CENAP Newsflash - No 22

Magazine Overview

CENAP - NEWSFLASH, Ausgabe Nr. 22, November 2006, is a German-language publication from Mannheim, serving as an 'UFO-Depesche' (UFO dispatch). It is described as one of the oldest German, non-commercial UFO journals, operating as a private publication. The issue's cover features three vintage comic book covers related to science fiction and space themes: 'Atom-Age Combat' featuring Buck Vinson, 'Biggles and the Menace from Space', and 'Aventuras de la Vida Real' with 'Los Platillos Voladores'. The main headline on the cover is 'Die UFO-Depesche aus Mannheim'.

CENAP Report and Editorial Stance

Page 2 provides details about CENAP (Das Centrale Erforschungsnetz Außergewöhnlicher Himmelsphänomene), an organization established in 1976. CENAP is a private, non-commercial, and ideologically independent entity dedicated to receiving, analyzing, and evaluating reports of alleged unidentified flying objects (UFOs) with a critical approach. It is associated with the GWUP (Society for the Scientific Investigation of the Paranormal) and the Gesellschaft für Anomalistik. CENAP collaborates with various national and international institutions, maintains a UFO video archive, and aims to conduct public education and demystification efforts through media, universities, planetariums, and public discussions.

The 'Impressum' identifies Werner Walter as the publisher and editor, located in Mannheim.

"O' zapft is!" - Editorial Introduction

The editorial, titled "Zum CENAP-Newsflash Nr.22 - 'O' zapft is!'", reflects on the nature of UFOlogy and the CENAP Newsflash itself. The author acknowledges that the publication might not be universally popular among UFOlogists, likening it to an 'ugly duckling'. The editorial criticizes certain aspects of the UFO community, portraying some as being in a 'research 'day clinic'' with a 'dark shadow', where 'patients' meet 'ufological doctors' and engage in self-talk and confusion. It suggests that the Newsflash aims to present 'nonsense' and 'helplessness' as a deterrent, critically examining UFOlogy as part of the UFO phenomenon. The publication seeks to explain backgrounds, critically analyze, and expose shortcomings within the UFOlogy scene, recognizing the complex web of relationships and interactions that influence ufological discourse and political performance.

The editorial emphasizes that their work, despite breaking taboos, aims to benefit and orient the 'consumer', acting as 'consumer protection' for those interested in UFOs. The CENAP Newsflash is presented as a guide through the 'thicket' of UFO topics, employing satire in its journalistic approach to examine the 'entangled' history and unique 'sovereignty' and 'sensitivity' required. The goal is to open the eyes of those interested in the UFO phenomenon to form their own opinions, distinguishing between knowledge and information. It contrasts this with 'contrary interested circles' who react with anger, possibly for the protection of the 'ufological empire'.

Critical Examination of UFOlogy and Belief

Pages 3 and 4 delve deeper into the author's critical perspective on UFOlogy. The author questions the value of engaging with the UFO topic, noting how some individuals become overly emotional and create 'enemies' and 'scapegoats'. The piece suggests that the CENAP and its publications aim to address an 'educational deficit' and encourage a reform of outdated ideas. It argues that the UFO question does not need an 'ufological ideology monster' but rather a synthesis of fundamental findings across all levels. The author acknowledges that practical reality differs from theoretical approaches, highlighting human fallibility as a constant weakness in UFO discussions. The publication's sober and demystifying approach is contrasted with the more alluring, fictional aspects of UFOlogy, drawing a parallel to superficial attractiveness over character.

The editorial discusses the 'ufological fundamentalism' and the 'end battle for UFOlogy' that some individuals feel compelled to engage in, comparing it to the radicalization of monotheistic beliefs. It asserts that UFO phenomenon research is not a mere 'cold' but a serious endeavor. The author expresses a personal lack of joy in belief but finds engagement with the UFO topic a 'social commitment' due to its fundamental role in the phenomenon. The author reflects on the human need for belief and meaning in an increasingly complex world, seeing the spiritual search for a counterbalance to neoliberalism's focus on economic values.

UFO-Thema and Public Perception

Page 5 discusses the human search for belief and meaning, linking it to the complexities of the modern world and the search for something that resonates with individual identity. It critiques the focus on economic growth and the resulting 'crazy conspiracy theories' as a form of rebellion against the establishment. The author recounts an experience on an internet UFO forum where a photo of a 'sky anomaly over Oklahoma' sparked debate, with some suggesting it was a 'teleportation/dimensional portal' or even 'God in the form of a bubble'. The author points out that the phenomenon was likely a simple 'sun dog' effect, highlighting how the lack of knowledge about common atmospheric phenomena (IFO - Identified Flying Objects) hinders understanding of UFOs.

Analysis of UFO Phenomena and Skepticism

Page 6 continues the critique, using the 'sun dog' example to illustrate how UFOlogists often fail to recognize or explain known phenomena. The author mentions that even UFO researchers like M. Hesemann did not offer a clear solution, while Jörg Böhme sarcastically questioned the seriousness of the 'portal-tor' discussion. The piece notes that the VdS (Vereinigung der Sternfreunde) had previously documented the 'sun dog' phenomenon, but UFO enthusiasts often avoid such factual information, fearing the loss of their 'magic'. The author laments that UFOlogy has been in a 'lopsided' state for a long time, with topics often relegated to 'entertainment'. The article quotes Lawrence M. Krauss, a Professor of Physics and Astronomy, emphasizing the importance of scientific methodology and accepting the universe as it is, rather than constructing it based on personal theories.

