CENAP Report - No 260

Magazine Overview

Title: CENAP-REPORT
Issue Date: July-August 1999
Publisher: CENAP
Country: Germany
Language: German
Price: DM 70,--

This issue of CENAP-REPORT, the 260th, delves into the intersection of UFO phenomena with television, media, and public perception during the late 1990s. It features a cover story on 'UFOs on Television' alongside other articles on 'Diverse Short Reports,' 'Press Review,' 'In the Sign of the Sun,' and 'Planets + Star Wars Fever.' The magazine is characterized by its critical and skeptical approach to UFOlogy, often debunking sensational claims and exposing media hoaxes.

Key Articles and Content

UFOs on Television

The lead article critically examines television's coverage of UFOs, particularly highlighting a Pro7 program called 'Die Reporter' which investigated the Billy Meier case. The article asserts that Meier's 'saucer' was constructed from common materials and that his 'alien ladies' were showgirls. It also discusses the perceived decline in public interest in UFO-related 'mystery' programming, suggesting a shift towards more 'non-fiction' and investigative content.

Media Criticism and Hoaxes

A significant portion of the magazine is dedicated to dissecting media portrayals of UFOs. The issue scrutinizes the RTL program 'EXPLOSIV-Weekend' and its segment on 'Greatest Hoaxes of the World - Debunked,' which featured Werner Walter. It also discusses the controversial 'Alien Autopsy' film by Ray Santilli, labeling it a hoax and a 'show stunt' involving a puppet. The magazine criticizes the media's tendency to sensationalize and promote 'UFOtainment,' often at the expense of factual accuracy. The article 'Die größten Bluffs der Welt entlarvt' (The Greatest Bluffs of the World - Debunked) is presented as a positive example of media attempting to debunk modern superstitions.

The Billy Meier Case

The Billy Meier case is revisited, with the magazine asserting that his 'saucer' was assembled from readily available materials and that his 'alien ladies' were performers. The article dismisses Meier's claims as a 'swindle' and criticizes figures like Michael Hesemann for continuing to believe in his UFO contacts despite the evidence.

The Ray Santilli Alien Autopsy Film

This film is thoroughly debunked as a hoax, with the magazine explaining it as a show stunt using a puppet. It criticizes the media's promotion of such films and the gullibility of some UFOlogists and the public in accepting them as genuine evidence.

UFOlogy and Skepticism

The magazine discusses the challenges facing UFOlogy, noting a decline in readership for specialized publications and a growing public skepticism. It highlights the work of organizations like GWUP (Society for Scientific Investigation of the Paranormal) and the emergence of 'skeptical centers.' The article suggests that the UFOlogy field is experiencing a 'trough' and that a more critical and scientific approach is needed.

Media Coverage Analysis

CENAP-REPORT analyzes various television programs and their UFO-related content, including segments on RTL, Pro7, and ZDF. It notes that while some programs attempt to debunk UFO claims, others contribute to the sensationalism. The magazine also points out the financial pressures on media outlets, which can lead to a focus on entertainment value over factual reporting.

Specific Case Studies

• Gemini XII Photo: A small object photographed in space from the Gemini XII capsule in 1966 is presented as an example of an accidental 'UFO' photograph.
• Thomas Rabenhorst's Photo: A reader submitted a photo of a cylindrical object, which was later determined to be an artifact of the photo development process, illustrating how chance can create apparent anomalies.
• KGB UFOs: The magazine critically examines a TV report on alleged KGB UFO files, concluding that much of the footage was manipulated or computer-generated.

Personal Anecdotes and Reader Mail

The issue includes reader feedback and personal anecdotes, some of which express frustration with CENAP's skeptical stance, while others appreciate its critical approach. One reader recounts a threatening phone call received by Werner Walter.

Financial and Publication Trends

The magazine touches upon the financial challenges faced by UFO publications, noting price increases and reduced publication frequency for some magazines. It also mentions the decline in UFO-related book offerings from major publishers.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

CENAP-REPORT consistently adopts a critical and skeptical stance towards UFO phenomena and the UFOlogy community. The magazine's editorial stance is to debunk sensational claims, expose hoaxes, and promote a rational, evidence-based approach. It frequently criticizes media outlets for sensationalizing UFO topics and contributing to public misinformation. The publication emphasizes the importance of critical thinking and scientific investigation in understanding alleged anomalies. There is a recurring theme of media manipulation and the financial incentives behind promoting paranormal claims. The magazine positions itself as a voice of reason and scientific inquiry within the often-speculative field of UFO research.

