CENAP Report - No 269

Magazine Overview

This issue of CENAP-REPORT, dated December 21, 2000, marks the transition into the 21st century and celebrates the 25th year of CENAP's activities. The cover features a NASA photo from Gemini XII, incidentally capturing an object identified as a 'UFO'. The issue's main headline is "With the CR into the 21st Century and into the 25th Year of CENAP Activities." The magazine is published bi-monthly in Germany.

Editorial and Publisher's Note

Werner Walter, the publisher, editor, and subscription manager, announces that this is the last printed issue of CENAP-REPORT. Future issues will be produced via photocopy to reduce costs, making the annual subscription cheaper. He notes the "downward trend of UFOlogy" and mentions a new regional UFO sighting investigator, Dina Krivoroutskaia, who received little response despite media attention. Walter also touches upon a TV UFO documentary on ZDF and reports in "Spektrum der Wissenschaft" and "P.M." regarding extraterrestrial life. He concludes with holiday wishes for the year 2001.

Article: UFOlogische Talfahrt - Schwere Zeiten für die Szene! (UFOlogy's Downward Trend - Difficult Times for the Scene!)

This main article delves into the perceived decline and challenges facing the UFOlogy field. The author argues that the allure of UFOs lies in the "unknown" and their impact on personal beliefs and priorities. However, the field has become saturated with myths and speculation, making rigorous research difficult. The article traces the history of UFO interest, noting its peak in the 1950s and early 1960s, followed by a decline after the Condon Report and the advent of the space age. The rise of science fiction films like "Close Encounters of the Third Kind" and "Independence Day" is seen as both popularizing UFO themes and diminishing their mystery by turning them into entertainment.

The article criticizes the "ufological Marshall Plan" proposed by some, highlighting a German photojournalist's 1967 request to Dr. Hynek for support in establishing a systematic UFO observation network. It points out the difficulty of communication due to language barriers and the tendency for UFOlogists to overemphasize and misinterpret phenomena.

Max B. Miller's observation from 1959 is quoted, noting the waning enthusiasm for UFOs and the influx of "childish comical characters." The article contrasts the scientific achievements of the Apollo moon landings with the fantastical narratives of UFOlogy. It discusses the impact of books like Maj. Lawrence Tacker's "The Flying Saucers and the U.S. Air Force" and the subsequent establishment of CUFOS by Hynek.

The piece highlights the rise of "Neo-UFOlogy" in Europe, which adopted a socio-psychological approach, and the emergence of skeptical voices within the movement. The 1980s are described as a more difficult period, with new figures in the scene reinterpreting older arguments, often overshadowing veteran researchers. The article notes the global "Americanization" of UFO discourse.

Steven Spielberg's personal connection to the UFO phenomenon is discussed, with his birth year coinciding with Kenneth Arnold's sighting and his early film "Firelight" being a precursor to "Close Encounters."

The Decline of UFO Interest and the Rise of Skepticism

The article details how UFO sightings and public interest declined significantly in the late 1960s and 1970s, following events like the Condon Report and the cancellation of the USAF's Project Blue Book. John Musgrave observed a drop in UFO club memberships and public engagement. The article suggests that the perceived lack of breakthroughs in proving UFOs as extraterrestrial craft, coupled with the satisfaction of space exploration dreams through films, led to this decline.

Coral Lorenzen of APRO questioned the public's apathy towards UFOs, noting a lack of progress and a shift towards sensationalized reporting. The article posits that the UFOlogy field survived by focusing on "special interests" like alien abductions, Area 51, Roswell, and crop circles, which appealed to a niche audience.

The Role of Media and the Shift Towards Conspiracy

The issue critically examines the media's role in shaping public perception of UFOs. It notes how media coverage can create UFO "waves" by amplifying initial sightings and encouraging more reports. However, in Germany, a consistently skeptical press has reportedly hindered the formation of such waves. The article contrasts the public's enthusiastic reception of scientific space achievements (like the Hubble Telescope and MIR space station) with the waning interest in UFOs, suggesting that the "alien" narrative has become less compelling.

The Commercialization and Mythologization of UFOlogy

The article criticizes the commercialization of UFOlogy, where sensationalism and profit often overshadow genuine research. It points to the proliferation of "conspiracy paranoia" in niche publishing, citing books on secret technologies, hidden agendas, and alleged government cover-ups. The rise of "Remote Viewing" is also mentioned as a trend that briefly captured public attention.