UFO and UFOlogy Surveys

Pages 6, 7, and 8 detail various surveys related to UFOs and belief systems. An 'UFOzine' survey conducted by Dennis Kirstein in late 2005 revealed that only 11% of respondents found a focus on the UFO phenomenon desirable in such a magazine. Other interests included Pre-Astronautics (9%), myths and legends (8%), conspiracy theories (8%), flying saucers (7%), secret societies (7%), crop circles (7%), PSI (6%), and cryptozoology (6%).

Another survey, conducted in August 2006 by Paranews.net, asked about expectations for current UFO research in Germany. The results were not detailed in the provided text, but the author criticizes the survey's design and execution as amateurish and possibly leading to skewed results. The survey received 286 votes, with 73 participants wanting more publications, 71 questioning if UFO research is conducted in Germany, and 23 wanting more exposure of fakes. 24 people desired more collaboration, and 10 wanted more sighting reports, suggesting that the quantity of reports might be overwhelming.

Pages 8 and 9 present a more substantial survey published by the National Geographic TV Channel on July 31, 2006, titled "Außerirdische" (Extraterrestrials). This national, representative telephone poll of 1000 Americans over 18 years old explored beliefs about extraterrestrial life. Key findings included: 60% of respondents believed in extraterrestrial life. When asked about the timeline for confirming extraterrestrial life, 38% believed it would happen in the next decades, and 34% in the next century. Regarding reactions to the discovery of extraterrestrial life, 72% expected to feel 'excited and hopeful', while 20% anticipated feeling 'anxious and nervous'. The survey also probed beliefs about the number of planets with life, the conditions under which life could develop, and the likelihood of extraterrestrial life evolving to stages like microbes, plants, animals, and intelligent beings. A significant portion (77%) believed life could exist on planets with very different conditions than Earth. The survey also touched upon the possibility of advanced extraterrestrial civilizations possessing technology for interstellar travel and communication, with 90% of those who believed in extraterrestrial life wanting to respond to any potential communication.

Roswell and UFO Research Critiques

Page 10 discusses the "E.T.-Umfrage" and its implications for understanding the American imagination regarding UFOs. It references Dennis Balthaser's report on the declining visitor numbers at the Roswell International UFO Museum and the annual Roswell UFO Festival in 2006. The article notes that attendance at music events associated with the festival had drastically decreased, and overall visitor numbers were at their lowest. The author suggests that the 'Roswell Daily Record' regretted the poor organization of the festival. It is mentioned that Roswell once had three UFO museums, but now only one remains, which charges an entrance fee.

The article also includes a quote from Michael Hesemann, emphasizing that a scientist trained in scientific methodology can research any field seriously. However, the author critiques the practice of some 'UFO academics' who, despite their titles, fail to apply rigorous methods, leading to a 'belief or superstition phenomenon'. The piece touches upon the veneration of religious relics, referencing Pope Benedict XVI's visit to Manoppello to venerate the 'Holy Face' of Jesus, a relic that is highly controversial.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

Throughout the issue, a recurring theme is the critical examination of UFOlogy, distinguishing between genuine scientific inquiry and unsubstantiated belief or speculation. The publication advocates for a rational, evidence-based approach, often contrasting it with what it perceives as the more sensationalist or ideologically driven aspects of the UFO community. The editorial stance is clearly skeptical, aiming to demystify the UFO phenomenon and encourage informed public discourse. The surveys presented serve to highlight public beliefs and attitudes, often juxtaposing them with the critical analysis offered by CENAP. The issue also touches upon broader themes of belief, human psychology, and the search for meaning in a complex world, framing these within the context of UFO research.

This issue of CENAP Newsflash, dated November 2006, delves into the complex relationship between faith, relics, and the field of ufology. It critically examines how belief systems operate, drawing parallels between the veneration of religious artifacts and the acceptance of UFO phenomena.

The Nature of Belief and Relics

The publication begins by discussing the concept of relics, using examples like the Shroud of Turin and the 'Blood Miracle of Naples.' It posits that even fabricated or disputed relics can hold immense symbolic power and influence believers, functioning as 'super-powerful symbols of faith.' The article draws a direct comparison to 'faked' UFO photos and cases, suggesting they continue to exert influence on the UFO community in a similar manner.

It highlights how the 'church' often tolerates phenomena that strengthen faith, even if they are not officially recognized, drawing a parallel to how 'trickster' UFO images and cases are presented as genuine UFO 'proof' by interested parties. The article points to the Meier photos and other films as examples that gain a similar level of reverence among UFO enthusiasts.

The Fehrenbach Case and the 'Alien Autopsy' Film

The issue scrutinizes specific instances within ufology. The MUFON-CES case involving the Fehrenbach incident is presented as an example where UFO 'scientists' were allegedly fooled by a simple plastic toy. The article notes that Fehrenbach himself reportedly made light of the situation, attributing it to political expediency. Similarly, the 'Alien Autopsy' film is criticized, with the article stating that an initial 'trick' suspicion was ignored, and a panel of 'experts' later 'confirmed' the presence of a formerly living being, a conclusion the authors deemed incorrect.

The 'Rotten Meat Scandal' Analogy

A significant portion of the text draws an analogy between the 'rotten meat scandal' and the UFO field. It argues that in both scenarios, experts (food control officials in the scandal, and UFO 'scientists' in the other) may overlook critical issues. The scandal, it is noted, was only brought to light through anonymous tips, not by the specialists themselves. The article questions how much UFO 'case material' might be similarly misclassified, like 'filet' being passed off as 'rotten meat.'

Relics and Modern Veneration

The publication further explores the concept of relics, referencing the 'Holy Veronica' cloth and the 'Shroud of Turin.' It discusses how these items, whether genuine or not, are imbued with meaning and serve as focal points for belief. The article notes that even 'fake' or 'trickster' images and phenomena can maintain their impact on a 'believing community.'

