CENAP Report - No 011

Magazine Overview

Title: CENAP - REPORT
Issue: nr.11
Volume: 1J/H 1/77
Date: January 1977
Publisher: CENAP
Country: Germany
Language: German

This issue of the CENAP REPORT critically examines the phenomenon of UFO sightings and the role of psychics and media in reporting them. It questions the validity of psychic predictions and highlights the official stance of governmental bodies regarding UFO information.

Article 1: Doch keine Hellseher? (No Clairvoyants After All?)

This article debunks psychic and spiritualist claims that infiltrate the UFO research scene, likening them to medieval superstitions about ghosts and demons. It presents a series of unconfirmed predictions from various sources:

• UFO-Nachrichten (October 1965): An Argentinian astrologer predicted an invasion of flying saucers by the end of the year.
• Das Neue Zeitalter (1972): A clairvoyant, Käthe Wiessen, claimed UFOs exist and that 1973 would bring a sensational turn in UFO research, with official admissions of three different types of UFOs.
• Das Neue Zeitalter (1974): Käthe Niessen predicted UFOs would attack 'Rupeland' and Leningrad in November 1974, causing panic and serving as a warning against military actions.
• Das Neue Zeitalter (1975): This source suggested that extraterrestrial beings would hold a press conference in 1976 and land on Earth within three years, providing definitive proof of UFO existence and an advanced civilization.

The article also references predictions from Peter Hurkos and American media, including claims of alien return after 19-22 months, landings in Arizona and New Mexico, and government admissions of UFO existence. It mentions a prediction by Jeanne Dixon about 'superhumans' from the cosmos landing on Earth by autumn 1977 to teach humanity about overcoming disease, hunger, and war.

Article 2: Berichte aus Dänemark (Reports from Denmark)

This section presents UFO sighting reports from Danish newspapers, translated for the CENAP audience.

• September 19, 1975: A strongly luminous object was observed moving at high speed over Harmerfest, Denmark. A witness described it as brighter than the strongest stars. Another witness reported a long, meteor-like trail and a sudden stop before accelerating rapidly.
• October 11, 1975: Frau Birgit Møller reported seeing a strongly luminous, orange, half-moon-shaped object hovering over the Haderslev pond. She initially mistook it for a house fire.

Article 3: Berichte aus Dänemark (Continued)

• January 26, 1976: In Ridsvoll, Norway, people observed a luminous object, described as a large luminous sphere, flying at low altitude and slowly from West-Northwest to East-Southeast. It had a core and no visible propulsion, and did not leave a fiery trail like a meteor.
• January 26, 1976 (continued): In Gidsvoll, Norway, a lagerleiter observed a strange object with a blue-green corona at an altitude of 2-3 meters, moving slowly. It disappeared backwards after two minutes and could not be explained naturally.
• April 10, 1976: In Ishøj, Denmark, a dark, boomerang-shaped grey object was observed moving at a speed of 500-700 km/h.

Article 4: Presse - News (Press - News)

This section compiles news items related to UFOs.

• Meteorite-related fire: A report from June 17, 1778 (sic, likely a typo for 1978), mentions British monks observing a fire and a 'flaming phenomenon' attributed by a New York meteorite researcher, Dr. Jack D. Hartung, to a meteorite impact. The article notes that Hartung's research suggests the event was caused by the collision of unknown objects.
• Book Advertisement: An advertisement for a book titled 'Das Geheimnis der unbekannten Flugobjekte' (The Secret of Unknown Flying Objects) by Adolf Schneider and Hubert Elias, promising a comprehensive photo documentation of UFOs from around the world.

Article 5: Eine weitere Anfrage (Another Inquiry)

This section details an inquiry made by CENAP to the German Federal Ministry of Defense regarding UFO information.

• Inquiry: CENAP, through its staff member Herbert Gallisch jun., inquired about UFO information held by government agencies.
• Ministry Response (November 5, 1976): The Ministry of Defense, represented by Oberst i.G. Griese, responded that they have no findings on the existence of UFOs within the Bundeswehr or NATO. They stated that all unknown phenomena have natural explanations (e.g., weather balloons, bird flocks) and that the scientific proof for UFO existence is still pending. The Ministry suggested the inquirer discuss the topic with their physics teacher.