Skeptical Voices and Internal Criticism

Several skeptical voices and internal criticisms within the UFO community are highlighted. Eberhard Schneider's article "UFOlogy: Crash into Myth-Building?" is cited for its critique of popular UFO figures as "crazy spinners" or "unscrupulous businessmen." The article also mentions Werner Walter's own critical stance, which has led to him being labeled an "Anti-UFO fanatic" by some within the community. The piece suggests that the UFOlogy field has become a breeding ground for "liars, paranoids, and charlatans."

The Impact of Science Fiction and Entertainment

Films like "Independence Day" (ID4) are discussed as having a significant impact on the UFO phenomenon. While popularizing UFO themes, they also demystified them by presenting them as entertainment. The article argues that these films, by "explaining" popular 90s mysteries, removed the "thrill" and "mystery" from the UFO concept, making it commonplace.

The Future of UFO Research and the Rise of Scientific Exploration

The article contrasts the decline of UFOlogy with the advancements in scientific space exploration, such as the discovery of exoplanets. It suggests that NASA's focus on finding extraterrestrial life through scientific means is overshadowing the UFO field. The article concludes that the UFO phenomenon itself might be the only real phenomenon, driven by people's belief in it and the myths surrounding it, rather than an objective physical reality.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue of CENAP-REPORT include the decline of UFOlogy, the impact of media and popular culture on the perception of paranormal phenomena, the tension between skepticism and belief, and the commercialization of the UFO field. The editorial stance is critical of sensationalism and unsubstantiated claims within UFOlogy, advocating for a more rational and evidence-based approach, while acknowledging the enduring human fascination with the unknown. The magazine positions itself as a platform for critical analysis and demystification of UFO-related topics.

This issue of CENAP REPORT, dated 6/2000, delves into the perceived decline of ufology and the factors contributing to it. The publication critically examines the shift in public and media interest away from UFOs towards conspiracy theories and other sensational topics. It questions the scientific validity of much of the research and reporting within the UFO community.

The Decline of Ufology and Media Influence

The article posits that ufology has entered a "downward trend" (Talfahrt) due to a failure of its proponents to adapt to changing times and a lack of genuine breakthroughs. The author notes the collapse of several UFO magazines and a general decrease in readership, citing the example of "UFO Magazine" in America and "UFO Reality" and "Encounters" in England. The trend is also observed in Germany, where publishers are increasingly being asked for critical contributions beyond the "mainstream" of UFOlogy.

The perceived "offensiveness" of UFOlogy is attributed to its willingness to embrace unverified claims and its inability to generate new, compelling narratives. The author points to the lack of progress in UFO abduction cases and the public's disillusionment with phenomena like the "Face on Mars," which was debunked as a natural geological formation. Even popular culture, like "The X-Files," is seen as reflecting this shift, with later seasons focusing more on mystery-horror than alien conspiracies.

The issue highlights a paradox: while mainstream interest wanes, books like "UFO Sects," "The Dreamland File," and "Fantastic Science" gain traction by challenging UFO narratives. This suggests a public re-evaluation of the topic.

The historical context of ufology's boom and bust cycles is drawn, comparing the current situation to the post-1969 period following the Condon Report. The author quotes John Keel, who argued that the UFO phenomenon "committed suicide" through its own excesses and promoters, rather than being killed by official investigations.

A Pro7 television special, "Alien Special," is discussed as an example of how UFO reports are often quickly dismissed as hoaxes or fabrications, with even Billy Meier's UFO material being downplayed. The program's critical approach to the Roswell incident, suggesting it was a secret spy balloon, is noted as a significant shift.

The article also references other media programs that have contributed to debunking UFO claims, such as RTL's "The Biggest Bluffs in the World Exposed" and reports on alleged KGB UFO files. The author suggests a cyclical nature to media interest in UFOs, where periods of low attention are followed by surges, but ultimately, the phenomenon may be fading.

European Ufology and the Search for Answers

Correspondents from various European countries report a similar decline in UFO activity and interest. In Spain, the trend is mirrored, with a lack of new UFO magazines. In England, Jenny Randles notes a severe downturn since 1997, with publishers hesitant to release new UFO books due to a collapsed market. Bruno Mancusi from Switzerland indicates low interest in UFOs generally. In Finland, since March 1999, reported UFO sightings have been dismissed as "jokes" or unworthy of investigation, leading to a "UFO depression."

Across the board, there's a consensus that without media attention, public interest in UFOs wanes, and consequently, sightings decrease. This raises questions about the very existence of UFOs as an independent phenomenon.

