2014 07 03 Theology and Science - Vol 12 No 3 - Albert A Harrison

Magazine Overview

This document contains book reviews from "Theology and Science, 2014, Vol. 12, No. 3". The reviews cover two distinct books, offering insights into the fields of ufology, theology, and the intersection of science and religion.

Book Review: UFOs: God's Chariots? Spirituality, Ancient Aliens and Religious Yearnings in the Age of Extraterrestrials by Ted Peters

This review discusses the revised and updated edition of Ted Peters' book, originally published in 1977. Peters provides a comprehensive overview of ufology, examining its scientific and theological underpinnings and consequences. The review highlights that polls indicate a significant number of people believe in alien visitations and government cover-ups. Peters asserts that regardless of the physical reality of UFOs, the beliefs surrounding them have tangible consequences, including disillusionment with science, rejection of traditional religion, and diminished trust in government. The interest in UFOs has persisted for nearly seventy years, despite claims of its scientific and spiritual bankruptcy.

The review outlines the broad scope of UFO narratives, from aerial phenomena to complex conspiracy theories involving military-intelligence-industrial complexes, secret societies, and even Nazi technology. Peters' preparation for this book involved extensive study of academic literature, UFO books, interviews with diverse individuals, and participation in UFO conventions.

Peters' analysis focuses on the often-overlooked theological and spiritual dimensions of ufology, while also critically examining the distinction between science and pseudoscience. The review notes Peters' argument that it is insufficient to categorize people merely as "believers" or "skeptics" and that the use of smear tactics against witnesses should be addressed.

The book is praised for being authoritative, well-written, and engaging, featuring case reports. It employs a typology of aliens, including "Interstellar Diplomats," "Research Scientists," "Celestial Saviors," and "Hybridizers." Peters' central thesis is that fundamental religious needs—for meaning, moral guidance, hope, and forgiveness—persist in modern materialistic society. As traditional religious values become harder to satisfy, people increasingly turn to science and technology for comfort, with the idea of benevolent extraterrestrial civilizations being one manifestation of this. Religious themes are evident in "UFO religions" or implicitly when people seek answers from advanced spacemen.

The review references the 1950s "contactee" phenomenon, where individuals claimed visits from superior humanoids who brought messages about nuclear warfare and urged harmony. This led to the emergence of UFO religions that predict salvation through UFOs. Peters critiques this as a flawed theology that replaces a transcendent God with finite, technologically advanced beings. The concept of "ancient aliens" influencing human evolution is also discussed, with Peters' analysis of these claims described as insightful and devastating.

Peters acknowledges the trauma associated with alien abduction experiences but suggests that with therapeutic guidance, these can lead to positive transformations. However, some ufologists perceive certain alien types as sinister, reminiscent of Jungian archetypes like the shadow and the trickster.

New additions to this edition include analyses of abduction experiences, the field of astrotheology, the ETI myth, and findings from a "Religious Crisis Survey" indicating that belief in extraterrestrial life is unlikely to shatter faith. The review concludes that the revised edition is a valuable successor to the original.

Book Review: The Spirit of Creation: Modern Science and Divine Action in the Pentecostal-Charismatic Imagination by Amos Yong

This review focuses on Amos Yong's book, which examines the relationship between Pentecostal theology and modern science. Yong, a prominent figure in Pentecostal theology, approaches the subject with an interdisciplinary perspective. The book, a collection of published materials, is structured into six chapters.

The first chapter provides a historical overview of Pentecostalism and modern science, outlining Yong's purpose. Subsequent chapters delve into the "science of Pentecostalism," aiming to illuminate Pentecostalism through science without reducing it. Chapters 3-5 explore science-theology in greater detail, connecting them to pneumatology and the understanding of God's action, including the "divine action project," teleology, eschatology, and a pneumatological cosmology.

Yong identifies a gap between Pentecostal theology and science, describing it as a span between "supernaturalistic religion" and the "naturalistic and rationalistic world of modern science." He argues for Pentecostals to engage with science for three reasons: they are part of the modern world, failure to engage could weaken their faith, and Pentecostalism offers a unique perspective.

Yong characterizes Pentecostal spirituality as a "countermodernist discourse," incorporating nonrational elements of human experience that challenge the overextended claims of science. He believes Pentecostalism's experiential, empirical, and pragmatic orientation can enrich science-theology discourse.

Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance

The recurring themes in this issue revolve around the complex interplay between belief systems (ufology, religion, spirituality) and scientific inquiry. The reviews highlight how individuals and groups seek meaning, purpose, and answers in both traditional religious frameworks and emerging phenomena like UFOs and scientific advancements. The editorial stance appears to be one of critical engagement, encouraging rigorous examination of claims, whether they originate from ufological circles, religious traditions, or scientific discourse. The reviews emphasize the importance of understanding the theological and spiritual dimensions of phenomena often relegated to pseudoscience or dismissed by mainstream academia.