Magazine Summary
The North Texas Skeptic
Summary
This issue of The North Texas Skeptic delves into various topics, including a mathematical web puzzle that uses digital roots to create a seemingly psychic effect. It also extensively covers the ongoing debate surrounding the teaching of evolution versus creationism in public schools, particularly in Kansas and Ohio, highlighting the political and scientific arguments. Additionally, the magazine discusses a book that attributes the 9/11 attacks to the White House, challenging the conventional narrative. The issue also touches upon the concept of perpetual motion and the impact of intelligent design on science education.
Magazine Overview
This issue of The North Texas Skeptic, Volume 20, Number 9, dated September 2006, features a cover story titled "Spooky? No" by John Blanton, which debunks a seemingly psychic web-based number and symbol puzzle. The magazine also includes several articles and news items focusing on the intersection of science, skepticism, and public discourse, particularly concerning the evolution versus creationism debate and conspiracy theories.
"Spooky? No" by John Blanton
John Blanton explains a popular internet puzzle that appears to have psychic properties. The puzzle involves the user thinking of a two-digit number, performing a calculation (adding the digits and subtracting the sum from the original number), and then identifying a symbol associated with the resulting number. Blanton reveals that the trick lies in the mathematical concept of the 'digital root.' The calculation always results in a number with a digital root of 9. The website then assigns a unique symbol to all numbers with a digital root of 9. The scrambling of symbols each time the user plays the game is a programming feature to maintain the illusion. A similar puzzle involving a four-digit number is also explained using the same digital root principle.
Events Calendar
The September Program includes a presentation on "9/11 conspiracy theories" by John Brandt and an NTS Social Dinner/Board Meeting. Information is provided for the Center for Nonprofit Management in Dallas and Good Eats restaurant.
North Texas Skeptics Officers and Board
The issue lists the officers of The North Texas Skeptics, including John Brandt (President), Pat Reeder (Vice President), Mike Selby (Secretary), and Mark Meyer (Treasurer). The staff includes Keith Blanton (Newsletter Editor) and John Blanton (Webmaster). The Board of Directors and Directors Emeritus are also listed, along with Scientific and Technical Advisors such as Joe Barnhart and Raymond A. Eve.
The organization is described as a tax-exempt 501(c)(3) scientific and educational organization. The newsletter is published monthly and mailed to members. Permission is granted for reprinting articles under certain conditions.
Evolution vs. Creationism Debate
Several articles address the ongoing conflict between science education and creationism/intelligent design.
Kansas School Board Controversy
An article discusses the situation in Kansas, where the state school board has been a battleground for evolution proponents and creationists. It highlights the importance of holding elected officials to basic standards of knowledge and criticizes the "ignorance" that allows scientifically illiterate individuals to determine curriculum. The article references Emma Roberson, a high school math teacher, as an example of someone who instilled an appreciation for mathematics, contrasting this with the perceived neglect of rational explanation by creationists.
Ohio School Board Elections
Another piece focuses on Ohio, where a coalition called "Help Ohio Public Education," led by Lawrence Krauss, is campaigning to unseat a Board of Education member who supports critical evaluation of evolution. The article notes that acceptance of evolution in America has declined and that "evolution denial" is growing. It criticizes the exclusion of Evolutionary Biology from a list of majors qualifying for "Smart grants" and mentions the replacement of Rev. George Coyne as director of the Vatican Observatory.
Phyllis Schlafly's perspective is also presented, with the article suggesting that she may not see the issue as a simple evolution vs. creationism debate and might be misinterpreting the "liberal press." The article quotes Schlafly on the importance of preparing students to distinguish scientific data from religious claims and to understand the "full range of scientific views." The author of the article counters that creationists refuse to acknowledge that science aims to dispute their worldview. The article also notes that liberals see political value in teaching evolution, as it challenges the idea of human exceptionalism. It references the "Dover effect" and the low voter turnout in Kansas.
9/11 Conspiracy Theory
An article by David Ray Griffin discusses a book published by the Presbyterian Church USA, titled "Christian Faith and the Truth Behind 9/11: A Call to Reflection and Action." Griffin, a professor emeritus of theology, claims that George W. Bush and the administration orchestrated the 9/11 attacks to justify wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. The book alleges controlled demolition of the Twin Towers and military personnel being given stand-down orders. Griffin believes churches need to be involved in exposing the truth behind 9/11. The publisher, Westminster John Knox, defended their decision to publish the book, citing a tradition of progressive stances and the "interesting issues" raised by Griffin.
Other News Items
Perpetuum Mobile
The slogan of a Dublin company, Steorn, "All great truths begin as blasphemies," is discussed in relation to their device using moving magnets for free energy. The full quote from George Bernard Shaw is provided.
