CENAP Report - No 241

Magazine Overview

This issue of CENAP-REPORT, dated Mai/Juni 1997 (Nr. 241, Volume 4/97), is a German-language UFO journal published by CENAP. The cover features a striking image of the Earth with a disc-shaped aircraft, referencing historical UFO events and the 100th anniversary of 'flying triangles'. The main headline, 'CR: Im Zeichen der Trauer!' (CR: In the Sign of Mourning!), introduces a theme that connects UFOs with historical events, ufology, spiritualism, occultism, the zeitgeist, and a mass suicide in San Diego.

Editorial Stance and Focus

The editorial states that 1997, the 50th anniversary of the UFO phenomenon, has taken an unexpected turn, referencing the Heaven's Gate incident. Consequently, the CENAP-REPORT will adopt a different orientation, focusing on the socio-psychological aspects of UFO phenomena. The issue aims to trace the history of ufology, identify past errors, and debunk UFO-related superstitions. It specifically addresses the 'Four Weeks in Spring 1997' following the mass suicide of UFO cultists in San Diego, using it to distinguish serious UFO researchers from those who are not.

Kenneth Arnold: The First UFO Investigator?

The issue dedicates significant space to Kenneth Arnold, often credited as the first modern UFO investigator. It details his June 24, 1947 sighting of nine fast-moving objects over the Cascade Mountains, which led to the coining of the term 'flying saucer'. The article clarifies that Arnold's description and subsequent drawings did not initially resemble the typical 'flying saucer' depicted in popular culture, but rather more like crescent-shaped objects or 'flying flapjacks'. It highlights his interactions with military intelligence (Lt. Frank Brown and Cpt. William Davidson) and his investigation into the Maury Island incident, which was later exposed as a hoax.

Arnold's book, 'Coming of the Saucers', co-authored with Ray Palmer, is discussed, with emphasis on lesser-known details. The article points out that Arnold's initial description of the objects was based on their behavior and appearance, likening them to 'flying discs' or 'flying flapjacks' rather than the later iconic 'flying saucer' shape. The investigation into the Maury Island incident involved attempts by military personnel to keep Arnold from discussing his sighting, despite its public nature.

The Maury Island Incident and its Aftermath

The Maury Island incident, initially investigated by Arnold, is presented as a hoax. The article details how Arnold was contacted by military intelligence and later by Ray Palmer, who offered a reward for investigating the incident. Arnold's subsequent investigation, aided by Captain Smith, involved examining alleged debris from the crashed craft, which turned out to be slag. The military's involvement, including the mysterious crash of a B-25 bomber carrying UFO material, adds to the intrigue and highlights the military's interest and potential cover-up.

George Adamski: The Contactee Controversy

A substantial portion of the magazine is dedicated to George Adamski, a prominent UFO contactee. The article critically examines his claims of meeting 'space-people' and his photographs of 'flying saucers'. It suggests that Adamski's stories and images were fabricated, possibly influenced by popular science fiction and occult beliefs. The magazine cites evidence from other researchers and former associates, like Jerrold Baker, who later recanted his support for Adamski, and James W. Moseley, who exposed many UFO photographs as hoaxes. Adamski's 'scout ship' photos are compared to contemporary light fixtures and models, and his explanations for the poor quality of his 'mothership' photos are questioned.

Adamski's interactions with figures like Desmond Leslie and his alleged encounters with 'Venusians' are presented with skepticism. The article also touches upon legal issues Adamski faced, such as a fine for conducting a UFO lecture on a tourist visa in Mexico. The magazine implies that Adamski, along with other contactees, may have been part of a larger scheme to mislead the public or promote certain agendas.

UFOlogy's Historical Trajectory and Critiques

The magazine critiques the broader field of ufology, suggesting that many researchers and enthusiasts are prone to accepting unsubstantiated claims and are resistant to evidence that contradicts their beliefs. It highlights the tendency for UFO narratives to evolve and adapt to popular trends, drawing parallels between Adamski and the case of Billy Meier. The article also touches upon the role of 'spiritism and occultism' in UFO phenomena, suggesting that some UFO beliefs have roots in these areas.

