Abduction Watch - No 10-11 1998

Magazine Overview

Title: Abduction Watch
Issue: 10/11
Date: June 1998
Theme: Critical examination of ufology practices and historical claims.

SPI and the Dangers of Regression Hypnosis

The issue begins with serious concerns about Strange Phenomena Investigations (SPI), a group that has undergone changes with Malcolm Robinson moving to London and Billy Devlin running SPI Scotland. The author, Kevin McClure, reiterates his previous concerns about the psychological welfare of witnesses, particularly regarding the use of regression hypnosis in ufology. McClure criticizes Malcolm Robinson for promoting regression hypnosis as a reliable tool, citing a specific claim that Helen Walters, the hypnotist used by SPI, was a "professional and qualified hypnotherapist."

However, despite repeated requests, Robinson failed to provide evidence of Walters' qualifications. McClure was surprised by Robinson's later statement in "Strange Phenomena Scotland" that he would "send Kevin all the relevant details soon," implying that McClure's focus on scientific and medical evidence was a waste of time. When McClure asked Billy Devlin to substantiate this statement and provide details of Walters' qualifications, Devlin was evasive. Robinson then phoned McClure, challenging him to a phone debate.

McClure asserts that he is not a qualified social worker but has experience in fraud investigation, which helped him uncover why Robinson had not provided information: Robinson himself admitted he did not know Walters' qualifications and that she had refused to provide them on grounds of privacy.

McClure questions Robinson's earlier claims, suggesting possible explanations ranging from an attempt to mislead to a basic mistake or a cover-up for using an unqualified person. He argues that without Walters' qualifications, the credibility of SPI's methods, particularly in cases like the "A70 case" which supposedly changed Robinson's view from skepticism to belief, is undermined.

McClure offers Robinson the opportunity to explain himself and suggests SPI refrain from using Walters until her qualifications are proven. He notes that SPI is considering setting up a "junior section" to advise and assist youngsters, potentially holding classes for investigators and organizing field trips. This plan is particularly concerning given that SPI's investigations rely on a hypnotist who will not reveal her qualifications, and the organization is run by individuals who believe in her psychic powers and regression hypnosis as a primary method for obtaining repressed memories of abduction events.

Devlin himself appears to believe in psychic powers, with a quote stating, "I actually saw what looked like an arm come out and take hold of Helen by the arm." The magazine also advertises "The Alien Abduction Helpline," which promotes claims of psychic protection from aliens through Grahame Wyllie's channeling, and "Truthseekers Tayside," which makes unsubstantiated assertions about ETs and encourages distrust of government agencies.

McClure sent Devlin articles from the British Journal of Psychiatry and The Lancet, which argue against the use of regression hypnosis for recovering traumatic memories. Devlin's response was that he found the articles "very interesting" and would consider them "when I next have to use hypnosis," raising concerns that Devlin himself might be practicing hypnosis.

Given SPI's commitment to involving children and its apparent lack of self-regulation, McClure has written to Devlin stating that if SPI, or anyone acting on its behalf, engages in specific activities with children (hypnosis, encouraging beliefs of sexual assault by non-humans, asserting alien abduction facts, or instructing in hypnosis), he will report the matter to social services, the police, and/or the media.

McClure dismisses Devlin's "nasty little threats" as typical of "alien abduction fundamentalists" who become defensive when their beliefs are challenged. He notes a recent rumor about SPI's approach to abductees, which strengthens his resolve to protect children.

A report in Ron Halliday's "Phenomenal News" mentions Gary Wood, an "A70 case" abductee, who had no recollection of alien interactions until regressed by Helen Walters. Wood's hypnosis sessions produced increasingly detailed, disturbing material, including a "naked woman, her eyes red with crying" and a "fat young girl of 9 or 10." The rumor is that SPI might be looking for these individuals in Edinburgh.

Malcolm Robinson's belief that "Humankind are being taken without consent from their normal friendly environments" and that "many people have been abducted since childhood" is highlighted. McClure criticizes SPI's approach, stating they rely on a hypnotist who won't discuss qualifications, believe produced 'memories' as fact, and want to enlist children as investigators.

McClure challenges SPI to produce videotapes of Walters' regression sessions for examination by professionals to assess the techniques' objectivity, genuineness, and any harm caused to clients.

