Magazine Summary
SAUCER SMEAR
Summary
This issue of Saucer Smear focuses on the passing of prominent UFO skeptic Philip Klass, detailing his impact on the field and his adversarial relationship with 'True Believers'. It also covers recent UFO sightings, including a case in Exeter, New Hampshire, and a historical account from California. The publication discusses remote viewing, the controversial figure Ed Dames, and the ongoing debate about the value of print publications versus the internet in disseminating information.
Magazine Overview
Title: SAUCER SMEAR
Issue: Volume 52, No. 8
Date: September 15th, 2005
Publisher: SAUCER & UNEXPLAINED CELESTIAL EVENTS RESEARCH SOCIETY
Type: Official publication of the SAUCER & UNEXPLAINED CELESTIAL EVENTS RESEARCH SOCIETY.
Main Cover Story: Super-Skeptic Phil Klass Moves On
The lead article announces the death of Philip J. Klass at age 85, describing him as the "most outstanding villain" in the flying saucer field. Klass, a senior avionics editor for "Aviation Week", was a co-founder of CSICOP and a prolific writer of anti-UFO material. The article notes that many UFO enthusiasts believed his skepticism was part of a government conspiracy to hide the truth. Klass was known for his relentless digging into negative material on pro-saucer individuals, such as revealing Ed Walters' past legal troubles. Despite their disagreements, the "Smear" editor considered Klass a friend and respected his sincerity, though not his views. Klass was recognized on "Fate Magazine's" list of top ufologists and Paul Kimball's 'Top 10' and 'Bottom 10' lists.
Other Articles and News Briefs
UFO Sightings and Incidents:
- Exeter, New Hampshire Sighting: A Navy veteran reported seeing a large, cigar-shaped object with windows hovering slowly, changing colors, and disappearing. The article questions the witness's anonymity and the lack of other witnesses, though Peter Davenport of the National UFO Reporting Center suggested the object's technology might have made it selectively visible.
- Brush Creek, California Sighting (Part 2): Karl Pflock continues his account of a miner named John Black who reported seeing a flying saucer multiple times in 1953. One incident involved the saucer hovering near a sandbar, emitting a hissing sound, and leaving human-appearing footprints.
- Mysterious Flying Humanoids in Mexico: An article from "C-COM - Classified Communications" discusses recent incidents in Mexico involving human-like creatures seen flying or hovering, concluding that this phenomenon presents a major research challenge.
- Loch Ness Monster: A new ferry service has begun operation on Loch Ness to help tourists search for the legendary beast.
- Unknown Creature in China: A fisherman found a large, dead creature near a sea-wall in Ningbo City, China, described as nearly 12 meters long with orange stripes and a heavy skull. Its identity remains unknown.
- Lajas, Puerto Rico UFO Festival: The town celebrated its designation as "The UFO Capital of Puerto Rico" with its 4th annual flying saucer festival.
Personalities and Investigations:
- Bob Lazar: Lazar, previously featured in "Smear", is now reportedly working on a conversion kit for hydrogen-powered cars, distancing himself from his earlier claims about Element 115 and Area 51.
- Ed Dames: The "Cursed Net" names Ed Dames as "UFO Dirtbag of the Month" for his unfulfilled predictions regarding remote viewing, including finding gold and disabling computers. The article criticizes his appearances on "Coast to Coast AM" with Art Bell.
- George Adamski and the Straith Letter: A discussion about the infamous 'Straith Letter', which was revealed to be a hoax authored by Gray Barker and the "Smear" editor, despite claims by researchers like Tim Good.
- James Randi: The article mentions James Randi's online store selling skeptical books and novelty items. It also touches on his past legal disputes and his "flying pig emblem" and "Randi Emblem". A lady referred to as "Mrs. X" is reportedly writing an authorized biography of Randi.
- Nick Redfern's "Body Snatchers in the Desert" Book: Karl Pflock expresses his disagreement with Redfern's claims and terminates their planned collaboration on a book about the alleged 1948 Aztec saucer crash.
- Wendy Connors and Print vs. Internet: Rick Hilberg defends the importance of print publications like "Smear" for historical research, arguing that the internet, while vast, is often unfiltered and ephemeral, making experienced editors crucial for discerning valuable material.
- Bob Pratt on Brazil's UFO Files: Bob Pratt clarifies that the Brazilian government has not officially opened its UFO files, though some documents from "Operation Prato" have been leaked and are available online. He corrects the spelling of "Gevaerd".
Conference Report:
- National UFO Conference (NUFOC): The 42nd annual conference was held in Hollywood, California. The "Smear" editor presented tales from the ufological past at the Saturday night banquet. The event featured about 18 speakers, but press attendance was low.