Article 6: CENAP - Press Release

This section discusses CENAP's efforts to obtain UFO information from official sources.

• Inquiry to US Embassy (September 27, 1976): Werner Walter of CENAP wrote to the US Air Force Attaché in Bonn requesting information on UFOs.
• US Embassy Response (October 8, 1976): The Defense Attaché Office of the US Embassy in Bonn replied that they had no UFO research information and forwarded the request to Washington D.C.
• Further US Response (December 3, 1976): The US Embassy provided the 'U.S. Air Force UFO Fact Sheet,' which mentioned the conclusion of Project BLUE BOOK investigations and the availability of data in the National Archive. CENAP notes that this information is already known through publications by Adolf Schneider and Axel Artelt.
• Inquiry to French Embassy (September 27, 1976): CENAP also contacted the French Air Force Attaché in Bonn.
• French Embassy Response (October 26, 1976): The Scientific Counselor of the French Embassy informed CENAP that the letter was passed to the Air Force Attaché and subsequently to Mr. Foher, an engineer at the Centre National d'Etudes Spatiales in Toulouse, who is considered highly competent in UFO research. Mr. Foher was suggested to contact CENAP.

The article concludes with a statement by Werner Walter: "The great UFO confusion continues..." and a call for translators for foreign languages.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are the skepticism towards psychic predictions concerning UFOs, the presentation of documented UFO sightings, and the critical examination of official responses from government and military bodies. CENAP's editorial stance appears to be one of critical inquiry, debunking unsubstantiated claims while diligently pursuing verifiable information from official sources, even if those sources are often unforthcoming or dismissive. The magazine highlights the perceived 'confusion' surrounding UFO phenomena and the challenges in obtaining concrete information from authorities.

This issue of CENAP-Dokumentation, titled "UFO-Fung? 2.Teil," published in November 1976, critically examines various aspects of the UFO phenomenon. It features a skeptical approach to 'contactee' reports and details a case that was exposed as a hoax, alongside an analysis of photographic evidence.

Contactee Reports and Skepticism

The issue begins by referencing a lecture by Dr. Mart, noting its interesting aspects for UFO research enthusiasts but also pointing out a perceived naive approach. A significant portion of the text is dedicated to the "DUIST-Einstellung" (DUIST's stance) on contactees, quoting Dr. G. Froese who emphasizes the need for an objective and critical approach, stating, "It is not all gold that glitters, nor is it all that runs under the heading of high 'UFO' messages... we are indeed obliged to maintain an objective-critical attitude..." The author criticizes DUIST for not living up to this principle, suggesting that acknowledging contactees is a simple system to gain acceptance within their circles, while dissenters are marginalized.

Dr. Froese's analysis of the Angelucci contact case is presented, highlighting its "high moral-religious value and a factual intelligent presentation." However, the author implies that such reports are often labeled as "serious presentations" without sufficient scrutiny. The text questions why both Eastern and Western superpowers would invest billions in investigating phenomena already pointed out by contactees.

Further discussion on contactee literature, such as that by "Söhne Naros," suggests these writings form the foundation of knowledge about beings on other planets. The article notes that contactees are often described not as ordinary people but as "incarnated planetary souls" assisting in UFO research. The skepticism of figures like Professor Bender from Freiburg, a parapsychology expert, is mentioned. Bender reportedly described George Adamski's report as a "mysterious report" and Angelucci's book as a "factual report," suggesting that such accounts can confuse listeners rather than provide clear enlightenment.

The issue also touches upon advice given to UFO researchers by "planetarians" to study esoteric literature and the Bible, and the urgency with which "planetarians" seek help from knowledgeable individuals to prevent panic when they "appear in masses in the sky." The text implies this is done to keep UFO believers engaged and financially supportive.

The Waldshut Case: A Hoax Exposed

A substantial part of the magazine is dedicated to an investigation of the "Waldshut case," which involved alleged UFO sightings and photographs. The CENAP team initially sought information from various UFO groups and individuals regarding a potential wave of sightings in Southern Germany in July 1976. Despite initial difficulties in obtaining information due to security concerns, the CENAP team, particularly the author as a specialist in this case, worked to gather and analyze facts.