Other UFO Cases and Themes

Brief mentions are made of other UFO-related events and figures, including the 'Flying Flapjack' aircraft, the 'Project Blue Book' report, and the 'Tomaten-Mann' photo case. The issue also includes a section on 'Spiritism and Occultism', linking it to UFO phenomena and suggesting that many UFO beliefs are intertwined with these domains.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are the critical examination of UFO history, the debunking of prominent UFO cases and figures (particularly Kenneth Arnold and George Adamski), and the exploration of the socio-psychological and occult dimensions of the UFO phenomenon. The editorial stance is clearly skeptical towards sensational claims and emphasizes the need for critical thinking and factual evidence in UFO research. The magazine positions itself as a source of in-depth, critical analysis, aiming to provide a more grounded understanding of UFOlogy and to challenge widespread beliefs that it deems unfounded or fraudulent.

Title: SAUCER NEWS
Issue: Volume 3, Number 3 (Whole Number 17)
Date: April-May 1956
Publisher: SAUCER AND UNEXPLAINED CELESTIAL EVENTS RESEARCH SOCIETY
Editor: JAMES W. MOSELEY

This issue of SAUCER NEWS, a publication dedicated to the study of flying saucers and unexplained celestial events, presents a critical and often skeptical examination of the UFO phenomenon. Editor James W. Moseley, through his publication, aims to sift through the sensational claims and alleged evidence, often exposing hoaxes and questioning the motives of prominent figures in the UFO community. The magazine features reports, analyses, and opinions on various sightings, contactee claims, and government involvement.

Key Articles and Reports

The Pentagon and 'Fact Sheets' An illustration depicts a chaotic scene at the Pentagon, satirizing the Air Force's tendency to issue dry and uninformative 'fact sheets' on flying saucers. The accompanying text suggests that while the military might have identified some classic UFO cases as conventional objects like stratospheric balloons or bolides, the public perception of UFOs as extraterrestrial vehicles persists.

UFO Criticism: Friendly Fire James W. Moseley faced criticism, termed 'friendly fire,' from fellow UFO enthusiasts for his perceived alignment with the US Air Force and his role in withholding information. Mr. Biddle of the British magazine URANUS accused Moseley of playing the 'Air Force game,' while Gray Barker suggested Moseley's magazine was a front for the US Air Force. Moseley defended his stance, stating his opinions changed in 1954 due to concrete information and investigations, and he denied any involvement with a 'silence group.'

The Adamski Controversy The issue revisits the controversy surrounding George Adamski, a prominent contactee. Moseley reiterates his skepticism, suggesting Adamski's claims were fabricated for financial gain. He recounts how a fabricated 'R.E. Straith' letter, intended to validate Adamski's claims, was exposed as a hoax by The Times of London. Moseley and Gray Barker are implicated in creating similar fake letters to satirize the UFO community.

UFO Sightings and Investigations Several specific UFO sightings and landing reports are discussed:

• Cincinnati, Ohio (March 21, 1956): A journalist reported a UFO described as a bright, signal-like light, appearing as a compact galaxy of lights through binoculars.
• New York to Buffalo (April 8, 1956): Pilot Raymond E. Ryan pursued a 'saucer' for 45 minutes.
• Kinross AFB, Michigan (November 23, 1953): A pilot and his radar operator disappeared after pursuing an unknown blip on radar.
• Glassboro, N.J. (September 5, 1964): Two boys reported finding holes and discs from a saucer landing. This case was later revealed to be a hoax orchestrated by teenagers.
• Augusta County, Virginia (January 29, 1964): A sheriff warned citizens against being armed while searching for 'little green men' amidst a UFO wave.
• Gemini Space Mission (April 8, 1964): Keyhoe claimed astronauts saw UFOs, but this was allegedly suppressed by NASA.

Debunked Cases and Hoaxes

• Fort Lauderdale Naval Air Station (December 5, 1945): Five TBM Avenger aircraft disappeared, a case later revealed to be linked to a non-existent base.
• Utica, New York (March 1956): An F-94 jet pursuing a UFO crashed after the pilot ejected due to a heat wave.
• Bad Axe, Michigan (August 1958): A figure in a space suit appearing on the roadside was revealed to be a prank.
• Eagle River (December 1961): 'Alien cookies' analyzed by the USAF were found to be made of common terrestrial ingredients.

