Magazine Summary
SAUCER SMEAR
Summary
This issue of Saucer Smear delves into the political implications of UFO sightings, questioning if alien presence explains the thawing of US-Soviet relations. It details a feud within the TREAT organization concerning UFO abduction trauma research, highlighting a conflict between Rima Laibow and Budd Hopkins. The magazine also addresses controversies surrounding Bigfoot researcher Erik Beckjord, including accusations of faking evidence and a debate on his character. Additionally, it examines claims about George Adamski's UFO photographs and critiques various UFO reports and researchers, including Eduard Meier and Hal Starr.
Magazine Overview
Title: SAUCER SMEAR
Issue: Volume 36, No. 10
Date: December 10th, 1989
Publisher: SAUCER AND UNEXPLAINED CELESTIAL EVENTS RESEARCH SOCIETY
Editor: James W. Moseley
This issue of SAUCER SMEAR presents a collection of editorials, reports, and letters from various figures in the ufology and paranormal communities. The tone is often skeptical yet engaged, with a focus on controversies, alleged hoaxes, and the personal rivalries within the field.
Crackpot Politically-Oriented Editorial
Editor James W. Moseley muses on the possibility of an alien presence on Earth, suggesting that the dramatic thawing of relations between Russia and the United States might be more than mere political maneuvering. He questions why Russia, which was predicted to collapse for decades, is now cooperating with the US, hinting at an external influence, perhaps from 'Space Bretheren' giving the 'Great Powers' a deadline to 'get-it-together'. He references George Adamski's saying, 'Time Will Tell.'
Miscellaneous Ravings: TREAT Controversy
The newsletter reports on a significant feud within the organization TREAT (Treatment and Rehabilitation of Experienced Anomalous Trauma), which aims to bridge professional psychology with UFO abduction research. The prime mover, New York psychiatrist Rima Laibow, is organizing TREAT II. A conflict has erupted between Laibow and prominent abduction researcher Budd Hopkins, leading to Hopkins and David Jacobs of Temple University being expelled from participation in TREAT II. Hopkins allegedly attempted to get outside funding for the conference canceled in retaliation. Several ufologists, including Ron Westrum, Jerry Clark, and Dick Hall, have withdrawn from TREAT II in protest of the expulsions.
"The Secret Government: The Origin, Identity and Purpose of MJ-12"
SAUCER SMEAR discusses a 30-page document by "Milton William Cooper" that delves into alleged alien bases and genetic experiments. A particularly strange claim attributes the funding of alien-connected and black projects to President Bush, who allegedly helped corner the illegal drug market through Zapata Oil, in conjunction with the CIA. The document asserts that the CIA now controls all the world's illegal drug markets.
Tidbits of Trash
This section includes holiday greetings to non-subscribers and promotes back issues of SAUCER SMEAR and a special Adamski Expose Issue of SAUCER NEWS. It also announces the "First Great UFO/ ET/ Humanoids/ Visitors/ Alien & Abduction Congress" in Trenton, N.J., featuring speakers like Dr. Leo Sprinkle, Charles Hickson, and Dr. James Harder.
More Sleaze from Gulf Breeze
This segment focuses on mysterious circles found in Gulf Breeze, Florida, and their connection to UFO sightings. Mr. Ed of Gulf Breeze is pictured next to a circle discovered on November 15th, which is 7 feet 8 inches in diameter, matching a calculation related to an Adamski photo. The town has also experienced unexplained sonic booms. The article notes that Ed himself is skeptical, considering the possibility of a hoax. It also questions the credentials of Dr. Willy Smith, a 'Visiting Professor' at the University of Valencia, Spain, as checks reveal no such department or professor exists.
Letters to Ye Olde Editor
Alan Abel's Russian Landing Hoax: Famed hoaxter Alan Abel claims responsibility for the alleged Russian landing case of October 10th, describing how Moscow University students, under his direction, created a spoof involving a three-foot-high spaceship model, a 'Twilight Zone' soundtrack, and a dug crater. The hoax was reported by Tass worldwide, and Abel claims he exposed it later, facing threats that led him to return home. He mentions a future hoax planned for East Germany.
Jim Oberg's Skepticism: UFO debunker Jim Oberg is skeptical of Abel's claims but believes the Russian landing case was a hoax, questioning if Abel is trying to hoax the readers.
Don Keating on Beckjord/Francis Case: Ohio Bigfooter Don Keating defends a researcher against accusations related to the Beckjord/Francis case, stating that death threat letters attributed to Beckjord appear phoney. Keating alleges that Mark Francis admitted to typing fake letters and faking Beckjord's signature, with two other Bigfoot researchers from the Pacific Northwest allegedly urging Francis to do so.
Erik Beckjord's Response: Erik Beckjord admits to writing one of the 'death threat' letters, explaining it was a declaration of 'death to the idea of sitting near Freddy' and not a genuine threat, especially since Freddy was allegedly carrying a pistol. He provides a mailing address for copies of his letter.
Betty Hill on UFOs: Contactee Betty Hill addresses Hal Starr, stating his sources are untrustworthy. She asserts that UFOs are seen in her area (known for 25 years) by many people, and they leave the UFOs alone. She mentions scientific testing and media attention, but notes that some investigators' thinking was too 'weird' to be accepted.
Dr. Frank E. Stranges on Record Expungement: Dr. Stranges writes that his alleged arrest record has been completely expunged, indicating court involvement. He expresses interest in attending a forthcoming Miami Beach Convention.