The case began with a letter from H.E. from Gundelfingen, informing CENAP about the founding of a UFO research center in Freiburg. Two photocopies of alleged UFO sightings from the Waldshut area were provided by witnesses H.P. and V.B. Further information from this source was limited.

CENAP sent out questionnaires to the witnesses and searched newspaper archives for information. However, the media at the time were preoccupied with the Olympic Games and did not report on the phenomenon. CENAP received further reports, including one from N.R. in Freiburg, which raised suspicions due to its "science fiction" elements. The author noted that the witnesses, including M.Ran, seemed to be part of a group called "Space of Galaxy" and shared similar science fiction interests. Attempts to obtain internal information from the leader of this group, R. in Lüneburg, were unsuccessful.

Despite receiving and analyzing CENAP questionnaires, the skepticism of the CENAP team was not alleviated. A letter from G.H. in Waldshut-Tiengen, along with photographic slides, was received. This witness was described as a "perfectionist" who provided many details. The witness also named another individual, A.Jound, who was also from Waldshut-Tiengen. Both witnesses claimed not to know each other previously but had similar professions and interests.

Following correspondence, Herr H. (presumably G.H.) became the spokesperson. The photos were copied and sent to a contact in the USA (Ground Saucer Watch) for computer analysis. The CENAP team developed a theory that the photos were trick photos, created by cutting black paper or cardboard and attaching it to a car window, with the background being the landscape outside. Characteristic features like the lack of a third dimension and the presence of adhesive residue were noted.

When CENAP confronted the witnesses with their suspicions, G.H. initially admitted it was a "bluff" intended to test CENAP's objectivity. However, after CENAP threatened legal action due to the potential costs of analysis (up to $210), G.H. retracted the bluff claim and insisted the material was real. This retraction further eroded the witnesses' credibility. CENAP managed to prevent the analysis of the photos just in time.

UFO Photography and Analysis

The issue highlights a spectacular UFO photograph taken in April 1974 by Japanese press photographer Tsutomu Nakayama in Hawaii. The director of JOUFON analyzed the photo, describing the object as "solid and flying." Nakayama, a 29-year-old press photographer, was in Hawaii to photograph traditional HULA dances. He focused on the subject matter, not the background.

The analysis of the photograph details the time, location, weather, and camera settings. The object is described as having a "disk-like" shape with a "domed hull" on its upper side and a "wavy surface" on the bottom. It is estimated to be 10-12 meters in diameter and moved approximately 2 meters forward during the exposure time, resulting in an average speed of 400 m/sec.

The object is considered to be of extraterrestrial origin, lacking any known terrestrial aircraft features like wings or jet engines. The article notes that similar objects have been photographed and filmed worldwide. The speed recorded is compared to the speed of the Concorde and a later sighting in 1975 near Stockton, California, where a similar object was observed by a US Coast Guard major.

The CENAP editorial notes that this Hawaii photo is among the best UFO photos in their archive, with two similar objects identified in photos from Namur, Belgium, and Nagora/Steiermark, Austria. A potential similar sighting from 1954 at Edwards Air-Force Base in California is also mentioned.

SETI and the Risk of Contact

The final section discusses NASA's efforts to search for extraterrestrial intelligence through the SETI project, specifically mentioning Frank Drake's transmission of a radio signal towards Messier 13 in the constellation Hercules in 1974. The signal, consisting of "pictograms" as navigational aids, was intended to be received by intelligent beings on a planet 24,000 light-years away.

However, the article highlights a protest against such endeavors, led by physicist and Nobel laureate Sir Fred Hoyle. In a message to the International Astronomical Union (IAU), Hoyle urged colleagues to cease activities that could reveal humanity's existence, fearing that it could lead to galactic colonization and the exploitation of Earth's resources. The article concludes by stating that such radio messages should only be sent when there is international consensus and a clear understanding of the implications of contact with extraterrestrial beings.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

This issue of CENAP-Dokumentation consistently adopts a critical and analytical stance towards UFO phenomena. It demonstrates a strong skepticism towards unsubstantiated claims, particularly those from contactees, and actively investigates and exposes hoaxes, as exemplified by the Waldshut case. The magazine values photographic evidence but subjects it to rigorous analysis, as seen with the Hawaii photograph. The editorial stance appears to be one of cautious inquiry, seeking factual evidence while remaining wary of sensationalism and potential risks associated with the search for extraterrestrial intelligence, as highlighted by the discussion on the SETI project and Sir Fred Hoyle's concerns.