The Role of Symbolism and 'New Age' Faith

The text delves into the significance of relics within Christian tradition and their connection to 'superstition' and 'faith.' It references an academic paper by Elke Beilfuß on the origin of relic veneration, noting that the 'packaging' of relics (reliquaries) also holds a mysterious and precious quality. This is directly compared to the 'UFO evidence corpus' for the UFO community, where the spiritual significance of UFO photos and films is central, carrying 'political' and ideological weight.

The article likens 'shrines' to UFO portals, books, and magazines, where believers embark on 'pilgrimages.' It identifies crop circles as modern 'sites of miraculous signs.' The author suggests that for many modern adherents of esotericism, these 'artworks' are part of a 'relic system' crucial to their 'New Age' faith, emphasizing the symbolic value and inner power attributed to them.

The 'Madonna Weeping Tears' Phenomenon

During the 'crop circle' hysteria starting in 1994, the article notes that in Catholic Italy, statues of the Madonna began to weep bloody tears, particularly around Easter and Ascension Day. This is framed as a manifestation of specific human cultic behavior, with Andre Heller quoted as saying, 'The world is full of small miracles, you just have to reach for them.' The article suggests that individuals seek personal association with 'heavenly events' to identify themselves as observers, leading to a 'prostrate, negating adoration of the art object.' This is described as the 'cult of relics' and their perceived 'holiness.'

Sexuality and Belief

A brief section touches upon sexuality, stating that it is a powerful drive that is often suppressed by belief systems to channel energy into other 'achievements' that hold similar power.

Historical Control of Information

The issue highlights how, historically, rulers have sought to control information that might contradict religious doctrines. An example is given of an 18th-century French king who tasked Jean-Francois Champollion with ensuring that any discoveries related to Egyptian antiquities that contradicted the Catholic Church's teachings were not publicized.

The Bundeslade (Ark of the Covenant) and Relic Trade

The 'Bundeslade' (Ark of the Covenant) with the Ten Commandments is presented as a precursor to all holy relics. The veneration of martyrs and their remains ('reliquiae') is traced back to an intensified ancient death cult. Relics were objects of veneration, believed to provide a connection to the deceased and a means of intercession, bestowing a 'healing power' or 'virtus.' They were seen as an earthly manifestation of the heavenly powers attributed to saints, capable of performing miracles.

The article notes that relics became objects of a significant European trade, requiring protection against theft and fraud. The Council of Trent confirmed the relic cult but also sought to address abuses. The Baroque period and the 19th century saw heightened displays of these relics, with a focus on the visual aspect. This is compared to the theme of 'Flying Saucers have landed,' which similarly had impacts on art and literature.

Pope John Paul II and Sainthood

The text discusses the process of sainthood for Pope John Paul II, noting that it requires proof of two miracles. It mentions that while many reports of miracles surrounding him exist, none have been officially recognized yet. The Vatican and external experts are scrutinizing these claims, and the article points out that even papal pronouncements of sainthood have been revoked in history if the 'saints' did not actually exist.

'Miracle' Verification Process

The 'Sacra Congregation' (now Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith) is described as having a process where 'relators' are appointed to review claims of miracles. In a 'legalistic process,' arguments for and against are presented. Pater Peter Gumpel is mentioned as a member of a committee that reviews these claims, stating that out of 20-25 discussions per year, 90% of reported miracles are dismissed in the initial investigation. Of the remaining 10%, further cases are eliminated, emphasizing the thoroughness of the examination.

UFOlogy and the 'Mr. Spock' Analogy

The article draws a parallel between the verification of miracles and the search for UFO phenomena, suggesting that the quest for 'Mr. Spock' or similar phenomena from unknown dimensions is a 'hard and tough job.'

Explanation from 'WW'

A quote from 'WW' (likely referring to Werner Walter) states that understanding 'miracles' involves clarifying them, rather than falling into a 'Pippi Longstocking' view where one constructs the world as they please, because the 'real world' quickly overtakes such fantasies.

'Pitfall' UFOlogy

This section addresses 'attempts at alienation' and 'solidarity' within the UFO community. It mentions the 'Cröffelbacher UFO-Runde 2006' and an 'official' boycott call based on anger and false pride regarding the 'ufological no-go area.' The author notes that a 'WW-Report' was criticized as 'personal hate and scientific garbage,' while another assessment praised H. Hesemann's 'profound knowledge' and criticized WW's 'hot air' and 'discriminatory insults.'

The 'Rattlesnake' Analogy

The article uses the term 'rattlesnake' to describe someone perceived as manipulative and untrustworthy, referencing Bob Lazar and a forum participant's reaction to a comment about him.

UFOlogy as a 'Brake Block'

The author expresses the view that ufology has become a 'brake block' for UFO phenomenon research. He suggests that the field, for dramatic reasons, seems to welcome skeptics, creating a 'good versus evil' narrative. The 'action' in ufological adventures is provided by alien encounters and 'flying saucers,' along with associated elements like cattle mutilations and conspiracies, all contributing to a 'stage-ready' spectacle.

The 'Benedict XVI and Islam Reaction' Analogy

This section discusses the controversy surrounding Pope Benedict XVI's speech at Regensburg University, where he quoted a medieval text suggesting Islam spread through violence. The article notes that radical Muslim fanatics reacted with outrage, leading to violence against Christians and churches, and calls for an attack on Rome. This is described as a paradox where the Pope's words were distorted and taken out of context by the media, fueling hatred.