The Alien Explanation: A Lazy Solution

McClure argues that major UK alien abduction cases like Aveley, Alan Godfrey, and the 'A70' case, all involving regression hypnosis, have been explained away by an "alien visitation and abduction" narrative. He contends that it is the hypnosis and the resulting narrative, rather than the actual experience, that changes the lives of the "experiencers." This "alien explanation" is presented as a common, standardized, and lazy solution that overshadows the real mystery of the consciously-recalled experiences.

Robert Moore's draft for a BUFORA handbook is mentioned, which outlines key issues in the Aveley, Godfrey, and A70 cases. Moore's work emphasizes that before hypnosis became fashionable, investigators thoroughly examined such reports, finding reasonable solutions. Now, investigators often skip difficult aspects and rely on hypnotists, leading to the experiencers' problems.

McClure cites an article by Dr. H B Gibson from the British Society of Experimental and Clinical Hypnosis newsletter, which details a case where a solicitor requested hypnosis for a policeman to recover memories. Despite the psychiatrists' findings, the solicitor was unsatisfied. The alien explanation for this case is deemed unwarranted and unhelpful, further supporting the argument that hypnosis is useless and dangerous.

Bob Dean and 'The Unopened Files'

McClure commends an article in "Quest International" publications, noting that since Tony Dodd parted ways with the Birdsalls, the content has become more balanced and investigative. He mentions an article by Timothy Good and Admiral Lord Hill-Norton concerning an investigation into "high military levels" related to Master Sergeant Robert Dean's claims about a "Cosmic Top Secret" document titled "An Assessment An Evaluation of a Possible Military Threat to Allied Forces in Europe."

However, Good and Hill-Norton concluded that Dean did not see "The Assessment" because it never existed. The document Dean provided describing his security clearance was deemed "patently bogus." The article suggests that "Quest International" showed courage in running this story, given their previous platform for Dean.

McClure also references Phil Klass's uncovering of Dean's service record, which showed his role at SHAPE was "Chief Clerk Language Service Branch," not a high-level security position. The article implies that magazine editors and authors should apologize for inadequate research and verification of Dean's claims, and calls for closer scrutiny of individuals who claim to remember more than they likely knew, mentioning Wendelle Stevens and Clifford Stone as examples.

Nazi UFOs: More Secrets Than Answers

This section delves into the "Nazi UFOs" phenomenon, with McClure expressing his persistent failure to anticipate tactics used to protect perceived interests. He acknowledges that this area involves mixed motivations and that his research might provoke difficult reactions.

McClure's research, presented as "Secrets or Lies," suggests that despite plans or drawings, there is "painfully thin" evidence for high-performance circular or spherical aircraft flying in Germany during WWII. He states that the legends of Nazi UFOs are "founded on sand" or "popcorn."

The concept of superior German technology is seen as underpinning beliefs that Germans achieved these flights with alien help or by reverse-engineering alien craft. It also supports the idea of post-war UFO sightings being evidence of hidden Nazi UFO bases in the Antarctic. This theory is profitable for some, including the German Research Project, author W.A. Harbinson, and writers of articles in UFO, New Age, and right-wing anti-NWO publications.

Another view is that there is a line of secret aeronautical development from wartime flying saucers to later UFO sightings and "Flying Triangles." Tim Matthews' monograph "Secret History" is quoted: "Surely it is to the military-industrial complex and not the heavens above that we should look for the origins of the flying saucer." Matthews argues that the evidence for 'alien flying saucers' is "wholly untenable" and that UFO researchers should "reorient their thinking" towards man-made flying saucer reality and an ongoing cover-up.

McClure acknowledges Matthews' response, including his concern that McClure might be "devaluing his research" by referring to fringe conclusions. McClure clarifies that he will debunk Matthews' book only if asked and if it contains "bunk." He believes Matthews has gone beyond the evidence, relying on secondhand assertions.

McClure questions the credibility of sources like Robert Jungk's "Brighter Than A Thousand Suns" and David Masters' "German Jet Genesis," stating they offer no more proof than the Schreiver/Lusar antecedents.

McClure considers the evidence for the "Schriever, Habermohl, Miethe and Bellonzo Flying Disc" improbable and self-contradictory, suggesting it likely never existed or flew. He contrasts this with Matthews' belief that Schriever's account is "a most credible story" and that researcher Bill Rose has confirmed it through "on-site research." However, McClure points out the lack of verifiable detail about Rose's sources and methods.

McClure challenges SPI to produce videotapes of regression sessions for examination by professionals.

Specific Questions Regarding Nazi UFOs

McClure poses several questions to stimulate research and consideration before concluding the existence of "Nazi UFOs."