Critiques of UFO Research and Organizations

The article presents a strong critique of UFO research methodologies and organizations. Dr. Frank Salisbury, a long-time UFO researcher, has given up, concluding that UFOs are not interstellar spacecraft but rather a staged "circus" or "show." He expresses frustration that his attempts to pursue a scientific approach were met with paranormal or religious explanations.

Mark Casham, the new MUFON state representative in Connecticut, has alienated many "para-freaks" by focusing on a new agenda and dismissing previous discussions. He notes that MUFON has dwindled from over 50 members to a handful of "serious people."

Concerns are raised about the lack of rigorous vetting within MUFON, where anyone can become a "field investigator" after passing a simple test, without background checks. This has led to problems in the past, with individuals like John Lear being appointed state directors.

The state of CUFOS is described as dire, with the case investigation system having collapsed and the scientific advisory board existing only on paper. Contacts with police and the FAA, established in the early days, have vanished.

The Brieselang Lights and Skeptical Investigations

A significant portion of the report focuses on the "Brieselang Lights" case. The author, Tino Günter, investigates reports of mysterious lights in the Brieselang forest, which have been attributed to supernatural or extraterrestrial origins. However, Günter's investigation, which involved interviewing witnesses and visiting the site, concludes that the lights are most likely caused by car headlights and flashlights used by visitors to the forest.

He critically examines the testimony of Doris W., a key witness in a previous report, and finds her identification of streetlights as UFOs to be mistaken. Günter suggests that many sightings are misinterpretations of common light sources, exacerbated by the desire for mystery and the influence of sensationalized media reports.

The article also touches upon the role of local cycling clubs in debunking some of the sightings, though the desire for mystery often prevents a full acceptance of rational explanations.

The Nature of UFO Reports and Scientific Inquiry

The report delves into the psychological aspects of UFO reporting, emphasizing that a UFO report is not a factual record but an interpretation of an experience. Witnesses, influenced by their cultural backgrounds and existing beliefs, tend to filter information to fit their preconceptions.

The author criticizes the tendency within ufology to label skeptics as "enemies" or "disinformants" and highlights the resistance to rational explanations that contradict established beliefs. The case of Illobrand von Ludwiger is presented as an example of a researcher who, despite claiming scientific rigor, is accused of selectively using information and engaging in polemics.

The article questions the scientific credentials of many UFO researchers, suggesting that their work often lacks empirical evidence and relies on speculation. The author contrasts the scientific method with the subjective interpretations common in ufology.

The Role of "Experts" and the Search for Proof

The report criticizes the reliance on "experts" in ufology, arguing that even renowned scientists can err. It suggests that many UFO researchers are not qualified to conduct scientific investigations and that their work is often driven by personal agendas.

The author highlights the importance of verifiable evidence, noting that despite decades of research, concrete proof of UFOs remains elusive. The article quotes Dr. Hynek, who described ufology as a field where "bluff and trash are sold as golden brilliance" and the search for the "Holy Grail" continues.

The report also touches upon the controversy surrounding UFO "evidence" such as photographs and landing traces, with examples of hoaxes and misinterpretations being presented.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue of CENAP REPORT are the decline of ufology, the critical analysis of UFO research methodologies, the influence of media on public perception, and the prevalence of hoaxes and misinterpretations within the UFO community. The editorial stance is clearly skeptical, emphasizing the need for rigorous scientific investigation and a critical approach to claims of extraterrestrial visitation. The report advocates for rational explanations and debunks sensationalized accounts, often highlighting the psychological and social factors that contribute to the UFO phenomenon.

Title: CENAP REPORT
Issue: 269,6/2000
Date: June 2000
Publisher: CENAP
Country: Germany
Language: German

This issue of the CENAP REPORT details significant developments in the UFO research community, including new publications, changes in the magazine's format, and reports on conferences and studies.

ET Jahrbuch 2000: A New UFO Chronology

The main feature on the cover is the announcement of the "ET Jahrbuch 2000" (ET Yearbook 2000). This is presented as the first part of a continuously evolving chronicle of the UFO phenomenon, aimed at providing information to those not connected to the online ET UFO magazine. The yearbook is described as an informative and up-to-date resource, compiled from the electronic magazine's content. It will be over 90 A4 pages long, featuring articles from known authors and interviews with figures like Michael Hesemann and Stanton T. Friedman. It will also include reports on spectacular UFO cases from the year, details about the "grosse Ufo-Tagung 2000" (Great UFO Conference 2000) with images, year-end UFO news, and a UFO lexicon. The yearbook is a self-produced, ring-bound publication with a color cover and black-and-white interior, priced at 16 DM for CENAP members. It was scheduled to be sent out to pre-order customers in mid-November.