This issue of CENAP REPORT, dated July/August 1999, focuses on UFO phenomena, space exploration, and astronomical events, particularly the upcoming solar eclipse. The cover headline, "UFO Believers Expect Visitors from Outer Space," sets the tone for much of the content, which explores public interest in UFOs, alleged encounters, and the scientific community's perspective.

TV and Media Coverage of UFOs

The magazine reviews recent television programs and discussions related to UFOs. The end of the popular TV series "X-Files" is noted, with its transition to cinema. Programs like "Mission Erde" and "Stargate" are briefly mentioned. A significant portion is dedicated to a talk show on RTL featuring alien contactees Andreas and Albert, and a skeptic named Hartmut. Another segment discusses a children's TV show on MDR that addressed UFOs, leading to a surge in calls to a hotline. The WDR's "Maus-Club" also touched upon the definition of UFOs and the likelihood of extraterrestrial life.

Scientific Explanations and Debunking

CENAP REPORT often provides scientific explanations for reported phenomena. The article "Flying Triangles: Partially Explained?" suggests that some sightings might be attributed to satellite constellations, specifically the US Navy's "White Cloud" system. It also discusses how commercial airliners at night can be mistaken for UFOs. The report on a supposed UFO crash on Tenerife is debunked as a fabrication by the tabloid press. Similarly, a reported UFO landing site on Gran Canaria is analyzed, with witness accounts suggesting exaggeration.

Military and Technological Developments

The issue includes an article on German military technology, specifically the development of stealth aircraft by the Bundeswehr, refuting claims that this technology was derived from alien sources. It highlights the "Lampyridae" project, a German attempt to create a radar-stealth fighter jet.

Scientific Breakthroughs and Theories

A significant scientific development reported is the alleged synthesis of elements 116 and 118 by physicist Viktor Ninov. This breakthrough is presented as potentially challenging theories like Bob Lazar's, which rely on the existence of element 115 for UFO propulsion.

The Solar Eclipse of August 11, 1999

A major focus of the magazine is the upcoming total solar eclipse on August 11, 1999. The article "In the Sign of the Sun" discusses the historical context of solar eclipses, often associated with apocalyptic fears and prophecies. It debunks sensationalist predictions, including those attributed to Nostradamus and Fatima prophecies, and emphasizes the astronomical nature of the event. The visible planets during the eclipse (Venus, Mercury, Jupiter, and Saturn) are explained as natural phenomena, not omens of doom. The magazine provides viewing information for Germany and warns about the dangers of looking directly at the sun without certified protective eyewear.

The Apollo 11 Moon Landing Anniversary

The 30th anniversary of the Apollo 11 moon landing is commemorated. The article "Apollo 11 - A Planned Death?" reveals that NASA had prepared a contingency plan for a "space burial" and a prepared eulogy by President Nixon in case of mission failure. It details the astronauts' experiences, including the risks involved in landing the "Eagle" module and the astronauts' personal reflections, such as Edwin Aldrin's communion on the moon. The article also touches upon the contrasting post-mission lives of Neil Armstrong, Buzz Aldrin, and Michael Collins.

UFO Congress and Personal Accounts

The magazine reports on a UFO congress in Grevenbroich, featuring personal accounts from individuals claiming contact with extraterrestrials. Bernhard Freytag shares his experiences of alleged alien visitations and examinations. The congress also included discussions on the possibility of aliens living among humans, disguised as plants, insects, or reptiles, and claims of implants and telepathic communication.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are the persistent public fascination with UFOs and extraterrestrial life, the tendency to interpret natural phenomena through a mystical or apocalyptic lens, and the role of media in shaping these perceptions. CENAP REPORT generally adopts a skeptical but open-minded approach, seeking rational explanations for reported phenomena while acknowledging the enduring mystery surrounding UFOs. The editorial stance appears to be one of critical inquiry, aiming to inform readers by presenting both sensational claims and scientific counterarguments, encouraging a balanced perspective.