Media Misrepresentation

It is argued that the media in the Arab world, particularly through outlets like Al Jazeera, presented a shortened and distorted version of the Pope's speech, leading to widespread anger based on hearsay. The ZDF program 'Frontal 21' is mentioned as having analyzed this media coverage, concluding that it was consistently inaccurate and focused on giving a platform to hate preachers.

Political and Cultural Undercurrents

The text links the reactions to the Pope's speech to a broader sense of the Arab world facing Western political and economic dominance, and a perceived 'ideological earthquake' attempting to 'inundate' Islamic culture. The author notes that in the post-9/11 era, heightened sensitivity is required, and criticizes US President Bush's 'utopian' vision of military control.

'Star Trek' and Missionarism

The article draws a parallel between the political rhetoric and the 'civilizational optimism' of the 'Star Trek' complex. It suggests that the principle of non-interference, traditionally favored by Republicans, has been abandoned in favor of a 'missionary forced democratization' of other countries.

UFOlogy and the 'Cröffelbach UFO Days 2006'

The publication addresses the 'Cröffelbach UFO Days 2006' event and a preceding 'hate' that seemed to underlie many expressions of discontent. Some UFOlogy promoters reportedly viewed the event with disgust, seeing it as a gathering of 'UFO terrorists.'

'Skeptic' vs. 'Believer' Divide

The article touches upon a dispute within the Alien.de forum, where it was labeled a 'skeptic forum.' The author states that the history of UFO phenomena also serves as a projection surface for various desires, particularly in 'esoteric ufology' with its contactees and 'channels.' The text emphasizes the importance of maintaining a clear line of research, distinguishing between substance and mere spectacle.

The UFOlogy Market and CENAP's Position

The author reflects on CENAP's position in the UFO market, stating that it has carved out a niche and is now in a better position than 15 years prior. However, ufology as a whole, the author contends, has lost its influence in the public sphere. The author notes that after 33 years of involvement in UFO research, the significant 'Rock 'n' Roll' experience has not come from UFO sightings themselves, but from interactions with representatives of the UFOlogy community, which is deemed insufficient for proving the UFO phenomenon.

'Rabbi Jakob' and the Cröffelbach Conference

This section addresses a ufological 'Rabbi Jakob' who allegedly criticized the 'radical UFO deniers' and Werner Walter for attempting to discredit the upcoming Cröffelbach meeting with 'vulgar insults and insinuations.' The article notes that this 'hate campaign' attracted attention.

'Schwulen- und Lesbenkonferenz' Accusation

The article refutes an accusation that the Frankfurt D.U.-Conference in 1989 was 'defamed' as a 'gay and lesbian conference.' It clarifies that the original text merely suggested the term 'DU-Konferenz' evoked associations with such events, a point that was apparently misinterpreted and became a source of trauma.

The 'UFO-Baron' and Sexpraktiken

It is recounted that following an article by Rudolf Henke about a TV talk show, where Johannes von Buttlar ('UFO-Baron') allegedly defamed Henke, Hesemann called the author to discuss 'various sexual relationships and situations,' implying that 'everyone slept with everyone' and mentioning 'special sex practices.'

Tino Günther and the Cröffelbach UFO Day FAQ

This part discusses Tino Günther's initiative on the Paranews.net forum to address 'Cröffelbacher UFO-Tagung FAQ' and counter prejudices. It highlights that the event was organized by autonomous organizers to ensure neutrality, attracting representatives from various organizations and individuals with diverse opinions.

Skepticism and Ideology in UFOlogy

The article addresses a 'skeptical' conference and a UFOlogist who allegedly feigned ignorance or acted ideologically to avoid rational discussion. The author expresses frustration with the 'hate' that seemed to permeate the lead-up to the 'Cröffelbach 2006' event, with some UFOlogy promoters apparently viewing UFO enthusiasts who planned to attend as 'UFO terrorists.'

The Alien.de Forum Debate

It is mentioned that the Alien.de forum was accused by Hesemann of being a 'skeptic forum,' a claim that others agreed with. The author reiterates that UFO history often serves as a projection screen for desires, especially in 'esoteric ufology.' The importance of maintaining a clear research approach, grounded in facts and experience, is emphasized over spectacle.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue revolve around the nature of belief, the power of symbolism, and the critical examination of both religious phenomena and ufology. The publication adopts a skeptical yet analytical stance, questioning the scientific validity of many UFO claims while acknowledging the psychological and social drivers behind belief systems. There is a strong emphasis on distinguishing between genuine research and what is perceived as 'entertainment' or 'fandom' within the UFO community. The editorial stance appears to favor rigorous, evidence-based inquiry and criticizes the tendency towards sensationalism and unsubstantiated claims in both religious and ufological contexts. The issue also highlights the role of media in shaping public perception and the potential for manipulation of information.

This issue of CENAP Newsflash, dated November 2006, focuses on a critical examination of the UFOlogy field, particularly in Germany. The publication appears to be a newsletter or magazine from CENAP, an organization that positions itself as a critical investigator of UFO phenomena.

Cröffelbach UFO Seminar

The issue extensively discusses the "Cröffelbacher UFO-Seminar-Tage" (Cröffelbach UFO Seminar Days). The author portrays this event as an attempt to foster a more rational and less commercial approach to UFO research, contrasting it with what is described as the 'ufological cartel' and the 'hardcore UFOlogists' who are seen as promoting belief over evidence. The seminar is presented as an opportunity for attendees to gain knowledge and engage in discussion, emphasizing its non-commercial and voluntary nature. The author notes that the event is open to all 'UFO people' of good will and aims to provide impulses for new self-recognized tasks in UFO research. It is highlighted that the event is not a 'pilgrimage' but rather an opportunity for learning and coming together.