CENAP REPORT Format Change

An important announcement details a significant change in the CENAP REPORT's publication format. Due to declining public interest in UFOs and the high costs associated with offset printing, the magazine will transition to a photocopied format starting with issue number 1/2001. This decision was made because the current printing and distribution costs were too high for the limited readership. The new format will feature 44 pages with a non-color cover. Rudolf Henke from Sandhausen will handle the printing and distribution. This change is accompanied by a price reduction: the annual domestic subscription will be DM 40, and the annual foreign subscription will be DM 45. The editorial acknowledges that the year 2000 was too expensive for the printed version and that hopes for growth were not realized, reflecting a perceived end to a period of intense UFO interest.

Cröffelbach III Conference Success

The issue reports positively on the "Cröffelbach III" autumn conference for German UFO researchers. The event was attended by 21 people, including members from MUFON-CES. The conference is described as a success, offering variety and discussions that provided new insights. Special mention is given to presentations by "outsiders" like theoretical physicist Markus Pössel, who discussed time travel and warp speed, and Ulf Harendarski, who spoke about UFO abduction experiences in relation to reality and literary representation. The report notes that this followed a similar approach from the previous year, which addressed atmospheric phenomena and fireballs.

UFO Study in Bad Pyrmont: "Aufklärung statt Mystifizierung"

A new UFO study is being launched in the Bad Pyrmont region, with the motto "Enlightenment not Mystification." CENAP, the national UFO hotline based in Mannheim, has appointed 20-year-old high school student Dina Krivoroutskaia as an honorary regional investigator for UFO sightings. Krivoroutskaia, who has been interested in UFOs for about ten years, will serve as the local contact point for UFO reports. The study aims to collect and analyze UFO sighting data, comparing it with CENAP's central database in Mannheim to find explanations. The initiative emphasizes a scientific approach, seeking serious reports and avoiding sensationalism. Krivoroutskaia, who has not personally witnessed any UFOs but wishes to, will be available via a "UFO-Telefon" at 05821/620301 from September onwards, taking calls Tuesdays to Sundays between 6 PM and 9 PM.

Other Mentions and Content

• Dr. Helmut Lammer's Apology: The report details an apology made by Dr. Helmut Lammer (formerly of MUFON-CES) for unfair and incorrect accusations made in his books about UFO skeptics, which he admitted were based on a lack of background knowledge and uncritical acceptance of information from his former chairman.
• Oliver Stummer's Disillusionment: Oliver Stummer (formerly of MUFON-CES, now with Z.E.U.S.) expressed disappointment with the UFO phenomenon and handed over his complete original case files to CENAP, rather than to his active MUFON-CES colleagues. His findings, though independently gathered, mirrored existing data, leading to his frustration.
• UFO Case Analysis: The issue touches upon the idea that practical research into UFOs consistently leads to similar conclusions, suggesting that alternative UFOlogy positions are often dogmatic and world-view driven, rather than based on empirical investigation.
• Cröffelbach Conference Details: The conference, now an institution, is planned for the last weekend of October annually. Attendees arrived on Friday to allow for more relaxed participation. Despite a limited program, time was still scarce, with discussions continuing until 2 AM. Video material of alleged UFOs was reviewed, though it reportedly became tedious for many.
• New York UFO Video: A recent video, received just before the conference, allegedly shows a flying saucer filmed over New York City on April 11, 2000, by a couple in a rented helicopter. The object reportedly emerged from behind a skyscraper and accelerated away at high speed, leaving a U-shaped condensation trail. The video was noted for its dramatic quality but was identified as likely computer animation, despite being used as a promotional trailer by the SciFi-Channel.
• Comic Strip: A comic strip on page 3 depicts a humorous exchange about seeing a UFO, with one character suggesting scientific investigation and the other humorously referencing hypnosis and telepathy.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The CENAP REPORT consistently advocates for a critical yet open approach to UFO research, emphasizing scientific investigation and factual analysis over speculation and sensationalism. The transition to a photocopied format signifies a pragmatic response to financial realities and perceived shifts in public interest, while still aiming to serve its dedicated readership. The magazine's stance is one of "Enlightenment not Mystification," seeking to demystify the UFO phenomenon through rigorous study and open discussion.