CENAP Report - No 198

Magazine Overview

This issue of CENAP REPORT, dated 9/92, is a German-language publication from CENAP, a Central Research Network for Extraordinary Celestial Phenomena. The cover prominently features "Projekt SETI" and images related to the AVRO and US Air Force, hinting at themes of extraterrestrial intelligence and advanced technology. The issue is dedicated to exploring "UFO Secrets and Lies," aiming to uncover the truth behind various UFO phenomena and alleged cover-ups.

Editorial Stance and Key Articles

The editorial, penned by Werner Walter, criticizes the media's tendency to ignore or sensationalize the UFO topic, contrasting it with CENAP's in-depth approach. Walter highlights the pervasive "mystery" surrounding UFOs and the alleged "cover-up" by powerful entities. He dismisses many popular UFO narratives, including those involving MJ-12 and Roswell, as rehashed sensationalism.

The 'Mel Noel' Story: A Case of Deception?

A significant portion of the magazine is dedicated to debunking the claims of "Mel Noel" (alias Guy Kirkwood/Bryce Cornwell), who presented himself as a former USAF pilot involved in UFO investigations. The article, drawing on research by John Keel and others, details how Cornwell's stories, including alleged encounters and involvement with a secret UFO group in Mexico, were found to be fabricated. Investigations by figures like Robert Dornan, a US Congressman, and UFO researcher Fritz Kron, revealed Cornwell lacked any verifiable military pilot record or relevant technical knowledge. The article suggests Cornwell's career was built on sensationalism and a desire for attention, possibly fueled by contactees like Narcisco Genovese.

Warminster Hoax: The Faulkner Photo Debunked

John Spencer of BUFORA presents a detailed investigation into the Warminster UFO phenomenon, specifically debunking the famous 1965 photograph of a flying saucer taken by Gordon Faulkner. Spencer argues that the photo was a hoax and that the entire Warminster event was surrounded by individuals who exploited the UFO craze for personal gain. Arthur Shuttlewood, a key figure in promoting the Warminster events, is implicated, with Spencer suggesting Shuttlewood may have been aware of the deception.

Gulf Breeze: More Questions Than Answers

The magazine also touches upon the Gulf Breeze UFO case, referencing the book by Ed Walters. It notes that the case, initially promoted by the Gulf Breeze Sentinel, has faced scrutiny. The article mentions that CBS Houston filmed "RUFOs" (Red Light UFOs) in the area, but suggests these might be flares or other conventional phenomena, cleverly disguised. The article points out that the book's sales have slowed after the UFO model and its discovery location became public, and a planned ABC-TV miniseries was canceled.

UFO Abductions: Statistics and Skepticism

Philip J. Klass's analysis of a Roper Organization survey on paranormal experiences is discussed. The survey indicated that 11% of Americans reported seeing a ghost, while only 7% reported a UFO sighting. The article questions the methodology and conclusions of studies on UFO abductions, particularly those by Budd Hopkins and David Jacobs. It highlights the psychological aspects, such as hypnagogic hallucinations, and suggests that alleged abduction experiences might be influenced by suggestion and pre-existing beliefs, rather than genuine extraterrestrial encounters.

The 'Alien Liaison' Book Review

A critical review of Timothy Good's book "Alien Liaison: The Ultimate Secret" is presented. The reviewer finds the book to be a compilation of unverified rumors and sensational claims, lacking rigorous research. While Good presents various UFO theories and alleged government involvement, the reviewer dismisses much of it as "foam-slapping" and "overvaluation." The book's claims about alien descriptions and the Roswell incident are also questioned for their inconsistencies.

UFO Technology and Camouflage

The issue briefly touches upon advanced UFO technology, referencing physicist Britchard's theories on "cloaking technologies" that could render UFOs invisible or project other shapes. This is linked to the Kornkreis (crop circle) phenomenon, suggesting UFOs might be responsible for their creation through advanced camouflage.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

Throughout the issue, a consistent theme is the skepticism towards sensational UFO claims and the alleged manipulation of public perception. CENAP REPORT positions itself as a source of critical analysis, aiming to separate fact from fiction in the often-unsubstantiated world of UFOlogy. The magazine criticizes the media for its superficial coverage and highlights the financial and personal motivations that can drive UFO proponents. The editorial stance is clearly one of critical inquiry, urging readers to question extraordinary claims and to look for evidence-based explanations, even when dealing with phenomena as enigmatic as UFOs.

This issue of UFO-Fibel, dated June 14, 1992, published by CENAP, delves into various UFO phenomena, hoaxes, and scientific investigations. The magazine explores the Warminster UFO photo incident, the SETI project, and recent UFO sightings and theories.