This issue of CENAP REPORT, dated July/August 1999, focuses on a blend of ufological discussions, astronomical news, and cultural phenomena, with a particular emphasis on the 30th anniversary of the Apollo 11 moon landing.

The Apollo 11 Anniversary and its Impact

The issue opens by reflecting on the 30th anniversary of the Apollo 11 moon landing, highlighting its profound impact on humanity's perception of Earth and the cosmos. The event is described as a 'new Copernican shock,' transforming Earth into a 'small blue marble' and initiating a new era of space exploration. This shift is linked to a rise in fringe sciences, esotericism, and a new cosmic perspective influencing popular culture. The article notes the emotional resonance of this anniversary, especially in conjunction with the upcoming solar eclipse.

UFO Phenomena and Sightings

The magazine discusses various UFO-related events and theories. It mentions the passing of ex-astronaut Pete Conrad, drawing a parallel between the vulnerability of heroes and the potential dangers faced by ordinary people. A significant event highlighted is a daylight bolide show over the northwest coast of New Zealand on July 7, 1999, which was heard and seen by thousands, causing a shockwave. The issue also touches upon alleged alien abduction experiences, including that of Peter Khoury, and the controversial claim of an alien hair sample undergoing DNA analysis.

Astrological Predictions and UFOlogy

A section titled 'Astrology Spook and Mystic Nervousness' explores the intersection of astrological predictions and UFO phenomena. It references an article in M2000 suggesting that the upcoming solar eclipse is a significant astrological event, potentially marking a new era. The magazine notes the increasing integration of UFO topics within forums that also discuss religious and spiritual phenomena, suggesting that UFOs are no longer seen as purely materialistic but possess a metaphysical component.

Crop Circles and Scientific Scrutiny

The phenomenon of crop circles is examined, with a mention of the Rockefeller Foundation funding research into these formations. The article notes that while some crop circles lack an 'earthly explanation,' the majority are attributed to human artistry. It also features researchers like Colin Andrews and Dr. Robin Allen, who are investigating the phenomenon using modern technology.

Sects and End-Time Beliefs

The issue touches upon the theme of end-time prophecies and cults, referencing a ZDF program on the 'Mythos 2000' and the idea of the world ending. It connects these beliefs to UFOs, with some groups hoping to be rescued by extraterrestrial craft. Examples include the Fiat Lux group and James Gilliand's followers. The disappearance of sect members in Colombia and Spain, who reportedly went to meet aliens, is also reported.

Scientific Exploration and the Search for Extraterrestrial Life

The magazine discusses the scientific search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI), including the 'seti@home' project that utilizes internet users' computer power. It also highlights the growing field of exoplanet discovery, with astronomers finding numerous planets around distant stars, increasing the probability of life elsewhere in the universe. The search for alien signals is also being explored using laser technology, moving beyond traditional radio wave searches.

The 'Star Wars' Phenomenon

A significant portion of the magazine is dedicated to the release of 'Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace.' It discusses the film's cultural impact, its technological advancements in CGI, and the marketing surrounding it. The article notes the film's massive success at the box office and its reception by audiences, contrasting it with critical reviews. It also touches upon the business aspects, such as distribution rights and ticket prices.

UFO Conferences and Research Groups

The issue announces an upcoming UFO conference, 'UFO-Begegnung 1999,' aimed at uniting different UFO research factions. It details the program, including presentations on UFO abductions, the Roswell incident, and atmospheric phenomena. The event is described as an 'insider meeting' focused on open discussion and personal exchange among researchers.

Critical Perspectives on Ufology

The magazine adopts a critical perspective on much of the UFO community, labeling some enthusiasts as 'blue-eyed, naive people' and 'spinners.' It questions the scientific rigor of some UFO research and expresses concern about the tendency towards pseudoreligion and esotericism within the field. The authors emphasize their commitment to objective research rather than catering to the 'phantastic wishes' of the UFO fandom.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue include the intersection of science, belief, and speculation, particularly concerning UFOs and extraterrestrial life. The magazine maintains a critical yet engaged stance, seeking to differentiate between rigorous scientific inquiry and more speculative or pseudoscientific claims within the UFO field. There is a clear emphasis on critical thinking and evidence-based analysis, even when discussing phenomena that challenge conventional understanding. The editorial stance appears to be one of promoting a more grounded and scientific approach to the study of unexplained phenomena, while acknowledging the public's fascination with them.

