Magazine Summary
SearchLites
Summary
The Summer 1999 issue of SearchLites highlights Noel Cedric Welstead as the recipient of the 1999 Bruno Award for his contributions to amateur radio astronomy in Australia. Dr. H. Paul Shuch, 'Dr. SETI', visited Vancouver to promote a new exhibit on extraterrestrial life. The issue also includes an editorial questioning if dinosaurs could have achieved space travel, an article on the standards of proof for detecting ETI, and a discussion on the challenges of satellite interference for radio astronomy. Software for the Project Argus Observatory System is detailed, along with a review of internal vs. external SETI receivers and a guide to building a quad-helix antenna.
Magazine Overview
SearchLites, Volume 5, Number 3, Summer 1999, is the quarterly journal of The SETI League, Inc. This issue focuses on the 1999 Bruno Award winner, Dr. SETI's activities in Vancouver, and various technical and philosophical aspects of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence.
1999 Bruno Award Winner
The issue introduces Noel Cedric Welstead of Australia as the recipient of the 1999 Bruno Award. Welstead is recognized for his pioneering work in amateur radio astronomy, including building the first amateur SETI observatory in Australia and leading efforts to trace "wigglers" to computer-generated radio frequency interference. He also founded the SETI Research and Community Development Institute and secured a donation of a sixty-foot radio telescope for amateur use. The Bruno Award is named in memory of Giordano Bruno, who was burned at the stake in 1600 for postulating the multiplicity of inhabited worlds.
Dr. SETI Visits Vancouver
Dr. H. Paul Shuch, Executive Director of The SETI League, known as Dr. SETI, visited Vancouver, British Columbia, to help launch a new exhibit at Science World titled "The Why Files." His presentation, "Searching for Life Among the Stars," coincided with the exhibit's opening. A regional SETI League meeting was also held, and Dr. Shuch was available for press interviews.
Guest Editorial: Might Dinosaurs Have Achieved Space Travel?
Bruce Cornet, Ph.D., an evolutionary biologist, explores the possibility of dinosaurs evolving into space-faring civilizations. He discusses the evidence for avian/dinosaurian connections and speculates that limitations imposed by specialization for flight might have hindered brain development and tool use in dinosaurs, preventing them from achieving higher intelligence and space exploration.
Standards of Proof for the Detection of Extra-Terrestrial Intelligence
Dr. H. Paul Shuch addresses the need for rigorous signal verification protocols in SETI, especially with the rise of nonprofessional participation. He discusses the balance between avoiding false negatives and the negative impact of false positives, the potential for hoaxes, and the importance of a prompt yet measured response to claims of ETI contact. The article concludes by emphasizing the "inter-ocular trauma test" for proof, suggesting that multiple, internally consistent observations by independent groups are crucial for public acceptance.
SETI Today
David Little's article provides an overview of the Search for Extra-Terrestrial Intelligence (SETI), its history, and current projects. It highlights The SETI League's grassroots approach of building a global network of amateur radio telescopes and its goal of an all-sky survey. The SETI@home project, which utilizes distributed computing power from personal computers, is also discussed as a significant advancement in signal detection.
Software Page: Project Argus Observatory Operating System
This section details the PAOOS (Project Argus Observatory Operating System) software, developed by Brian Adam and R.J. Fear. PAOOS is a Windows 95/98/NT program designed for data collection and submission from Argus Antenna Network sites. It operates in two modes: Configuration Mode for setting up modules and connections, and Run Mode for data collection and display. The article lists the modules included in the first release of PAOOS and notes that the software is undergoing testing and will be distributed free to registered Project Argus stations.
Hardware Page: SETI Receivers: Internal or External?
Milan Hudecek of WINRADIO Communications discusses the advantages and disadvantages of internal versus external PC-based VHF/UHF receivers for SETI. He concludes that practical differences in susceptibility to PC-generated noise are minimal, and the overall system details, including earthing, power supply filtering, and antenna placement, are more critical. Recommendations are made for good RF engineering practices and the use of linear power supplies for external receivers.
Hardware Page: A Quad-Helix Antenna For Hydrogen Line SETI
William H. Black describes the construction and specifications of a quad-helix antenna for SETI research, particularly for the hydrogen line at 1420 MHz. He notes its realistic and formidable possibility for observers with space or covenant restrictions, offering a gain of around 24 dB. The antenna elements can be purchased separately or as a pre-built quad.
Hardware Page: Disabling AGC in the Icom R-7000
Randy Stegemeyer provides a technical guide on how to disable the Automatic Gain Control (AGC) circuit in an Icom R-7000 receiver to maximize sensitivity for SETI applications. The modification involves cutting a specific resistor on the IF board.