1. Al Pinto/Tal and Vangard Sciences: Inquiries are made about "Al Pinto" and "Tal," who appear to be sponsored by "Vangard Sciences," and their extensive online information, including claims about Schauberger developing the "Schriever, Habermohl, Miethe and Bellonzo Flying Disc" at Malthausen Concentration Camp.
2. Renato Vesco: Questions arise about Vesco's biographical information. While Pinto claims Vesco was a licensed aircraft engineer who studied at the German Institute for Aerial Development and worked with Germans at Fiat Lake Garda, the cover of Vesco's book "Intercept - But Don't Shoot" states he was born in 1924, was a licensed pilot in 1944, and commanded the technical section of the Italian Air Force at age 19 or 20. McClure finds this timeline improbable and notes Vesco's absence from wartime German aircraft literature.
3. Major Rudolf Lusar: Questions are raised about Lusar's vague biographical details, his alleged involvement in the German Ministry of Propaganda or Patent Office, and whether he had special access to information about the "Schriever, Habermohl, Miethe and Bellonzo Flying Disc."
4. Captain Rudolph Schriever: The article questions the biographical information provided in a Der Spiegel report, including his alleged status as a former Luftwaffe Captain, born in 1909/1910, a graduate of Prague University, and an aircraft designer whose blueprints were stolen. It asks if his claims of working near Prague in 1944/45 on a "Nazi UFO" can be traced and verified.
5. Klaus Habermohl: The article seeks biographical material to confirm if Habermohl designed the "first radial-flow engine" and was part of the team near Prague in 1944/45.
6. Giuseppe Belluzzo (Italian Bellonzo): The article asks for information to suggest that "the Italian Bellonzo" mentioned by Lusar is the same person as "Guiseppe Belluzzo," who Maurizio Verga claims was a "turbine expert" working on circular craft from 1942.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue are the critical examination of ufological investigative methods, particularly the unreliability and potential harm of regression hypnosis, and a skeptical approach to historical claims, especially concerning "Nazi UFOs." The editorial stance is one of rigorous investigation, demanding evidence, questioning authority, and prioritizing the welfare of witnesses, especially children. The author advocates for a scientific and evidence-based approach, contrasting it with what he perceives as the "fundamentalist" and speculative nature of some within the UFO community. There is a strong emphasis on debunking unsubstantiated claims and exposing potential misrepresentations or lack of research in the field.

This issue of "Secrets or Lies?" (Volume 1, Issue 2, dated May 1946, though the cover date is May 1946, the content refers to events in December 1944 and January 1945) is a UK-based publication by Kevin McClure, focusing on ufology and related phenomena. The magazine appears to be a continuation of a series, with "Secrets or Lies 2" mentioned.

Foo Fighters and Their Origins

The first section addresses the origins of "foo fighter" reports. The author, likely the editor, questions the widely accepted link between German spherical craft and these phenomena, attributing the popularization of this idea to Vesco in 1969. Vesco's detailed accounts, including pilot conversations, are suggested to be potentially fabricated or based on less credible sources, specifically Ray Palmer's "Amazing Stories" magazine, with the May 1946 issue being a particular point of inquiry. The author expresses a strong suspicion that Vesco relied heavily on such fictionalized accounts.

The Brisant Newsletter and Harbinson's Book

Further investigation is called for regarding a supposed magazine or newsletter called "Brisant." This publication is cited as the source for an introduction to Harbinson's book "Projekt UFO." However, "Harbinson's publisher" reportedly lost their copy, and no complete copy has been located. The primary evidence usually presented from "Brisant" is a drawing of a flying saucer, which Harbinson claims was altered by the West German government to be "safe" for publication. The author intends to contact Harbinson's publisher directly to inquire about this, but raises doubts about the authenticity of "Brisant" and its drawing, suggesting they might be imaginative creations from more than 30 years after the war.

The "Christmas Season" Secret Weapon

The issue examines an AP release from December 1944 concerning a German "secret weapon" described as resembling glass balls, colored silver, and appearing transparent. These objects were reportedly seen hanging in the air over German territory, individually or in clusters. The author proposes a provocative interpretation: that this was a light-hearted Christmas jest, a bit of fun designed for the holiday season, and not a genuine report of an enemy weapon. This interpretation is supported by the fact that such reports appeared in the "South Wales Argus" (December 13, 1944) and the "New York Herald Tribune" (January 2, 1945). The author argues that during wartime, censorship would prevent the open announcement of mysterious enemy weapons by official sources like AP, and their publication by combatant nations' newspapers. Mainstream history has also ignored these reports, leading the author to conclude they were likely a seasonal joke.