Critique of UFOlogy

A significant portion of the text is dedicated to a critique of the prevailing UFOlogy scene. The author expresses frustration with what is perceived as a lack of scientific rigor, a tendency towards dogmatism, and the promotion of unsubstantiated beliefs. The article contrasts the 'UFO-Kultur' (UFO culture) with 'UFO-Phänomenerforschung' (UFO phenomenon research), advocating for the latter. The author criticizes the 'hardcore UFOlogists' for creating 'pseudo-realities' and for their resistance to critical inquiry. The term 'ufologisches Drogenkartell' (ufological drug cartel) is used to describe the community's insular and self-reinforcing nature.

The article also touches upon the debate between UFO proponents and skeptics, describing it as a 'snake pit' quality, driven by ideological conflicts rather than a sober, scientific approach. The author argues that the UFO phenomenon itself, through 'materialization,' should be the focus, not the 'pro' or 'con' sides. The lack of concrete evidence for genuine UFOs is pointed out.

Specific Incidents and Personalities

The issue references several specific incidents and personalities within the UFO community. The 'Greyhunter-News' article by 'Corinna' is mentioned as a skeptical piece that was criticized for being polemical. The author also refers to a past demonstration by CENAP and GWUP at a conference in Frankfurt in 1989, which was compared to SA boycotts. Incidents in Mexico (a thermal camera film) and Greifswald are cited as examples that brought UFOlogy back to unexpected facts.

Personalities like W. Raab, Hesemann, Roland Gehardt, Werner Walter, Jochen Ickinger, and Peter Hattwig are mentioned in the context of their roles and views within the UFOlogy discourse. The author clarifies his own position, stating he is neither an 'Anti-UFO-Pope' nor a carnival prince, but a servant of rationality and reason in the examination of UFO phenomena.

CENAP's Role and Methodology

The article explains CENAP's motivation for existing, stemming from the perceived lack of quality control in UFO reporting. CENAP aims to provide a critical inquiry into UFO phenomena, focusing on the quality control of UFO reports and distinguishing them from non-UFO cases. The organization seeks to banish esoteric and spiritualistic elements from the scene, along with 'spinners and lunatics' and 'entertainers.' The author emphasizes the need for personal engagement and knowledge of the UFO phenomenon's spectrum, rather than relying on official mandates or large funding.

Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue include the critique of UFOlogy as a field prone to belief and lacking scientific methodology, the importance of critical thinking and evidence-based research, and the dynamics within the UFO community, which the author views as often dogmatic and resistant to external criticism. The editorial stance is clearly that of a critical investigator advocating for a scientific and rational approach to the study of unexplained aerial phenomena, distinguishing it from mere belief or speculation.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

This issue of CENAP Newsflash consistently adopts a critical and skeptical stance towards mainstream UFOlogy. The publication's editorial stance is firmly rooted in the pursuit of rational, scientific investigation, prioritizing evidence and critical analysis over belief, speculation, or what it terms 'ufological dogma.' The author repeatedly contrasts the 'ufological' approach, characterized by its adherence to established narratives and resistance to questioning, with a more rigorous, evidence-based methodology. There is a strong emphasis on distinguishing between genuine UFO phenomenon research and what is perceived as the commercialized or belief-driven aspects of the UFO community. The publication positions itself as a voice for critical inquiry, aiming to bring clarity and a grounded perspective to the often-heated debates surrounding UFOs. The underlying message is a call for intellectual honesty and a commitment to factual accuracy in the study of unexplained phenomena.

Title: CENAP Newsflash
Issue: Nr. 22
Date: November 2006

This issue of CENAP Newsflash critically examines the state of UFOlogy, the role of skepticism, and promotes various astronomy-related events and research initiatives in Germany.

The State of UFOlogy and Skepticism

The editorial opens by discussing the 'skeptic pressure' that has burdened UFOlogy in recent years, leading to disillusionment within the community. It highlights the failure of UFOlogy to present 'flying saucers' as undeniable proof of extraterrestrial visitors, attributing this partly to the lack of cooperation from the phenomena themselves, or perhaps their non-existence as imagined by enthusiasts. The article suggests that after nearly 60 years of searching for the 'pot of gold at the end of the rainbow,' UFO enthusiasts have been chasing a mirage. It posits that admitting skeptics might be right would be a form of 'self-surrender' for many UFO proponents, potentially leading to the end of UFOlogy as they know it.

The text emphasizes the need for a paradigm shift towards a sober, demystified UFO phenomenon research. It calls for individuals who not only talk but also act, to identify and rectify fundamental errors within the UFO scene. A crucial distinction is made: UFO research does not investigate UFOs directly, but rather studies UFO reports. The credibility of witness reports is paramount, requiring careful scrutiny and critical evaluation.

John Sayer of the Norfolk UFO Society is mentioned for his emphasis on UFO researchers familiarizing themselves with all potential celestial phenomena. The article reiterates that UFOs are simply reports of unidentified flying objects, and that Allen Hynek's definition implies that only when 'persons capable of identification with common sense' cannot find a solution, does a 'real UFO' remain.

However, the author questions how many people can truly identify phenomena when their understanding of the 'IFO-palette' (Identified Flying Objects) is vague. The problem of misidentifying known objects as UFOs is presented as a major issue for UFO research. It is argued that 'common sense' is insufficient; specialized knowledge is required. Ironically, it is the 'hated skeptics' who possess this knowledge and expose the flaws, a fact that the UFO community often rejects for ideological reasons.

