REALL News - Vol 02 No 11 - 1994

Magazine Overview

The REALL News, Volume 2, Number 11, published in November 1994, is the official newsletter of the Rational Examination Association of Lincoln Land (REALL). It serves as a platform for critical examination of paranormal claims, media coverage, and pseudoscientific phenomena from a skeptical viewpoint. The organization's primary geographic region of coverage is central Illinois.

From the Editor: Bob Ladendorf

Bob Ladendorf, the newsletter editor, introduces a new three-part series titled "A Look into the Sun -- and Other Tabloids." He challenges the monolithic view that all tabloids are alike, stating that while some focus on gossip, others delve into paranormal and pseudoscientific content. Part 1 of the series analyzes the content of various tabloids, highlighting significant differences in their focus. Ladendorf also mentions that David Bloomberg's "REALLity Check" column will continue to provide media commentary.

From the Chairman: David Bloomberg

David Bloomberg, the chairman, reflects on a busy month and recaps recent REALL activities. He mentions a successful meeting at Shakey's and an upcoming meeting featuring a Skeptics Society video on the psychology of psychics. He also recounts an engaging experience meeting with comedy-magicians and skeptics Penn & Teller, which provided an opportunity to reach a wider audience. Bloomberg also reminds members about book orders, offering a discount and reduced shipping.

A Look into the Sun -- and Other Tabloids (Part 1 -- Difference in Content) by Bob Ladendorf

This article begins a three-part series investigating tabloid journalism. Ladendorf examines the content of five prominent weekly tabloids (National Enquirer, Star, Globe, Sun, and Weekly World News) collected in August 1994, December 1993, and November 1993. He notes that while some tabloids, like the National Enquirer and Star, focus heavily on celebrity gossip, others, such as The Sun and Weekly World News, feature more articles on odd events and paranormal/pseudoscientific topics. The article presents a table categorizing articles into: Celebrities, Odd/Real Events, Paranormal/Pseudoscientific, Health, Governmental/Scientific Studies, and Miscellaneous. Ladendorf argues that understanding these differences is crucial for any focused criticism of tabloid content, particularly regarding paranormal claims. Part 2 of the series will focus on The Sun and Weekly World News.

REALLity Check by David Bloomberg

The Future of Politics, Part II

David Bloomberg reports on the outcome of Ellen Schanzle-Haskins' bid for the Illinois State Senate, which she lost. He notes that a fund-raiser for her campaign featured 'Noted Parapsychologist' Greta Alexander, but Alexander did not predict Schanzle-Haskins' win. Bloomberg recounts a conversation with Schanzle-Haskins where she stated Alexander made only general predictions, which were trivial and predictable. He questions whether Alexander's inability to foresee this outcome will be addressed in future media appearances.

The New Fall Season, Part II

Bloomberg discusses the surge of paranormal-related programming on television, referencing an article in TV Guide. He critiques shows like "Sightings" and "Encounters," pointing out perceived flaws in their investigative reporting and the lack of balanced perspectives. He specifically mentions the show featuring Dr. Richard Boylan, an abduction expert who believes he is targeted by government hit teams. Bloomberg also notes that while some articles address skeptics, their views are often dismissed, highlighting the common argument that the sheer number of people claiming experiences makes it a legitimate area of inquiry.

Mary, Mary, Everywhere, and Not a Drop of Proof

This section discusses the phenomenon of Virgin Mary sightings reported in various media outlets. The sightings, often occurring at Rosa Lopez's home in Florida, are presented as a significant event by some. However, the article notes that the Roman Catholic Church is not convinced of the miraculous nature of these events. Skeptic Joe Nickell is quoted, stating that while people are entitled to their beliefs, there is no evidence of supernatural occurrences, suggesting explanations like emotional contagion or mass hysteria. The article also addresses claims of miraculous events, such as silver rosaries turning gold or a "golden door to heaven," offering mundane explanations like silver coating or camera lens effects.

Problems in the Office of Alternative Medicine

The resignation of Joseph Jacobs, the director of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) Office of Alternative Medicine (OAM), is reported. Jacobs criticized politicians, particularly Senator Tom Harkin, and some alternative medicine advocates for pressuring the office and promoting specific therapies over objective scientific inquiry. The article cites an example where Senator Harkin promoted bee pollen therapy, despite the owner of the remedy facing FTC fines for false advertising. Jacobs warned that without rigorous, well-controlled data collection, field studies could devolve into anecdote-gathering, and that alternative therapists might not welcome scientific rigor.

Calendar of Events

Announcements for upcoming REALL meetings in November and December, featuring video presentations on "The Psychology of the Psychic and the Believer" and other topics.

A Nod to Our Patrons

A thank you to REALL's patron members who contribute $50 or more to support the organization's work in promoting critical thinking.

Letters to the Editor

An invitation for members to submit letters to the editor, encouraging a forum for discussion. Potential future topics include Part 2 of the tabloid analysis, cancer clusters, hormones in milk, and anti-oxidants.

Skeptics Online

Information on participating in skeptic message areas on computer BBS networks, specifically mentioning "The Temples of Syrinx" in Springfield, which hosts FidoNet SKEPTIC, EVOLUTION, UFO, and FMS conferences, as well as ParaNet conferences.

Membership Form

A form detailing various membership options for REALL, including regular, student, family, and patron memberships, as well as subscription-only and trial options. It provides contact information for mailing or in-person registration.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue revolve around the critical evaluation of media, particularly tabloids, and the rigorous application of the scientific method to paranormal and pseudoscientific claims. REALL maintains a stance of objective, critical inquiry, not rejecting claims outright but demanding evidence and logical reasoning. The newsletter promotes skepticism towards unsubstantiated claims, whether from media, television, or alternative medicine practitioners, and encourages members to engage in rational thinking and discussion.