The Warminster UFO Photo Hoax

The issue details the famous Warminster UFO photograph, revealing it to be a deliberate hoax. Arthur Shutt lewood's book 'UFOs: Key to the New Age' is mentioned for its early inclusion of crop circle images. The Warminster phenomenon gained traction with Gordon Faulkner's photograph, taken on August 29, 1965. The article reveals that the photo was a staged event conceived by George Knock, the owner of the Weymouth Arms pub, and executed by Roger Hooton, with Faulkner photographing a model made from a milk bottle cap, buttons, and cotton wool. The intention was to amuse the editor of the Warminster Journal, Charles Mills, and to stir up local sentiment. The hoax was later amplified when the photo was published in the Daily Mirror, giving it international notoriety. The article criticizes the poor investigative practices of the time, which allowed such hoaxes to gain credibility.

UFOlogy and the Media

The media's reaction to UFO phenomena is discussed, noting the division between sensationalist reporting and more cautious, scientific approaches. The Warminster incident is cited as an example of how sensationalism can shape public perception, making the UFO topic seem less credible to some.

Operation: Right to Know

This section covers the first public UFO demonstration in Washington D.C. on March 28, 1992, organized by UFOlogists under the banner 'Operation: Right to Know'. The demonstration aimed to end UFO secrecy and cover-ups. While the MUFON UFO Journal hailed it as a success, the article notes it was supported by a small group of UFOlogists.

The French UFO Flap of 1990

Jean Sider and Irena Scott report on a significant UFO flap in France on November 5, 1990, described as the largest since 1954. Approximately 30,000 sightings were reported, with many describing triangular objects, diamonds, and spheres. The phenomena were observed to be silent, large, and flying at low altitudes. The French defense ministry's response, attributing some sightings to a Soviet re-entry vehicle, is questioned by Sider and Scott, who are critical of potential cover-ups.

Earthlight Theory and UFOs

Geophysicist John S. Derr is presented as proposing a new explanation for some UFO sightings: the 'Earthlight' theory. Based on his research, Derr suggests that underground stress and seismic activity can generate glowing balls of electricity, similar to ball lightning, which may be mistaken for UFOs. His findings, linking UFO sightings in New Mexico to earthquake epicenters, are met with skepticism but are also seen as a potentially interesting area for further scientific investigation.

SETI and the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence

The article discusses the SETI (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) project, highlighting the scientific community's efforts to detect signals from alien civilizations. Thomas R. McDonough, an astrophysicist and coordinator for SETI, explains the challenges, including filtering out terrestrial radio interference ('electro-smog'). He notes the difficulty in getting government support for SETI due to its association with UFO research. The role of Hollywood figures like Steven Spielberg in funding SETI is also mentioned. McDonough expresses a belief in the possibility of extraterrestrial life but cautions against equating SETI with UFO sightings, which he considers often unreliable and prone to hoaxes.

UFOs and Space Missions

Reports of mysterious objects observed during space missions are covered, including an incident near the Space Shuttle Atlantis in August 1991, where a 'flying bumper' object was filmed. The article also touches upon earlier sightings by astronauts, often explained as ice crystals or debris.

Crop Circles: Messages or Fakes?

An international conference on crop circles is described, where experts and skeptics debated the origin of these formations. While some, like James Dartford, believe they are messages from extraterrestrial intelligence urging environmental awareness, others, including artists Doug and Dave, have claimed to have faked some circles, raising questions about authenticity. The article notes the growing interest in crop circles as a phenomenon, linking it to the 'New Age' movement and the search for meaning in uncertain times.

UFOs as a Lecture Topic

Werner Walter of CENAP gave a well-attended lecture on UFOs in Nuremberg, sparking a lively discussion. Despite a lack of media coverage, the event drew over 120 attendees, highlighting the public's continued interest in the topic. The article suggests a growing openness to UFO research within astronomical institutions.

Book Review: 'Spuren im Korn'

A review of Jürgen Krönig's book 'Spuren im Korn' (Traces in the Grain) is included. The book is described as a comprehensive collection of information on crop circles, featuring numerous images and contributions from various authors. It explores connections between crop circles and UFO culture, while also acknowledging the socio-cultural aspects and the potential for human-made formations.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The magazine consistently questions the authenticity of UFO phenomena, distinguishing between genuine scientific inquiry and sensationalism or hoaxes. There's a critical stance towards unsubstantiated claims and a preference for evidence-based investigation. The editorial stance appears to be one of cautious skepticism, acknowledging the possibility of extraterrestrial intelligence while emphasizing the need for rigorous scientific methods and debunking fraudulent claims. The magazine also highlights the public's enduring fascination with UFOs and related mysteries.

This issue of "Neue Spezial" (Issue 30, 1992) delves into various aspects of UFO phenomena, experimental aircraft, and the skepticism surrounding these topics. The cover prominently features a dramatic illustration of a UFO landing on an aircraft carrier, hinting at the sensational content within.