Jim Deardorff on Hal Starr and Eduard Meier: Jim Deardorff comments on Hal Starr's mention of Eduard Meier's alleged time travel experience, suggesting it might have been a put-down. He raises the question of whether UFO intelligences should be called 'ETs' or if they could be from Earth's future. He also references a photo of a wheat circle in England and Eduard Meier's earlier reporting on similar phenomena.
Phil Klass on Ed Walters and Socorro UFO: Phil Klass addresses Ed Walters' letter, clarifying the difference between passing a bad check and forgery. Klass suggests early senility as a possible explanation for Walters' 'flawed memory' regarding his imprisonment for forgery. Klass also dismisses the Socorro UFO sighting reported by Opál Grinder as spurious, referencing a 1977 White Paper.
Jerrold Baker on George Adamski: Jerrold Baker offers a new perspective on George Adamski's UFO photographs, suggesting that the saucer's features, including portholes, might resemble an old army pith helmet. He describes Adamski as not highly intellectual and lacking in simple photographic skills, implying his photos might have been staged.
August C. Roberts on UFO Video: August C. Roberts shares an account of a videotaped UFO sighting where objects scattered and then regrouped. He also describes a 'figure' or 'creature' seen in a bathroom window, which was not found upon investigation.
More Tidbits of Trash
Mike Luckman Fired: Publicist Mike Luckman has been removed as MUFON Section Director for New York City.
Bill English vs. Bill Cooper: An item from "The Pegasus" reports that Bill Cooper has been expelled from an organization for falsely claiming he was shot at by unknown assailants. Bill English is also mentioned as attacking Bill Moore.
Uri Geller Lawsuits: Uri Geller has sued magician James Randi for 45 million pounds, in addition to other lawsuits, aiming to tie Randi up in legal defenses globally.
Floyd Murray: Long-time UFO researcher Floyd Murray is now a Contributing Editor for "Caveat Emptor" Magazine and provides a P.O. Box for correspondence.
Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance
The recurring themes in this issue of SAUCER SMEAR include skepticism towards sensational claims, the exposure of alleged hoaxes, and the exploration of rivalries and controversies within the UFO and paranormal research communities. The editor, James W. Moseley, adopts a critical yet open-minded stance, questioning official narratives and encouraging readers to consider unconventional explanations, while also being diligent in pointing out potential deception and self-promotion within the field. The publication appears to value investigative journalism and the airing of diverse, often conflicting, viewpoints.
The only explanation we have heard mentioned is, 'economic problems within the USSR'. However, American propaganda has told us ever since World War II that Russia was going to collapse momentarily because of its evil Communist ways. Yet it never happened, in spite of our wishful thinking. What is different now??
Key Incidents
A mysterious circle of swirled grass, 7 feet 8 inches in diameter, was discovered in a local park.
Site of some of Mr. Ed's UFO sightings, where a mysterious circle was found.
Dr. Willy Smith listed as Visiting Professor at the University of Valencia.
Dr. Willy Smith listed as Chairman of the Dept. of Astronomy and Physics at the University of Valencia.
George Adamski's famous UFO photographs are re-examined, with the possibility that the saucer's features resemble a pith helmet.
Mark Francis allegedly told Don Keating he intended to type up fake death threat letters to frame Beckjord.
Erik Beckjord admits to writing one of the death threat letters, stating it was not a real threat.
Betty Hill reports seeing and filming UFOs in an area known for such phenomena for approximately 25 years.
Eduard Meier reported on horizontally-growing grass within circles left by a UFO.
A White Paper is published questioning the authenticity of Opál Grinder's UFO sighting report.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is TREAT and what is its purpose?
TREAT stands for Treatment and Rehabilitation of Experienced Anomalous Trauma, and its purpose is to bring professional psychologists and psychiatrists together with abduction researchers to study and treat UFO abduction experiences.
What is the controversy surrounding Erik Beckjord?
Erik Beckjord is accused of arrogance and obnoxious behavior, and there are allegations that he faked death threat letters to frame another researcher, Mark Francis.
What is the new perspective on George Adamski's UFO photographs?
A new perspective suggests that the main body of Adamski's saucer photographs, including the portholes, strongly resembles an old khaki army pith helmet with the top cut away.
What is the latest on Uri Geller's lawsuits?
Uri Geller is suing magician James Randi for 45 million pounds, in addition to other lawsuits, aiming to tie Randi up in legal defenses worldwide.
In This Issue
People Mentioned
- James W. MoseleyEditor and Still Supreme Commander
- Rima LaibowNew York psychiatrist
- Budd HopkinsUFO abduction researcher
- David JacobsTemple University professor
- Ron WestrumUfologist
- Jerry ClarkUfologist
- Dick HallUfologist
- John LearUFO figure
- Bill CooperUFO figure
- Bill EnglishUFO figure
- Milton William CooperAuthor
- George BushPresident and CEO of Zapata Oil
- +8 more
Organisations
- SAUCER AND UNEXPLAINED CELESTIAL EVENTS RESEARCH SOCIETY
- TREAT
- MUFON
- UNINET
- NASA
- CIA
- Zapata Oil
- Temple University
- University of Valencia
- UFO Reporting Center
- NCIC Federal, State, County, City
Locations
- Key West, Fl., USA
- Russia, USSR
- South America
- Las Vegas, USA
- Texas, USA
- Blacksburg, Va., USA
- New York, USA
- East Germany, Germany
- Red Square, USSR
- London, UK
- Sebring, Ohio, USA
- Pacific Northwest, USA
- New Jersey, USA
- Trenton, N.J., USA
- +6 more