidentification or fraud. The magazine also promotes paranormal events and research, indicating a broader interest in unexplained phenomena beyond UFOs.