Critiques of Key Figures

• Donald Keyhoe: Keyhoe's book 'The Flying Saucer Conspiracy' is analyzed, with Michael G. Mann questioning the validity of his cases and the alleged 'US Air Force censorship of UFO sightings.' Mann contacts Major Tacker at the Pentagon, who states that Keyhoe's cases were not reported to the USAF.
• Howard Menger: Menger's claims are questioned, with suggestions that he may have been hypnotized. His book 'From Outer Space to You' is discussed.
• George Hunt Williamson: His book 'Road in the Sky' is reviewed, which made sensational claims about Hopi Indians, the Abominable Snowman, and space visitors. Williamson's efforts to establish a colony of UFO researchers in Peru are also mentioned.

Moseley's Personal and Professional Life

• Financial Independence: Moseley clarifies that he is an antiquities dealer and funds his ufological activities and publications independently, denying any government or CIA funding.
• Past Conflicts: The issue touches upon past conflicts, including a dispute with Gray Barker over a woman, which led to a period of mutual fabrication of 'fake stories' for their respective magazines.
• Offer for UFO Proof: Moseley's $1,000 offer for UFO proof, made in 1956, was never claimed, leading him to withdraw it in December 1963.

UFO Investigator and Other Publications

The issue references other UFO publications like 'The U.F.O. Investigator' and 'URANUS,' and discusses their content and editorial stances. It also mentions the formation of organizations like 'GAP Germany' and their efforts to gather UFO reports.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue of SAUCER NEWS are skepticism towards sensational UFO claims, the exposure of hoaxes, and a critical examination of prominent figures in the UFOlogy field, particularly George Adamski and Donald Keyhoe. Editor James W. Moseley consistently strives to present a rational perspective, often clashing with other UFO enthusiasts who hold more fervent beliefs. The magazine highlights the challenges of separating fact from fiction in a field rife with speculation, misinformation, and alleged government secrecy. Moseley's editorial stance is one of critical inquiry, aiming to provide readers with a more grounded understanding of the UFO phenomenon, even if it means challenging popular narratives and alienating some within the UFO community. The publication also touches upon the media's role in shaping public perception of UFOs and the difficulties in obtaining official information.

This issue of CENAP REPORT, dated Mai/Juni 1997, focuses heavily on UFOlogy, alien contact, and related spiritual and conspiracy theories. The cover prominently features 'GAP-GERMANY UFO-TREFF OLCHING', indicating a local UFO enthusiast group and their activities. The magazine explores various facets of the UFO phenomenon, from personal accounts and research to the societal and psychological impact of these beliefs.

GAP-Germany and UFO-Treff Olching

The magazine introduces GAP-Germany and its UFO-Treff Olching, aiming to share experiences and information about UFOs and spirituality. They invite contributions and suggestions for their website, which was updated on March 2, 1997. Their stated themes include Ashtar Sheran, Santiner, contact with extraterrestrials, future events on Earth, and spiritual consciousness.

Ashtar Sheran and the Ashtar Command

A significant portion of the issue is dedicated to Ashtar Sheran and the Ashtar Command. Ashtar Sheran is described as a 'Commander of Love' and the 'Son of Man', leading a fleet of 10 million spaceships. His mission, guided by the 'Divine Plan', is to help humanity evolve and to evacuate Earth if necessary. The concept of evacuation is detailed in three phases: Phase I (sudden global evacuation), Phase II (rescue of children and followers), and Phase III (final mass evacuation). The Ashtar Command logo is explained as representing the universal blue of the cosmos, the white divine light, and the intergalactic legion.

Hermann Ilg: A Leading German UFO Researcher

The article profiles Hermann Ilg, a retired bridge builder and prominent German UFO researcher. Ilg, who relies on logical thinking, firmly believes in the existence of extraterrestrials, specifically the 'Santiner', who he claims have been observing Earth for millennia and will eventually save humanity from self-destruction. He communicates with them telepathically and through 'medial writing', even corresponding with Ashtar Sheran. Ilg describes the Santiner's advanced technology, including 'psycho-dynamic' propulsion, and their benevolent intentions.