Title: CENAP
Issue: 52/1976
Date: December 27, 1976 (derived from issue number and year)
Publisher: DER SPIEGEL (as source of an article)
Country: Germany
Language: German

This issue of CENAP, a publication focused on extraordinary phenomena, delves into the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) and related scientific endeavors. It includes a discussion of radio astronomy, the potential for communication across vast distances, and a specific photograph of an unidentified object.

Content Analysis

The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI)

The magazine opens with a discussion about the possibility of a 'supersivilization' not attempting to contact Earth, suggesting that Earth has been broadcasting signals into space for about 50 years since entering the 'radio age.'

Several points are enumerated, likely as a list or explanation of concepts related to SETI:

1. Numbers 1 to 10 in relation to something.
2. A schematic representation of chemical elements.
3. Chemical structure of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA).
4. A diagram illustrating the double helix structure of DNA.
5. A depiction of a human figure, possibly indicating scale or comparison.
6. Information about the population of Earth and related links.
7. The solar system.
8. An antenna for a radio telescope with size specifications.

The text then elaborates on the possibility of life in solar systems millions of light-years away, referencing books by authors like Carl Sagan and Bill Haley. It notes that while some scientists believe in the possibility of life, others remain skeptical. The sheer scale of the universe and the number of stars and potential planets are highlighted as reasons for continued investigation.

The possibility of receiving 'intelligent signals' is discussed, with the Arecibo radio telescope theoretically capable of detecting such signals. The article mentions the SETI project and the significant funding it receives, including from NASA. The project aims to deploy 1500 radio telescopes, each with a 100-meter diameter, with a potential 'Cyclops' site in the German state of Bavaria.

Radio Astronomy and the 'Water Hole'

The magazine details the work of radio telescopes, including those in the United States, involved in the 'Sesi' (Search for Extraterrestrial Signals) project. The University of California (Vola) has developed a special computer program to analyze cosmic signals from NASA's 'Deep Space Network.' This program is designed to identify ordered structures that might indicate intelligent origin.

The 'Sesi' computer is capable of simultaneously processing six million radio frequencies, focusing on the range between 1420 and 1662 MHz, known as the 'water hole.' This frequency band is significant because it lies between the emission frequencies of hydrogen (1420 MHz) and hydroxyl (1662 MHz), two fundamental components of water, which is considered essential for life. The 'water hole' is seen as a potential universal communication channel.

Potential for Contact and the Nature of Extraterrestrial Life

The article discusses the chances of a 'rendezvous' with extraterrestrial civilizations in the 'water hydrogen' (likely referring to the hydrogen line). It suggests that such beings might be similar to 'cosmic Yotis' (possibly a typo or reference to a specific concept). The possibility of detecting such signals is considered high, and it is estimated that with an increased capacity of the SETI project to one billion channels, an interesting signal might be detected within ten years.

Astronomer Drake is quoted speculating about the nature of potential alien civilizations. He suggests that they might be concerned with overcoming mortality, perhaps by achieving immortality themselves, implying a highly advanced and perhaps 'fanatical' drive for self-preservation.

Unidentified Object Photograph

A significant part of the issue is dedicated to a photograph taken on August 17, 1973, by Ryo Teromotu on Bali Island, Indonesia. The photograph clearly shows an unidentified object in a landscape. An arrow points to the object, highlighting it for the viewer. The CENAP archive is credited for this image.

Source and Context

An article excerpted from DER SPIEGEL (Issue 52/1976) is included, featuring a drawing of a radio telescope array labeled 'Cyclops.' The excerpt includes a quote from Drake: "Their best insurance is to make others immortal like themselves." The contact information for CENAP is provided, listing Hansjürgen Köhler and Werner Walter with their respective addresses in Mannheim, Germany.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are the scientific search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI), the significance of radio astronomy in this endeavor, and the potential characteristics of advanced alien civilizations. The magazine also highlights photographic evidence of unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP), suggesting an open-minded approach to unexplained events. The editorial stance appears to be one of scientific curiosity and exploration, encouraging the investigation of possibilities beyond conventional understanding, while grounding the discussion in scientific projects and theories like the Drake Equation and the 'water hole' frequency.