Conclusion and Search for Reference Material

The author acknowledges that the current document is merely a starting point and emphasizes the need for more reference material to pursue the subject further. A list of items is provided, for which copies are requested. The author is willing to pay for materials or cover costs for loans and photocopies. The requested items include:

• American Legion Magazine, December 1945 (regarding foo fighters)
• Any issue of Ray Palmer's Amazing Stories referring to foo fighters
• "Close Encounters of the Kugelblitz Kind" by Vladimir Terziski (book)
• "The German Saucer Story" by Michael X (book)

Thanks are extended to a list of individuals for their help and advice: David Sivier, Dave Newton, Peter Brookesmith, Peter Williams, Wayne Spencer, Andy Roberts, Peter Rogerson, Eugene Doherty, Hilary Evans, Martin Kottmeyer, and James Moseley.

Updates and the 'Alison's Balloon' Case

A section titled "Updates, and an intriguing possibility" discusses the "Alison's Balloon" case. The "regressionist doctor" involved in this case did not respond to a second letter. The author had sent the doctor a copy of a lengthy article from the "British Journal of Psychiatry" (No. 172, 1998) titled "Recovered memories of childhood sexual abuse - Implications for clinical practice." This was intended to inform the doctor about the current professional views on using hypnotic regression to recover memories of traumatic events. The author also asked the doctor to confirm, in light of the Royal College of Psychiatrists (RCP) warnings, that he would not use the technique in the context of a supposed UFO case again. The author plans to write to the General Medical Council (GMC) on this issue.

The 'Jason' Case and Tony Dodd

There has been silence from the publisher "Headline" (which had promised an informed response) and investigator Tony Dodd regarding serious discrepancies between two accounts of the "Jason" case. The author suggests that neither party is willing to have the evidence examined by anyone other than those involved in creating the book. Since the truth of either version is uncertain, the author proposes ignoring the book and sparing a thought for Jason. The apparent marginalization of Tony Dodd within UK ufology is noted as a potential factor in reducing future occurrences of such scenarios.

Tim Rifat and Remote Viewing

Silence has also been received from Remote Viewer and self-publicist Tim Rifat, who was asked for objective evidence of his powers. The author suspects there is no independent proof of Rifat's claims of "positively superhuman powers," which underpin his attempts to make money. This led the author to research the "Fraudulent Mediums Act 1951," which appears to still be in force and applicable in Scotland.

The Fraudulent Mediums Act 1951

The Act defines an offense as a person who, with intent to deceive, purports to act as a spiritualistic medium or exercise powers of telepathy, clairvoyance, or similar abilities, or uses any fraudulent device in doing so. Crucially, a conviction requires proof that the person acted for reward. The author finds the definition of "powers of telepathy, clairvoyance or other similar powers" particularly relevant to remote viewing (RV), though no evidence currently suggests that supposed remote viewers cannot perform their claimed abilities. The author anticipates a convincing and testable demonstration of these skills in the near future.

Subscription Information

Subscription details are provided for the UK and internationally. In the UK, 12 issues cost £10. Internationally, £5 (cash, UK cheque, or International Money Order) covers 5 issues in the UK, 4 in Europe, and 3 issues elsewhere. All back issues are available. Payments should be made out to Kevin McClure and sent to 3, Claremont Grove, Leeds, LS3 1AX, England.

Obituary for Ralph Noyes

The issue notes the recent death of Ralph Noyes, described as a man of great intelligence, tolerance, kindness, and intellectual generosity. He is credited with broadening the outlook of the SPR (Society for Psychical Research) in a remarkable way and always hoped that wonderful things might be true. The author reflects that Noyes now knows the secrets of life after death.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue revolve around the critical examination of UFO phenomena, particularly the origins and evidence surrounding "foo fighter" reports and alleged German flying saucers. The editorial stance is skeptical, questioning the authenticity of sources and interpretations, and advocating for rigorous research and evidence. There is a strong emphasis on debunking unsubstantiated claims and exposing potential fraud, as seen in the discussion of Tim Rifat and the Fraudulent Mediums Act 1951. The magazine also touches upon the controversial use of hypnotic regression in cases involving recovered memories, highlighting professional concerns. The overall tone is investigative and analytical, aiming to separate fact from fiction in the realm of unexplained phenomena.