UFOlogy and Spiritualism

The magazine explores the intersection of UFOlogy with spiritualism and New Age beliefs. It discusses how UFO encounters are often interpreted as spiritual experiences, akin to religious revelations. The concept of 'archetypal initiation processes' is presented, drawing parallels between UFO abduction experiences and mystical experiences, both involving a sense of otherworldliness, guidance from superior beings, and themes of light and sexuality.

The Dark Side of UFOlogy: Sects and Mass Suicide

A critical perspective on UFOlogy is presented, particularly concerning UFO sects. The article 'Massen-Suizid in San Diego' discusses the Heaven's Gate cult's mass suicide, noting the parallels with other UFO-based groups that combine Christian elements with science fiction beliefs. Horst Dittmer, a German sect founder, distances his 'Licht-Kreis' from Heaven's Gate, though both groups believe in aliens and a coming cataclysm. The article highlights the dangers of 'reality loss' and the potential for self-destruction or violence within such groups.

UFOs in the News and Popular Culture

Several news snippets report on UFO sightings and related events. The article 'Kosmopolitische Verschwörung' examines how the US TV series 'X-Files' is being used by right-wing extremists in France to promote their ideology of a global conspiracy. Another piece discusses Johannes von Buttlar's book reading on the Roswell incident, while 'Unita 96' in Gütersloh is presented as a forum for UFO discussions. The 'Ufo-Stammtisch' in Regen is described as a group of individuals who believe extraterrestrials are among us and that governments are covering up the truth.

Personal Accounts and Encounters

The issue includes personal stories, such as the case of Monika Schlensog, who allegedly joined a UFO sect and disappeared, leaving a note about being on a spaceship. There's also the story of Vittorio L., the 'Uni-Feuerteufel', who committed arson, believing a UFO incident caused a brain tumor. The article '300 warteten auf UFO: Es kam nur die Polizei' recounts a failed attempt by a couple to stage an alien landing, resulting in disappointment and vandalism.

Thematic Analysis

The magazine presents a broad spectrum of views on UFOs, ranging from fervent belief and spiritual interpretation to skepticism and critical analysis. The recurring themes include: the existence of extraterrestrial intelligence, the potential for alien contact and communication, government secrecy and cover-ups, the spiritual and religious dimensions of UFO beliefs, the dangers of UFO cults, and the influence of UFOs in popular culture.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The CENAP REPORT appears to adopt a stance of exploring the UFO phenomenon from multiple angles, including the enthusiastic embrace of contactees and researchers, as well as critical perspectives on the more extreme manifestations of UFO belief, such as cults and conspiracy theories. There's a clear interest in the spiritual and psychological aspects of UFO encounters, often linking them to religious experiences and a search for meaning. The magazine seems to present information from various sources, allowing readers to draw their own conclusions, while also highlighting potential dangers and misinformation within the UFO community.

This issue of CENAP REPORT, dated Mai/Juni 1997 (Issue 241), focuses heavily on the phenomenon of UFO cults, their ideologies, and the tragic consequences that can arise from them. The cover story, "Der Mann, der die onlinen Männchen gesehen hat" (The Man Who Saw the Online Little Men), introduces Claude Vorilhon (Rael) and his claims of encountering aliens and founding a new religion. The magazine explores how UFO sightings have become intertwined with spiritual and religious beliefs, often leading to the formation of groups that promise salvation or a better existence on other planets.

The UFO Cult and Its Victims: The Days After

The issue dedicates significant space to the "Heaven's Gate" cult and their mass suicide in San Diego, California, on March 27, 1997. The 39 members believed that the arrival of Comet Hale-Bopp was a sign to leave their earthly bodies and ascend to a spacecraft. The article details their highly organized ritual suicide, involving a 'death cocktail' and plastic bags. It highlights how these cults often recruit individuals seeking meaning or an escape from earthly realities, promising a higher level of consciousness and a 'better world'.

The magazine traces the origins of Marshall Applewhite, the leader of "Heaven's Gate," and his earlier involvement with Bonnie Lu Nettles in the "Human Individual Metamorphosis" sect in the 1970s. It notes that Applewhite had a history of psychological issues and a fascination with extraterrestrials, which he used to manipulate followers.