Before a 'real UFO' can be identified, all 'possible misinterpretations of conventional objects and phenomena' must be excluded, including the problem of human deception ('X-factor UFO witness'). The article laments the lack of popular appeal in contemporary UFOlogy, with former 'UFO preachers' gone and only one attempting to maintain a following. A specific instance is cited of a user in the Schwarzwald initiating a discussion on 'Free UFO Conference' on the Paranews.net forum, proposing an event as a counter-initiative to a 'Cröffelbach' event, which is described as unique in its conception and aimed at promoting UFO research.

Astronomy Events and Initiatives

The issue extensively covers various astronomy-related events, highlighting CENAP's involvement and observations.

Astronomy Day 2006: Several articles detail the 4th nationwide Astronomy Day held on September 16, 2006. Events included an 'Astronomy Day' at the Radio Observatory Mannheim, organized by CENAP and ERAC, featuring lectures and public access to the radio telescope. Despite efforts to promote the event through local media, the turnout was described as modest, with around 30-40 people present for much of the day, though the total attendance was estimated at 250.

'Stilles Feuerwerk' (Silent Firework) Experiment: As part of the Cröffelbach 06 event, an experiment called 'Stilles Feuerwerk' was conducted. This involved helium-filled balloons with lights, super-sparklers, or glow sticks attached. The experiment was described as easy to stage, with the main cost being the helium gas. The article notes that the material was readily available in a shop named 'Luft & Liebe' in Mannheim.

Cröffelbach Events: The Cröffelbach event is described as a gathering for the UFO-interested world, not just 'folk music entertainment.' It included two events on September 16: the 4th Astronomy Day (coinciding with the 10th anniversary of the author's book 'UFOs: The Truth') and an event at the end of the month. The latter is characterized by 'strikebreakers' from the 'Looserfraktion der UFO-Laien,' who view such structures as a 'sect-like' danger to UFOlogy.

SETI and 'First Contact': The SETI-League Radio Observatory, run by Peter Wright, organized an 'Open Day' with a program including talks by Monika Maintz, Oliver Dreissigacker, and Michael Kunkel. The article briefly touches upon SETI's mission and the question of 'Contact: What Happens If A Signal Is Found,' referencing an article by Seth Shostak. The challenge of intelligent civilizations having short lifespans is mentioned.

Media Coverage and Public Engagement: The issue critiques the inconsistent and often insufficient media coverage of astronomy events. While some local papers provided brief mentions, the author expresses disappointment with the lack of widespread promotion for the Astronomy Day, comparing it unfavorably to local festivals. The article notes that some events struggled with low attendance, attributing this partly to poor publicity and the difficulty of engaging the public.

• Specific UFO Sightings:
• Wiesbaden, September 9, 2006: Orange lights were observed in the sky for about 5 minutes by multiple witnesses. The lights flew in formations and were described as silent and numerous, leading to initial confusion with helicopters.
• Odenwald, August: Hansjürgen Köhler reported observing a green-white, pear-shaped object with a tail in the sky.

Psychological Aspects of Memory: A footnote (1) explains how the brain fills 'gaps in perception' with 'false memories' (Trugbilder). It states that memory reliability depends on mood, and that under stress, individuals may resort to illusions to fill gaps in their recollection.

Critique of UFO Community: The article criticizes the UFO community for not truly understanding Hynek's definition of a UFO and for rejecting scientific skepticism. It suggests that many in the community are stuck in a cycle of misinterpretations and lack the necessary expertise to differentiate between genuine anomalies and misidentified phenomena.

• Regional Event Summaries: The issue includes reports on various astronomy events across Germany, including:
• Hildesheim: A 'Planetarium Show' was a crowd-puller, but overall attendance was modest.
• Doberlug-Kirchhain: The local observatory had low visitor numbers compared to previous years.
• Potsdam: The 'Long Night of Stars' at the Astrophysical Institute attracted 670 visitors, with media coverage focusing on the need for funding.
• Heppenheim/Starkenburg Observatory: An event was described as having a 'fairy-tale' quality, with a three-day event held in the town.
• Erkarth/Neanderhöhe Hochdahl: The 'Long Night of Stars' at the planetarium attracted about 400 visitors, with a focus on family engagement.
• Berlin: The Wilhelm Förster Sternwarte was closed.
• Bielefeld: The Ubbedissen Observatory had only 25 visitors for its ten-hour program, a significant drop from 300 in 2004.
• Mannheim: The 'Astrotreff.de' event saw high click-through rates but limited direct participant feedback.
• Dessau: The astronomical station had 1700 visitors, partly due to media coverage of its funding needs.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are the critical examination of UFOlogy, the importance of scientific rigor and skepticism in understanding unexplained phenomena, and the promotion of astronomy and public engagement with science. The editorial stance appears to be one of advocating for a more grounded and evidence-based approach to UFO research, distinguishing it from sensationalism. There is a clear emphasis on the value of scientific explanations and the efforts of astronomical organizations to educate the public, while also acknowledging the persistent interest in UFOs and the challenges of public perception.

This issue of CENAP Newsflash, dated November 2006, focuses on a variety of topics including UFO sightings, the nature of conspiracy theories, and religious discourse, particularly concerning Pope Benedict XVI.

UFO Sightings and Analysis

The magazine reports on several alleged UFO sightings. One account from Wiesbaden describes multiple objects flying in a formation, with witnesses unable to identify them and some taking mobile phone pictures. A user comment dismisses such reports as mass hysteria, suggesting mundane explanations like fireworks or misinterpretations. Another detailed report from Barsinghausen describes a dozen luminous points observed in a triangular or arrow formation, moving at airplane speed and emitting a slight humming sound. The observer, a journalist, contacted local police and the operations center but found no immediate explanation.