A SETI Dialog
This section features a Q&A between Professor Ian Morison and Dr. H. Paul Shuch. They discuss the belief in intelligent life, the chances of discovery, the potential impact of such a discovery on humankind, and the detectability of ETI signals, including radio pollution from Earth. Dr. Shuch explains The SETI League's strategy of building a global network of amateur radio telescopes, contrasting it with targeted searches by larger projects. He emphasizes the importance of SETI research as a continuation of humanity's quest for knowledge.
Event Horizon
A calendar of upcoming SETI League participation and related events is listed, spanning from May 1999 to September 2001, including hamventions, conferences, and astronomy meetings.
Ask Dr. SETI®
In this Q&A segment, Dr. SETI addresses two reader questions. The first, from Rolando in Peru, inquires about the impact of Motorola's Iridium satellite constellation on amateur radio astronomy, particularly concerning the hydroxyl radical line. Dr. Shuch explains that while Iridium does not violate ITU allocations, adjacent-channel interference is possible, and an agreement with the European Science Foundation (ESF) provides protection for European astronomers, but similar protection for the rest of the world is uncertain. He notes that while Iridium might be tolerable for Project Argus, future PCS constellations could worsen the situation. The second question, from Gary in Ohio, asks for advice on finding a compatible partner interested in SETI, to which Dr. Shuch suggests joining The SETI League and utilizing its membership channels.
Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance
The recurring themes in this issue revolve around the ongoing search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI), the technological advancements and challenges in radio astronomy, and the role of amateur enthusiasts. The SETI League's editorial stance is clearly in favor of promoting grassroots participation in SETI research, building a distributed network of observatories, and advocating for the protection of radio astronomy frequencies against interference from satellite constellations. The publication also touches upon broader philosophical questions related to humanity's place in the cosmos and the potential implications of discovering alien life.
“When you have ruled out the impossible," Arthur Conan Doyle wrote in the voice of Sherlock Holmes, "whatever remains, no matter how unlikely, must be the truth." Above all else, this truth must pass the inter-ocular trauma test: when the proof we seek is so powerful as to hit us between the eyes, we can no longer deny it.
Key Incidents
Noel Welstead hosted a SETI League wine-and-cheese reception at the 'SETI in the 21st Century' Conference.
Dr. H. Paul Shuch presented 'Searching for Life Among the Stars' to kick off The Why Files exhibit.
A regional SETI League meeting was hosted.
ESF issued a press release regarding an agreement with Iridium LLC for radio astronomy observation time.
Iridium satellites, with downlinks in the 1621.25 to 1626.5 MHz band, became operational, potentially impacting radio astronomy observations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who won the 1999 Bruno Award?
Noel Cedric Welstead, an Australian radio ham and pioneer in amateur search for intelligent life, received the 1999 Bruno Award for his contributions to amateur radio astronomy.
What is the SETI League's strategy for searching for extraterrestrial intelligence?
The SETI League is building a global network of thousands of small, relatively inexpensive amateur radio telescopes to compensate for funding limitations, aiming for an all-sky survey.
How do Iridium satellites affect radio astronomy?
Iridium satellites operate in frequency bands that overlap with radio astronomy observations, potentially causing adjacent-channel interference, though agreements are in place to mitigate this in Europe.
What is the PAOOS software?
PAOOS (Project Argus Observatory Operating System) is a Windows-based program designed for collecting and submitting data from Argus Observatories, with modes for configuration and data collection.
In This Issue
People Mentioned
- Noel Cedric Welstead1999 Bruno Award Winner
- Dr. H. Paul ShuchExecutive Director
- Dr. Sandra EixCurator of The Why Files
- Gillian LundeScience World's Manager for Marketing and Communications
- Bruce CornetPh.D.
- Al AburtoSETI League member
- Dr. Jill TarterProject Phoenix scientist
- Giordano BrunoItalian monk
- Donald TarterSociologist
- Dr. D. Kent CullersPrevious Bruno recipient
- Daniel Boyd FoxPrevious Bruno recipient
- Trevor UnsworthPrevious Bruno recipient
- +8 more
Organisations
- The SETI League, Inc.
- Commonwealth Scientific & Industrial Research Organization (CSIRO)
- American Association for the Advancement of Science
- Science World
- Project Phoenix
- NASA
- University of California, Berkeley
- European Science Foundation (ESF)
- Committee on Radio Astronomy Frequencies (CRAF)
- International Telecommunications Union
- Global Positioning System (GPS)
- WINRADIO Communications
- Olde Antenna Lab
- Icom
- +2 more
Locations
- Australia, Australia
- Eastern Australia, Australia
- University of Western Sydney, Macarthur, Australia
- British Columbia, Canada
- Vancouver BC, Canada
- Spain, Spain
- China, China
- Hawaii, USA
- Kohala Coast, USA
- Peru, Peru
- Europe, Europe
- New England, USA
- Ohio, USA
- Winston-Salem, USA