Magazine Summary
SAUCER SMEAR
Summary
This issue of Saucer Smear, dated December 15, 1987, focuses heavily on the controversial MJ-12 documents, with multiple contributors debating their authenticity and the possibility of government disinformation. Editor James W. Moseley also touches on back issue sales, the sale of George Van Tassel's Integratron, and a listing of UFO information sources. Other topics include the spelling of 'materiel', the Fund for UFO Research's financial status, the upcoming 1988 National UFO Conference, and the potential author of the MJ-12 documents. Several letters to the editor offer diverse opinions on these subjects, including skepticism towards certain researchers and claims of Bigfoot and Loch Ness Monster sightings.
Magazine Overview
Title: SAUCER SMEAR
Issue: Volume 34, No. 9
Date: December 15th, 1987
Publisher: SAUCER AND UNEXPLAINED CELESTIAL EVENTS RESEARCH SOCIETY
This issue of "Saucer Smear" is a non-scheduled newsletter dedicated to ufological journalism. The editor, James W. Moseley, addresses non-subscribers with a "dreaded 'X'" on their envelope, indicating they will be dropped from the mailing list unless they respond. The newsletter covers a range of topics, from the availability of back issues and the sale of the Integratron to discussions on UFO documentation and personal accounts.
Miscellaneous Ravings
The "Miscellaneous Ravings" section opens with Moseley's holiday greeting and a notice about dropping non-subscribers. He then discusses the availability of 135 back issues of "Smear" for $95 per set or $1.00 each, noting their historical value. The sale of George Van Tassel's Integratron for $150,000 is announced, with contact information for his widow, Dorris. For those with less funds, a $2.00 listing of 58 UFO information sources in Canada, England, Australia, and the USA by ufologist George Fawcett is mentioned.
Moseley also addresses a point raised by Dr. Bruce Maccabee regarding the correct spelling of "materiel" (with an 'E') versus "material" (with an 'A'), noting that this corrects Phil Klass's accusation against Bill Moore. Maccabee's quarterly report for the Fund for UFO Research, Inc. is mentioned, highlighting the high cost of professionally analyzing MJ-12 documents ($3,000), a goal to which the editor has contributed.
NUFOC and MJ-12 Document Authorship
The newsletter reports that the location for the 1988 National UFO Conference (NUFOC) is still unknown, raising doubts about its continuation. A significant piece of news, termed a "hot FLASH," suggests that Col. Wendelle Stevens, currently in an Arizona penal institution, has identified Richard Doty, an Air Force Intelligence officer, as the author of the MJ-12 documents. The newsletter questions why Stevens's information should be believed on this matter when not on others.
Presidential Curses and Skepticism
President Reagan is noted as potentially being the first president in over a century to overcome the "Twenty Year Curse" (presidents dying in office), a pattern that has affected seven U.S. presidents since 1840, including John F. Kennedy.
Letters to the Editor
Several contributors share their views:
- Brian Parks (California): Criticizes the "appalling lack of research or logic" from critics of the MJ-12 matter, dismissing the idea that a covert operation would release material to archives. He uses the term "useful idiots" for some critics.
- Jennings Frederick (Contactee): Responds to Larry Peters regarding Bigfoot, stating it's a real "non-human" entity from prehistory, possibly from extraterrestrial experiments. Frederick asserts the MJ-12 documentation is authentic, regardless of future findings.
- Mike Dennett (Skeptic): Praises the issue, particularly the UMMO affair review and Erik Beckjord's Loch Ness photo.
- Tom Mercatante: Questions Erik Beckjord's luck in finding Nessie or Bigfoot and obtaining great pictures.
- Riley Crabb (New Zealand): Believes the MJ-12 controversy highlights high-level conferences on UFOs in the 1950s. He suggests that if MJ-12 is a government plant, its motive is dissatisfaction with government secrecy. Crabb also recounts a personal experience in the 1970s with Barbara Schutte, who was abducted and given hypnotic suggestion, leading to recurring nightmares.
- Denis Corey (Cowtown/Columbus, Ohio): Concludes that MJ-12 is a hoax after a trip to Southern California. He notes the intricate effort involved and expresses hope that Bill Moore will "go public" soon. Corey also criticizes Erik Beckjord, calling his photos poor and him a "laughing-stock."
- Peter Gersten (CAUS): States that Citizens Against UFO Secrecy (CAUS) continues to pursue truth via FOIA requests. He shares a recent FOIA release titled "German Flying Wings Designed by Horton Brothers," believing it explains the nature and origin of strange objects seen from 1946-1952.
- Leonard Stringfield: Expresses concern over the dispute surrounding the MJ-12 documents, noting that research itself is at stake. While skeptical of surreptitiously released documents, he refrains from making conclusions. He acknowledges the validity of questions raised by Fawcett & Greenwood but urges allowing Moore & associates to respond. Stringfield also raises the omission of the Aztec, N.M. crash case of 1948 from the MJ-12 papers, questioning if it's fiction as Moore contends or an oversight.