The Avrocar: An Ambitious Failure

The lead article, "Irdische Fliegende Untertassen: The AVRO-Car," by William B. Blake, details the development and testing of the Avrocar VZ-9, an experimental flying saucer-like aircraft. Originally conceived by Avro Aircraft Limited of Canada, the project received significant funding from both the Canadian and US governments in the 1950s. The Avrocar, designed to be a VTOL (Vertical Take-Off and Landing) aircraft, was intended to be a six-meter diameter disc capable of high speeds. However, its first and only test on November 12, 1959, revealed severe stability and control problems that were never resolved. Despite attempts to test it in NASA wind tunnels, the Avrocar proved to be unstable and uncontrollable, barely achieving a meter in altitude during tests. The program was eventually canceled in December 1961 after an investment of $10 million. One of the prototypes was dismantled, while the other was sent to the Smithsonian.

The article also briefly mentions other related projects, such as Convair's large hovercraft-like vehicle for naval operations.

UFO Landing on an Aircraft Carrier: A Sensational Claim

Another section, "UFO LANDET AUF FLUGZEUGTRÄGER!" (UFO Lands on Aircraft Carrier!), discusses a story from the German publication "WEEKLY WORLD NEWS." This sensational claim, accompanied by elaborate photo manipulations, alleges a UFO landed on the deck of the US aircraft carrier NIMITZ in the Atlantic on February 18, 1992. The UFO is described as being as large as half a football field and 30 meters high. The story, attributed to "reliable sources" within the CIA, suggests the UFO was subsequently transported to NASA's Space Center at Cape Canaveral. The article notes the weakness of the story despite the striking visuals.

Mysterious Lights: Saratoga and Marfa

"Ghost Lights Of Texas" investigates unexplained luminous phenomena reported near Saratoga and Marfa, Texas. Herbert Lindeee, president of the Houston Association for Scientific Thinking, proposes that these "spuklichter" (ghost lights) are often misidentified headlights of vehicles on highways. He explains that the optical effects, combined with terrain features like small rises and dips, can create the illusion of lights hovering in the air. The article details Lindee's team's investigations in Saratoga, where they observed car headlights appearing and disappearing as vehicles navigated the landscape. Similarly, investigations into the Marfa Lights suggest they are also likely vehicle headlights, particularly those on the highway between Marfa and Presidio.

UFO Research and Skepticism

The issue features several articles discussing the broader landscape of UFO research and the role of skepticism.

"Neues von der Verschwörungs-Front" (News from the Conspiracy Front) touches upon theories presented at the "Phenomicon" conference, including claims that UFOs and aliens were fabricated by governments to distract from planned global dictatorships. It also mentions the idea that UFO technology was reverse-engineered from Nazi findings.

"12 Meldungen aus der Uckermark zu UFO-Sichtungen" (12 Reports from Uckermark on UFO Sightings) discusses a collection of UFO sighting reports from the Uckermark region of Germany. The article notes the formation of a UFO research group in Prenzlau and their efforts to exchange experiences and conduct scientific investigations.

"German journalist recounts sighting of mysterious lights" details a German journalist's experiences with mysterious lights in Florida, which he described as unusually bright and unlike any aircraft lights he had previously seen.

"Wie stoppt man Außerirdische?" (How to Stop Extraterrestrials?) reviews Sidney Sheldon's thriller "Die letzte Verschwörung" (The Last Conspiracy), which explores themes of alien invasion and government cover-ups.

"DER DR-SCHLONZ-REPORT: WIE DIE SKEPTIKER MANIPULIEREN!" (The Dr. Schlone Report: How Skeptics Manipulate!) presents a series of satirical cartoons illustrating how skeptics allegedly twist witness accounts and evidence to dismiss UFO phenomena. The cartoons depict skeptics attributing sightings to drunkenness, imagination, or misinterpretation.

Michael D. Swords' contribution discusses the biological and genetic differences between humans and potential extraterrestrial life forms, arguing against the possibility of human-alien hybrids and questioning the feasibility of interspecies genetic compatibility.

Other Content

The magazine also includes a section on "Ulrich Magin-Cartoons," which are well-received by readers for their humor and commentary on UFO topics. Additionally, there's a brief mention of a WDR television program that featured UFO cases and interviews with researchers.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are the exploration of unexplained aerial phenomena, the historical development of experimental aircraft designed to resemble UFOs, and the critical examination of UFO reports through a skeptical lens. The magazine appears to present a range of perspectives, from sensational claims and conspiracy theories to scientific investigations and debunking efforts. The editorial stance seems to be one of open inquiry, presenting various accounts and theories while also highlighting the challenges and potential for misinterpretation in UFO research. The inclusion of satirical cartoons suggests a critical, and perhaps slightly cynical, approach to both extreme believer and extreme skeptic viewpoints.