1981 11 00 OMNI - Allan Hendry - Betty Hill

Magazine Overview

Title: ORBIT
Issue Date: November 1981
Price: $2.50
Volume/Identifier: C2484

This issue of ORBIT magazine features a striking cover with a surrealistic painting depicting a Siamese cat and a winged creature. The cover headline announces a diverse range of topics and contributors, including Arthur C. Clarke, James A. Michener, Ray Bradbury, Carl Sagan, Erica Jong, Norman Cousins, and Robert Silverberg, discussing subjects such as blimps, explorers, magnetic people, and transsexual reincarnation.

UFO Update: The Betty Hill Star Map Hoax

The lead article, titled "A French astronomer challenges Betty Hill's star map, revealing the most elaborate UFO hoax ever," by Allan Hendry, critically examines the famous Betty and Barney Hill UFO encounter from September 20, 1961. The article focuses on the star map that Betty Hill recalled from her alleged abduction experience.

The Hill Encounter and the Star Map

During a hypnosis session to recover memories of an "interrupted journey," Betty Hill described a star map shown to her by her alien captors. This map reportedly connected twelve sunlike stars with travel routes, with two stars identified as the aliens' home. The map, published by Mrs. Hill in 1966, gained significant traction and was considered highly credible, even resisting challenges from figures like Carl Sagan.

Marjorie Fish's Interpretation

Amateur astronomer Marjorie Fish became interested in the star map and sought to match its patterns with real stars. She reasoned that aliens seeking new civilizations would likely visit planets orbiting sunlike stars. Fish created a three-dimensional model of nearby sunlike stars, excluding binary systems that could not support life. She claimed that twelve stars on Hill's map corresponded to stars in her model, identifying Zeta 1 Reticuli and Zeta 2 Reticuli as the alien homeland.

Bonneau's Demolition of the Thesis

The article reveals that French astronomer Daniel Bonneau has effectively debunked Fish's thesis. Using speckle interferometry, Bonneau proved that Zeta 2 Reticuli is actually a binary star system, making it an improbable candidate for supporting alien life. The article points out that if binary stars were to be considered, it would drastically alter the matching patterns of the star map. Even Terry Dickinson, a key figure in publicizing the Hill case, has acknowledged that the star map leads to a dead end.

Conclusion on the Hoax

The article strongly suggests that the Betty Hill star map, once a cornerstone of UFO lore, is likely the "most elaborate UFO hoax ever perpetrated." The findings by Daniel Bonneau have invalidated the astronomical basis for the map's credibility.

Other Content

While the primary focus of the provided text is the UFO update, the cover headline indicates that the issue also features contributions from a wide array of notable authors and thinkers on diverse subjects, including science fiction luminaries, social commentators, and writers exploring themes of exploration, human potential, and societal change.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The editorial stance, as evidenced by the UFO article, appears to be critical and investigative, willing to challenge long-held beliefs within the UFO community based on scientific evidence. The magazine seems to cover a broad spectrum of topics, from speculative science and science fiction to social commentary and personal transformation, as suggested by the diverse list of contributors and themes mentioned on the cover.