- Jerry Clark (CUFOS and FATE): Considers skepticism a rational response to the MJ-12 matter, noting that things too good to be true often are. He believes that while the MJ-12 briefing itself might be a simple matter of document analysis, the broader issue of UFO crashes and retrievals may remain unanswerable. He also mentions information from independent sources suggesting MJ-12 existed and that the Aztec case is not fiction.
Other Articles and Features
- "Off-duty nudity keeps cop off force": A brief report on a California Highway Patrol officer's dismissal for appearing naked at his home windows.
- "Moseley Posts Loss for Quarter, May Sell Operation": A report from The Wall Street Journal about Moseley Holding Corp.'s financial losses and potential sale of its retail brokerage business.
- "Dead man re-elected": A report from New York about Bronx District Attorney Mario Merola being re-elected shortly after his death.
- "The Beckjord File": This section presents images related to Erik Beckjord, including a blow-up of a Loch Ness Monster picture, an anti-Beckjord cartoon, and a mention of his planned "Creature museum." Beckjord claims to be the only person to have photographed Bigfoot and the Loch Ness Monster, though not at the same time.
- "SPACE POTTY": A story about Dr. Leonard Stern reporting the discovery of a fiberglass porta-potty in a Swedish peat bog, allegedly left by aliens 20,000 years ago.
- "In case of a quake, break the toilets!": A brief item from United Press International about earthquake emergency plans.
- "You Can Call the Dead - Collect": An article detailing people who claim to be able to telephone the dead, sometimes collect, with anecdotes about advice received from deceased individuals.
- "It's time to shine for Moseley": A byline for David Ramsey, Staff Writer.
- "FAA rules out alcohol, drug abuse as cause of a close encounter": A brief mention of a ruling by the Federal Aviation Administration.
Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance
The recurring themes in this issue are the ongoing debate surrounding the MJ-12 documents, the credibility of UFO researchers, and the nature of disinformation within the UFO community. The editorial stance, as expressed through Moseley's "Miscellaneous Ravings" and the selection of letters, appears to be one of open discussion, presenting various viewpoints from skeptics, believers, and researchers, while also maintaining a critical eye on claims and evidence. There is a clear emphasis on the historical value of UFO literature and a desire to track down the truth behind alleged UFO phenomena, even while acknowledging the possibility of hoaxes and deception.
I am so convinced that the Roswell crashed saucer story is true, that I was too eager to believe in the MJ-12 papers and not as cautious as I should have been. Everyone goofs (except Phil Klass).
Key Incidents
Alleged crash of an extraterrestrial craft, disputed by some as a government project aerial device.
A UFO crash case that is debated, with some questioning its validity and omission from MJ-12 papers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the status of the MJ-12 documents according to this issue?
The MJ-12 documents are a subject of intense debate, with many contributors expressing skepticism and suggesting they may be fakes or part of a disinformation program. Some believe they are authentic, while others are reserving judgment pending further investigation.
What is being offered for sale in this issue?
Complete sets of back issues of 'Smear' are available for $95, and individual issues for $1.00. Additionally, George Van Tassel's Integratron is for sale for $150,000.
Who is identified as a potential author of the MJ-12 documents?
According to a 'hot FLASH' based on 'Good Authority', Col. Wendelle Stevens reportedly wrote in a letter that Richard Doty, an Air Force Intelligence officer, is the author of the MJ-12 documents.
What is the 'Twenty Year Curse' mentioned in the issue?
The 'Twenty Year Curse' refers to a pattern where U.S. presidents have died in office, starting in 1840. President Reagan is noted as potentially being the first president in over a century to beat this curse if he completes his second term.
In This Issue
People Mentioned
- James W. MoseleyEditor and Supreme Commander
- George Van Tassel
- DorrisGeorge's widow
- George Fawcettufologist
- Dr. Bruce Maccabee
- Phil Klass
- William Moore
- Col. Wendelle Stevens
- Richard DotyAir Force Intelligence officer
- President ReaganPresident
- John F. KennedyPresident
- Brian Parks
- +8 more
Organisations
- SAUCER AND UNEXPLAINED CELESTIAL EVENTS RESEARCH SOCIETY
- Ministry of Universal Wisdom
- Fund for UFO Research, Inc.
- CAUS
- Citizens Against UFO Secrecy
- CSICOP
- CUFOS
- FATE
- Bay Area Skeptics
- FAA
- The Wall Street Journal
- United Press International
- The Cryptozoology Museum
Locations
- California, USA
- Barstow, USA
- Canada, Canada
- England, UK
- Australia, Australia
- USA, USA
- Lincointon, USA
- New Jersey, USA
- Arizona, USA
- Southern California, USA
- Columbus, USA
- Ohio, USA
- New Mexico, USA
- Sandia, USA
- +6 more