UFOlogy's Influence and the 'Contactee' Phenomenon

CENAP REPORT examines the broader UFO cult phenomenon, noting how various individuals and groups have capitalized on the idea of flying saucers and alien contact. Figures like George Adamski are mentioned as pioneers in this field, establishing a narrative that often parallels religious prophecies and apocalyptic visions. The article criticizes the tendency for UFOlogy to become entangled with esotericism and New Age beliefs, arguing that this distracts from a scientific understanding of the phenomenon.

It discusses how UFO contactees often present themselves as intermediaries or prophets, relaying messages from 'higher beings' or 'space brothers.' These messages frequently address moral and metaphysical issues, offering guidance on how humanity should live and prepare for future events, including potential alien interventions or cosmic shifts.

Historical Context and International Cases

The issue provides historical context by referencing earlier UFO-related events and figures, such as Swedenborg and Madame Blavatsky, and their influence on modern UFO beliefs. It also touches upon the US military's initial interest in UFOs in the 1940s and 50s, which later waned.

International examples are also presented, including a brief mention of a German case involving Monika Schlensog, who disappeared into a psycho-sect. The article also references a story about Claude Vorilhon (Rael) and his claims of alien encounters in France.

The Hale-Bopp Connection and Media Spectacle

The comet Hale-Bopp is frequently cited as a catalyst or signifier for many of these UFO-related events and beliefs in 1997. The magazine notes how the comet's appearance fueled public interest and speculation, with some interpreting it as a harbinger of alien visitation or a cosmic event.

The role of media, including television programs and magazines like OMNI, is scrutinized for its part in popularizing UFO narratives and potentially contributing to the sensationalism surrounding the phenomenon. The article criticizes the commercialization of UFO topics, suggesting that some publications exploit the public's fascination for profit.

Anomalous Object in Deep Space

A section details the sighting of an anomalous object near Comet Hale-Bopp, photographed by amateur astronomer Chuck Shramek. The object, described as Saturn-like and self-luminous, sparked debate among astronomers and fueled speculation about it being a UFO or an alien spacecraft accompanying the comet.

The 'UFO-Kult' and its Consequences

The magazine emphasizes the dangers of unchecked belief in UFO cults, highlighting how they can lead to psychological manipulation, isolation from society, and ultimately, self-destructive behavior. It criticizes the 'ufological-esoteric' milieu for blurring the lines between genuine inquiry and irrational belief, which it argues has contributed to the tragic outcomes seen in cases like Heaven's Gate.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

This issue of CENAP REPORT adopts a critical stance towards UFO cults and what it perceives as the irrational and pseudo-religious aspects of UFOlogy. The editorial stance is one of skepticism towards claims of alien contact that are not scientifically verifiable. The magazine highlights the dangers of manipulation within these groups and criticizes the media for sensationalizing UFO phenomena. It advocates for a more scientific and grounded approach to understanding UFOs, distinguishing it from the more mystical and cult-like interpretations that have become prevalent. The recurring themes include the intersection of UFO beliefs with religion, esotericism, and apocalyptic narratives, as well as the psychological vulnerabilities that cults exploit.

This issue of CENAP REPORT, dated May/June 1997, delves into the complex intersection of cults, UFO phenomena, and the pervasive influence of the internet on end-time beliefs. The cover story, "Endzeit-Wahn aus dem Internet" (End-Times Delusion from the Internet), sets the tone for an exploration of how modern technology and societal anxieties fuel fringe beliefs.

Stigmatized and Skeptical Views

The issue begins with an examination of Giorgio Bongiovanni, a stigmatized individual whose claims are discussed by Dr. Michael Stellenwerk. Dr. Stellenwerk expresses skepticism regarding the physical evidence of Bongiovanni's wounds, noting that they do not conform to typical medical observations. Bongiovanni himself attributes the phenomena to a miracle, while Dr. Stellenwerk suggests a psychological or parapsychological explanation, aligning with the views of psychiatrist John Mack.