The Psychology of Conspiracy Theories

A significant portion of the issue is dedicated to analyzing conspiracy theories. The article posits that these theories fill a vacuum created by events that leave people feeling helpless and confused. They offer simple, albeit often irrational, explanations and a sense of order in chaotic situations. The text highlights how conspiracy theories leverage concepts like 'facts, falsifications, and suppressed evidence' to gain traction, appealing to a desire for hidden truths. It criticizes individuals who abandon rational inquiry in favor of these narratives, creating a 'Gaga generation.' The article also touches upon the appeal of conspiracy theories in the USA, linking it to a general distrust of government, referencing Watergate and the Roswell incident.

The issue further explores the structure of conspiracy narratives, often featuring a hero who uncovers a plot and faces opposition from shadowy figures and complicit media. This narrative simplicity, combined with an appeal to existing cultural sentiments like anti-Americanism, contributes to their success. The article notes that while psychologists study the attribution of causes for events, conspiracy theories often rely on emotional rather than rational criteria, and that objective truth can be elusive.

Religion, Faith, and Science

The magazine engages with religious themes, particularly through the lens of Pope Benedict XVI's statements. It discusses his views on the resurrection and ascension, suggesting a metaphorical interpretation of biblical texts. The author expresses a personal struggle with theological interpretations that deviate from the literal meaning of scripture, contrasting this with the need for clear communication in faith. The article questions whether the Pope's emphasis on 'faith and reason' and a 'new science in faith' is a subtle promotion of humanism. It references his comments on the burning bush as an 'inner analogy' and his discussion of early Christian history, noting how theological interpretations have evolved over time.

The text also touches upon the perceived decline of ufology, comparing it to a loss of connection with God, and suggests that both fields struggle to provide convincing evidence. The author critiques the scientific explanation of the world, noting how the Pope's theological stance can appear anti-scientific. The article concludes that the Pope's message, while potentially aiming for a humanistic interpretation, is not always clearly conveyed.

Historical UFO Investigations

The issue includes a section on historical UFO investigations, specifically focusing on the British Ministry of Defence's secret unit, DI55. It details how persistent inquiries by scientists, using the Freedom of Information Act, led to the admission of this unit's existence and its research into UFOs. The article reveals that the Ministry attempted to have the files destroyed or altered, but a clerical error in 1983 led to the unit's name appearing on a distribution list. Despite the initial secrecy and attempts to downplay the findings, the unit's existence became public knowledge. A subsequent report by the British government concluded that most UFO sightings had natural explanations and found no evidence of 'militarily relevant technologies.' The article also mentions the work of UFO researchers David Clarke and Andy Roberts in uncovering these details.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

This issue of CENAP Newsflash exhibits a critical and analytical stance towards phenomena often shrouded in mystery or sensationalism. It questions official narratives, examines the psychological underpinnings of belief systems (including conspiracy theories and religious faith), and scrutinizes the role of media in shaping public perception. The editorial approach appears to favor rational inquiry and evidence-based analysis, while acknowledging the complexities of human belief and the allure of the unexplained. There is a recurring theme of skepticism towards unsubstantiated claims, whether they originate from UFOlogy, conspiracy circles, or even certain interpretations of religious doctrine. The magazine seems to advocate for a grounded understanding of events, encouraging critical thinking and a discerning approach to information.

CENAP Newsflash Nr. 22, November 2006, is a German-language publication that delves into a variety of topics, including UFO phenomena, science fiction literature and television, and a specific meteor event.

Main Articles and Topics

The New Zealand Meteor Event

The issue details a meteor event that occurred in New Zealand on September 18, 2006. Initially, there was confusion and speculation, with some media outlets reporting it as space debris. The event involved a loud sonic boom that shook houses and a bright light seen by witnesses. A pilot, Neville van Eerten, described a large fireball. Scientists from the National Radiation Laboratory in Christchurch investigated a recovered fragment. While initially suspected to be part of an old spacecraft, the fragment was found to be non-radioactive and made of an 'unknown substance' with a low density, unlike typical rock or metal. The article contrasts the speed and behavior of meteors with re-entry phenomena of space debris, noting that meteors typically enter at much higher speeds and often disintegrate with a 'heavenly thunderclap'. The event caused considerable alarm among New Zealand residents, accustomed to earthquakes but not atmospheric entry phenomena.

Star Trek's Cultural Impact

The article discusses the 40th anniversary of Star Trek, highlighting its vision of human progress and its creation of a unique cult status. It suggests that the 'intergalactic humanism' of Star Trek reflects an American ambition to 'transcend' and promote a multinational, unified humanity, akin to a 'New Frontier'. The concept of 'flying saucers' is mentioned as past symbols of the future, now less relevant, though still offering an escape from everyday life for some UFOlogists.

Perry Rhodan: A Science Fiction Phenomenon

A significant portion of the magazine is dedicated to the German science fiction series 'Perry Rhodan'. It notes the series' 45th anniversary with its 2350th issue. The article traces the history of Perry Rhodan, from its massive success in the 1960s, which led to intense criticism from literary circles who labeled it 'trash literature' and accused it of promoting 'space fascism' and 'imperialism'. The criticism, particularly from East German publications like 'Kürbiskern', is detailed, with authors like Robert Jungk calling it the 'Hitler of the space age'. Despite these attacks, the series maintained a strong readership and developed a dedicated fan base, the 'Rhodanists'. The article also touches on the series' evolution, its 'cosmic mysticism', and its ability to engage readers on an emotional level, contrasting it with more traditional 'high literature'. It mentions how the series influenced individuals, including Professor Harald Lesch, who encountered the concept of neutron stars through Perry Rhodan as a youth.