This issue of CENAP REPORT, dated July/August 1999, focuses on various aspects of the UFO phenomenon, blending investigative reporting with cultural commentary and news updates. The magazine criticizes the dogmatic and fanatical elements within the UFO community, contrasting them with a more objective research approach.

Russian Flying Saucer Project

The lead story, "Russische Fliegende Untertasse abgestürzt" (Russian Flying Saucer Crashed), discusses the long-standing rumor of Russia developing a flying saucer-shaped aircraft. While models and prototypes have been shown in various media reports, including a visit by President Yeltsin, the project appears to have been halted due to lack of funds. The report cites a BBC article from June 27, 1999, and a Ren-TV report from Saratov, indicating that the project was discontinued in its model stage. The intended aircraft was designed to reach speeds of 700 km/h and potentially serve as a mass transporter for up to 1000 passengers.

UFO Business Ventures

An article titled "UFO-Geschäft platzte nicht" (UFO Business Didn't Burst) details an unusual real estate venture. Paul Ki Ping-ki attempted to sell a large US property in Iowa as a UFO landing site for $12.80 per square inch. This advertisement, placed in a Hong Kong newspaper, led to a critical article in the "Oriental Daily News," which labeled the offer a hoax. Ki sued the newspaper and won, with the judge ruling that while Ki had no proof of UFOs, he was free to make such an offer based on his personal belief, leaving the decision to potential buyers.

New Role for the RAF

"Ein neuer Job für die RAF" (A New Job for the RAF) reports on the UK Ministry of Defence's collaboration with the film industry. Under Ms. Una Muirhead, a new department within the Directorate for Information, Communication and Strategy was established to handle requests from TV and film producers seeking access to military infrastructure, personnel, and equipment. This initiative aims to promote British culture and lifestyle, attract tourism, and provide opportunities for military personnel to participate in productions. The article mentions examples like the James Bond film "The World is Not Enough" and the BBC sci-fi series "Invasion Earth." It also references lessons learned from the production of "Saving Private Ryan," where the UK military's inflexibility led Steven Spielberg to film in Ireland instead of England.

E.T. Wants to Phone Home

"E.T. will wieder nach hause telefonieren..." (E.T. Wants to Phone Home...) highlights a marketing campaign by British Telecom (BT) featuring Steven Spielberg's alien character E.T. to promote their "Stay in Touch" campaign.

GUS-Aliens Differ from Western Perceptions

"GUS-Aliens ganz anders als im Westen" (GUS-Aliens Completely Different from the West) explores the idea that UFO encounter narratives are culturally influenced. Citing an article by Wladislaw Raab in "UFO Report" Nr. 3/1999, the piece contrasts Western UFO experiences with those reported in the GUS (formerly Soviet) states. While Western accounts often feature small aliens and abductions, GUS reports tend to describe large, robot-like beings and invitations to enter UFOs. The article draws parallels to Russian folklore, where giants play a significant role, and notes that GUS encounter narratives often include elements of hospitality, such as being offered food and gifts, reminiscent of interactions with nature spirits in older myths.

The TV Movie UFO Blimp

"Das TUMovie-UFO" (The TV Movie UFO) announces the planned advertising tour of a 60-meter long blimp by the German TV magazine "TV Movie." The blimp, equipped with special lighting, was scheduled to fly over several German cities, including Berlin, Cologne, Hamburg, and Munich, between August and October 1999. The article provides a detailed schedule of its planned routes and landing sites, noting its flight altitude and speed, and suggesting it could stimulate UFO sightings.

Comic Strip

A comic strip by "Corso" is included, humorously depicting the author's books "The Day After Roswell" and "The Day Before Roswell." The comic satirizes the content of these books, suggesting that while they discuss events like shopping trips and haircuts, UFOs only appear a day later in the narrative.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The magazine consistently criticizes what it perceives as unscientific and dogmatic attitudes within the UFO community, advocating for a more rigorous and objective research approach. There's a recurring theme of distinguishing between genuine research and mere fandom or belief systems. The issue also highlights the intersection of UFO phenomena with popular culture, media, and even business ventures, as seen in the Russian project, the US land sale, and the RAF's media engagement. The cultural relativity of UFO reports is also a significant point of discussion.