The Heaven's Gate Tragedy and UFOlogy

A significant portion of the magazine is dedicated to the Heaven's Gate cult's mass suicide in San Diego, which was linked to their belief in an approaching UFO associated with the Hale-Bopp comet. The article critiques how media outlets, including CNN, covered the event, often sensationalizing it and potentially fueling the 'UFO-wonder belief.' The role of figures like Uri Geller, who was interviewed by CNN, is questioned in relation to his claims of being 'PSI-enabled' and his past interactions with cult leader Marshall Applewhite.

Whitley Strieber's appearance on CNN's Larry King Live is also discussed, particularly his comments about the 'companion' to the Hale-Bopp comet, which the article suggests was a fabrication. The pervasive nature of UFO-related ideas in society is highlighted, with the suggestion that these beliefs are more prevalent than religious ones, leading some individuals to 'drift away.'

The Internet as a Breeding Ground for Beliefs

The magazine strongly criticizes the idea that the 'Higher Source' sect was a network of rational computer freaks. Instead, it posits that the internet, while not the sole cause, acts as a powerful amplifier for esoteric UFOlogy and its associated fantasies. The article points out that many people lack internet access, indicating that the roots of these beliefs lie deeper in esoteric UFOlogy and its distorted imagery.

The influence of the internet is further explored in the context of the Heaven's Gate tragedy, with discussions about how online platforms can be used to spread cult ideologies and recruit members. The article questions the media's portrayal of the cult members as simply 'X-Files' fans, suggesting a deeper underlying desperation and a search for meaning.

Critiques of UFOlogy and Skepticism

Several articles and commentaries express strong skepticism towards the UFO phenomenon and its proponents. The 'Gast-Kommentar' by Pfarrer Thomas Gandow highlights the destructive nature of cults, even those with a spiritual or UFO-centric focus, and contrasts them with mainstream religions. He argues that the modern search for meaning, exacerbated by societal anxieties, makes people vulnerable to such groups.

Alan Hale, a co-discoverer of the Hale-Bopp comet, is quoted extensively, expressing his disillusionment with the UFO field. He states that despite his lifelong interest in astronomy and extensive study, he has never encountered an object that could not be explained by conventional means. Hale criticizes the UFO community for embracing 'bizarre ideologies' and for lacking critical thinking, suggesting that many UFO claims are based on 'friend-of-a-friend' stories and a desire for sensationalism rather than evidence.

James Moseley, a long-time UFO chronicler, also voices his skepticism, stating he no longer believes in UFO landing stories or the Roswell incident. He argues that while people may see unexplained things, there is no concrete evidence of alien involvement, and that governments are not hiding such evidence.

The Billy Meier Case and Other UFO Claims

The issue also touches upon the case of Billy Meier, a Swiss UFO contactee, and his wife Kalliope Meier's public denunciation of his claims as a fabrication. This exposé is presented as evidence of how long-standing UFO narratives can be debunked.

Further skepticism is directed towards the alleged UFO footage and claims, such as the Apollo 11 'secret film,' which is dismissed as a series of images with light spots and audio transmissions from the LEM module. The article criticizes the Italian UFO organization CUN for promoting such questionable material and for its perceived lack of critical analysis.

The Role of Media and the 'Will to Believe'

The magazine consistently criticizes the media for its uncritical reporting on UFO phenomena, often sensationalizing events and failing to provide balanced perspectives. The 'will to believe' is identified as a driving force behind the acceptance of UFO claims, even in the face of rational explanations. The article suggests that many people seek adventure and excitement rather than truth, and that the media plays a significant role in fostering this environment.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

Throughout the issue, a strong theme of skepticism towards UFO claims and cult ideologies is evident. The editorial stance appears to be one of critical inquiry, urging readers to question sensational narratives and to seek evidence-based explanations. The magazine highlights the dangers of uncritical belief, particularly when amplified by the internet and sensationalized by the media. There is a clear emphasis on the need for critical thinking and rational analysis in understanding phenomena, contrasting this with the 'esoteric UFOlogy' and 'end-time delusions' that are seen as prevalent.

The issue concludes with a call for more professional and evidence-based research in the UFO field, while simultaneously acknowledging the difficulty of achieving this due to the deeply ingrained 'will to believe' among many proponents.