Other Mentions:
- Michael Jackson: An article in "Globe" magazine discusses Michael Jackson's belief that he is an alien from a planet called "A Capricious Anomaly in the Sea of Space".
- Robert Anton Wilson: Famed writer Robert Anton Wilson has a cover story in "Metro Santa Cruz". He is noted as the inspiration for J.R. "Bob" Dobbs of the Church of the SubGenius.
Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance
This issue of "Saucer Smear" maintains its critical and skeptical stance towards many UFO claims, exemplified by its extensive coverage of Philip Klass's passing and his role as a debunker. However, the magazine also acknowledges the enduring nature of UFO mysteries and the importance of research, even from a skeptical viewpoint. There's a recurring theme of questioning the authenticity of claims and exposing hoaxes, as seen with the 'Straith Letter' and the critique of Ed Dames. The publication also champions the value of traditional print media in preserving information against the perceived ephemerality of the internet. The editorial stance is one of critical inquiry, a willingness to challenge established narratives (both pro- and anti-UFO), and a dedication to documenting the history of ufology, even if it involves controversial figures and past deceptions.
We rejected this for several reasons, among which I remember: It was a dead calm evening, not a breath of wind. The area for miles around was all but unpopulated hilly pasture land and orchards. The object was rock steady in every position it took, and the spacing of these positions from the object's original location was precisely the same in all cases. There was no flickering or variation in brightness, except for the extreme intensification just before the object's departure. And, of course, there was that very high speed vertical departure, executed without the slightest jitter or hesitation.
Key Incidents
A Navy veteran reported seeing a large cigar-shaped object with windows hovering slowly, changing colors, and then disappearing.
The site of famous sightings that led to John Fuller's book 'Incident at Exeter'.
Miner John Black reported seeing a silvery disk multiple times, including one instance where it hovered near a sandbar, emitted a hissing sound, and left human-appearing footprints.
A flying saucer was seen closely, passing about a quarter mile away, flying low and silently.
A saucer was seen hovering 150 feet away, then sailed rapidly east emitting a hissing sound.
Alleged saucer crash near Aztec.
Operation Prato involved examination of UFO files and photos.
Massive radar detection of UFOs with six jet fighters scrambled to track them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was Philip J. Klass and what was his role in ufology?
Philip J. Klass was a senior avionics editor for "Aviation Week" and a prominent skeptic of UFO phenomena. He was a founder of CSICOP and wrote several anti-UFO books, often seen as a 'villain' by UFO enthusiasts.
What is the significance of the 'Straith Letter' mentioned in the issue?
The 'Straith Letter' was a purported letter from a high State Department official that seemed to support George Adamski's UFO claims in the 1950s. It is revealed that the letter was actually authored by Gray Barker with help from the 'Smear' editor.
What are the main points of contention between print publications and the internet regarding UFO information?
Some argue that print publications have a longer lifespan and are more reliable for historical preservation, while others believe the internet offers immediate access to vast amounts of information, though it can be unfiltered and contain much 'crap'.
What recent UFO sighting is detailed in this issue?
A Navy veteran reported seeing a large, cigar-shaped object with windows hovering slowly and changing colors in Exeter, New Hampshire on July 29th.
In This Issue
People Mentioned
- Philip J. KlassSkeptic, Senior Avionics Editor of "Aviation Week"
- James W. MoseleyEditor and Still Supreme Commander
- Karl T. PflockContributing Editor, Former CIA employee
- James RandiSkeptic, Investigator
- Donald MenzelHarvard professor, author of anti-UFO books
- Ed WaltersGulf Breeze fame
- DavidNavy veteran
- Peter DavenportDirector of the National UFO Reporting Center
- Michael JacksonSinger
- Michael LuckmanNew York publicist
- Bob LazarUfologist
- George KnappInvestigator
- +8 more
Organisations
- SAUCER & UNEXPLAINED CELESTIAL EVENTS RESEARCH SOCIETY
- CSICOP
- Skeptical Inquirer
- National UFO Reporting Center
- UFO-WATCHDOG.COM
- Coast to Coast AM
- Church of the SubGenius
- C-COM - Classified Communications
- NUFOC
- VHI Pocket Books
Locations
- Washington, D.C., USA
- Florida, USA
- Philadelphia, USA
- Exeter, New Hampshire, USA
- Seattle, USA
- New York, USA
- New Mexico, USA
- Gulf Breeze, USA
- Nevada, USA
- Kansas City, Mo., USA
- Mexico, Mexico
- New Jersey, USA
- Bordontown, N.J., USA
- Key West, USA
- +6 more