Evolution Seminar
A weekend seminar is announced to examine the impact of Darwin's theory on Catholic teaching of creation, including the involvement of Austrian Cardinal Schoenborn.
Freedom of Science
An "Open Letter about the Freedom of Science" from G.O. Mueller in Germany is mentioned, which apparently argues that the Special Theory of Relativity is nonsense. The author notes that this is a common sentiment and that the scientific system is working to address such claims.
Kansas Primary Election
Moderate Republicans gained an advantage on the Kansas Board of Education, with evolution being a key issue.
Bleep: William Tiller and Ramtha's School of Enlightenment
This section briefly introduces William Tiller, a physicist who was an expert witness in a case involving a fraudulent medical diagnostic device, and his connection to Ramtha's School of Enlightenment. The article notes that Tiller has a high regard for graduates of the school and that a movie about it doubled his book sales.
Skeptic Ink
A comic strip by Prasad Golla and John Blanton, titled "Skeptic Ink," features a humorous exchange about immigration and visas, with characters representing "Homeland Security" and "You."
Future Meeting Dates
A list of future meeting dates for The North Texas Skeptics is provided, spanning from October 2006 to August 2007.
The Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal (CSICOP)
The issue includes a statement from CSICOP, encouraging critical investigation of paranormal claims and promoting science and reason. It also provides subscription information for "The Skeptical Inquirer" magazine.
Application for Membership
The final page is an application for membership to The North Texas Skeptics, detailing membership levels, dues, and contact information.
Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance
The recurring themes in this issue are skepticism towards paranormal claims and pseudoscientific phenomena, a strong advocacy for science-based education and critical thinking, and a critical examination of conspiracy theories and religious arguments encroaching on scientific discourse. The editorial stance is clearly in favor of rational inquiry, empirical evidence, and the scientific method, actively debunking claims that lack such grounding and promoting scientific literacy. The magazine appears to be a platform for disseminating skeptical viewpoints and engaging in public debate on issues where science and pseudoscience intersect.
“All great truths begin as blasphemies, but all blasphemies do not become great truths.”
Key Incidents
A web-based puzzle that asks users to think of a two-digit number, perform calculations, and then identify a symbol associated with the resulting number, which appears to be a form of digital root trickery.
Another web-based puzzle where users remove a digit from a four-digit number, and the system identifies the removed digit, also based on digital root principles.
The ongoing debate and political battles surrounding the teaching of evolution versus creationism/intelligent design in Kansas public schools.
Efforts by evolution proponents to influence elections for the Ohio Board of Education to counter the influence of intelligent design advocates.
A book published by the Presbyterian Church USA, authored by David Ray Griffin, which blames the 9/11 attacks on the White House rather than Osama bin Laden, alleging controlled demolition and stand-down orders.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does the 'Spooky? No' web puzzle work?
The puzzle uses a mathematical trick involving the digital root of numbers. By performing specific calculations (adding digits, subtracting the sum from the original number), the result always has a digital root of 9, allowing the website to consistently link it to a specific symbol.
What is the main controversy discussed regarding education?
The main controversy is the debate between teaching evolution and creationism/intelligent design in public school science curricula, with articles focusing on political battles in Kansas and Ohio over these standards.
What is the main claim of the book discussed on page 5?
The book, 'Christian Faith and the Truth Behind 9/11,' by David Ray Griffin, claims that the 9/11 attacks were orchestrated by the Bush administration as a pretext for war, involving controlled demolition and military stand-down orders.
What is the stance of The North Texas Skeptics on paranormal claims?
The North Texas Skeptics encourages the critical investigation of paranormal and fringe-science claims from a responsible, scientific point of view, promoting science, critical thinking, and the use of reason.
In This Issue
People Mentioned
- John BlantonAuthor
- Emma RobersonMath teacher
- John BrandtSpeaker on 9/11 conspiracy theories
- Keith BlantonNewsletter Editor
- Mike SelbyWebmaster, Meetings and Social Director
- Laura AinsworthBoard of Directors
- Daniel BarnettBoard of Directors
- Virginia BarnettBoard of Directors
- Erling BeckBoard of Directors
- John BlantonBoard of Directors
- John BrandtBoard of Directors
- Prasad GollaBoard of Directors
- +8 more
Organisations
- The North Texas Skeptics
- Center for Nonprofit Management
- Discovery Institute
- Help Ohio Public Education
- Case Western Reserve University
- Presbyterian Church USA
- Westminster John Knox
- The Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal
- CSICOP
Locations
- Dallas, USA
- Carrollton, USA
- Kansas, USA
- Ohio, USA
- Dover, USA
- Pennsylvania, USA
- Turkey
- Vatican
- Dublin, Ireland
- Tacoma, USA
- Washington, USA