'24' (TV Series)

Brief mentions are made of the US TV series '24', specifically its fifth season. The article notes its popularity and the anticipation for its release in Germany. It provides a detailed synopsis of the first hour of the fifth season, involving the assassination of David Palmer and the subsequent events, including a bomb attack on Michelle and Tony.

Other Mentions

Other brief mentions include Anoushed Ansari, the first female space tourist, and the SMART1 space probe's impact on the Moon. The article also references a historical meteor event from a 1945 Time Magazine report.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The magazine exhibits a clear interest in phenomena that challenge conventional scientific or societal norms, such as UFOs and speculative science fiction. There's a critical examination of how mainstream science and literary criticism have often dismissed or attacked these subjects, particularly Perry Rhodan and UFO research. The editorial stance appears to be one of defending these areas against what it perceives as prejudiced or ignorant criticism, highlighting their cultural significance and the passion of their followers. The publication seems to advocate for a more open-minded approach to unconventional topics, suggesting that they often hold more merit than initially dismissed by established institutions.

Title: CENAP Newsflash
Issue: Nr. 22
Date: November 2006
Publisher: CENAP
Country: Germany
Language: German

Post-Reunification Literary Landscape in East Germany

The article begins by describing the limited access to science fiction (SF) literature in East Germany (GDR) prior to reunification, where it was a restricted and censored part of the book market. Following the fall of the Berlin Wall and the opening of the market, there was a significant "buying frenzy" for new reading experiences, which also extended to UFO literature. This period saw many stars of the book scene traveling to the East to give lectures. For the general population, this was their first encounter with previously hidden and forbidden reading material. Western imports were generally perceived as good and superior, leading some capitalists to exploit this demand.

The East German population took time to adapt to the Western free market dynamics and to understand the cultural shifts and previous perceptions. A study conducted by the University of Halle interviewed 'PR' (Perry Rhodan) fans who admitted that they had encountered 'PR' and immediately found it to be more "realistic" than literature from the GDR. The researchers were surprised to learn that in the early years after reunification, fans of GDR Utopia also fell for Ron Hubbard, the founder of Scientology, and did not distinguish between his writings and early, simple SF novels. It took time for them to "socialize" with genuine Western SF literature. One reader, who had initially been misled, later admitted, "I actually thought I was reading science fiction, but then I realized it was a variant of Islam."

Personal Reflections on 'Perry Rhodan'

The author, Werner Walter, shares his personal "PR" commitment, which includes attending "PR World Congresses" in Mannheim, Saarbrücken, and Mainz. He lists his favorite characters from the SF series, emphasizing those with a "Sense Of Wonder," such as the Haluter Icho Tolot (who is still alive), Atlan, Ronald Tekener (as 'Lebo Axton'), Anson Argyris, Harno, Reginald Bull, 'Hamiller'-Tube, and ES (the "old man" and his laugh).

A special place is reserved for the transmitter-damaged, masked character Alaska S. The author notes that while Alaska S.'s surname is difficult for most to pronounce, he is described as the tragic "loser type" of the series. Despite being somewhat colorless, he possesses something almost indefinable, embodying the "cosmic breath" and symbolizing a "superintelligence." Walter expresses a slight weariness with the concept of "superintelligence" and its increasingly esoteric applications, but finds Alaska S. to be the one character who has traveled extensively and experienced much, having been written out of the story only to mysteriously "materialize" again and recount astonishing events. Walter considers Alaska S. to be the "joker" of the series.

He then questions where Perry Rhodan himself fits into this ranking. While Perry is the namesake and "overfather" of the series, Walter finds him "much too nice" in his concern for humanity and the universe. In contrast, Atlan possesses this quality in abundance as a former admiral of the Arkon fleet during the Methan wars, even though the "heir of the universe" has somewhat tamed him. Atlan embodies the type of hard-action figure that early critics might have confused with 'PR,' a mix of 'Dirty Harry' and 'John McClane,' who was meant to represent the "cosmic emperor." However, 'PR' humanism eventually influenced Atlan.

Walter highlights several "cycle highlights" for him, including Blues, MdI, Schwarm, Kosmische Hanse, Endlose Armada, and the current Terranova. He also appreciates the old ATLAN series (a spin-off of 'PR') which focused on USO agent missions against the terrorist organization 'Condos Vasac,' likening the action to "24" within a "Star Wars" context, and even the "Planetenromane" paperback series.

Regarding authors, Walter states he has no single favorite, believing the collective work is what matters and that he has never paid attention to individual authors. He acknowledges that 'PR' authors have produced both brilliant episodes and uninspired, low-quality material. With nearly 2400 individual issues, he cannot create a "hit list" of the "best novels."

Conclusion and Personal Context

Werner Walter concludes his essay by placing himself in the context of Autumn 2006, feeling torn between various events: the Pope's visit, UFOlogy "outbursts," the Emmy Award for "24," holy relics, and cosmic SF fantasies with 'Perry Rhodan' devotion. He expresses astonishment at his own reflections.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The issue focuses on the cultural and literary impact of Western science fiction, particularly the 'Perry Rhodan' series, on East Germany after the fall of the Iron Curtain. It explores themes of cultural adaptation, the perception of Western media, and the complex character development within long-running SF narratives. The editorial stance appears to be one of critical appreciation for SF, acknowledging its ability to provide 'sense of wonder' while also examining its potential for misinterpretation or ideological comparison. The author's personal engagement with the 'Perry Rhodan' universe is evident, offering a detailed analysis of specific characters and story arcs.