Magazine Summary
JAMA
Ever wanted to host your own late-night paranormal radio show?
Across the Airwaves
You’re on the air. Callers bring Mothman, Fresno Nightcrawlers, UFO sightings, reptilian autopsies, and whispers about AATIP and Project Blue Book. Every reply shapes how the night goes.
Summary
This issue of JAMA explores the deep-seated belief in UFOs within the American psyche, linking it to phenomena like the Heaven's Gate cult suicides and the enduring fascination with the Roswell incident. Astronomers like Hal Weaver and Olivier Hainaut discuss how UFO theories often arise from misinterpretations of astronomical data, while psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton analyzes the psychological appeal of such beliefs. The US Air Force's announcement regarding the Roswell incident, attributing it to parachute tests with dummies, is also covered, alongside details of the 50th-anniversary commemorations.
Magazine Overview
This issue of JAMA, dated July 16, 1997, Volume 278, Number 3, focuses on the intersection of UFO beliefs, cult psychology, and astronomical phenomena. The cover headline, "Belief in Alien UFOs Deep in American Psyche," sets the stage for articles exploring these themes.
Cultic Behavior and Physician Response
An article by Lynne Lamberg discusses the challenges physicians face when dealing with patients involved in cults, referencing the Heaven's Gate cult suicides. Psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton is quoted, emphasizing the need for physicians to understand cultic behavior and the psychological struggles of individuals leaving cults. Lifton urges a critical examination of societal factors that contribute to extreme behavior and the sense of 'deadness' that might lead individuals to embrace apocalyptic beliefs.
UFO Theories and Comet Hale-Bopp
Another piece by Lynne Lamberg addresses the phenomenon of UFO theories, particularly in relation to Comet Hale-Bopp. Astronomers like Hal Weaver from the Space Telescope Science Institute and Olivier Hainaut from the Institute for Astronomy at the University of Hawaii report receiving numerous inquiries linking the comet to UFOs. Hainaut explains that many purported UFO sightings in astronomical images are actually artifacts of the detectors used, and he provides resources on his website to debunk these claims. He notes a shift in popular belief from seeing 'dragons and giants' to 'UFOs and aliens,' attributing this to the cultural significance of comets and the end of the century.
Hainaut's experience highlights the public's low level of scientific literacy, with some recipients of his explanations accusing him of being a CIA agent or an alien. Despite this, Hainaut acknowledges the existence of unidentified flying objects but distinguishes them from 'flying saucers,' stating that supposed alien spacecraft never appear in the presence of astronomers.
The Roswell Incident
The issue also covers the US Air Force's press conference in June 1997 regarding the Roswell incident. The Air Force announced that the alleged alien sightings from 50 years prior were actually anthropomorphic dummies used in parachute tests, detailed in a 231-page document titled "The Roswell Report: Case Closed." Despite this official conclusion, the article notes the continued public fascination, with the Roswell chamber of commerce anticipating thousands of visitors for the 50th-anniversary commemorations, including events at the International UFO Museum and Research Center.
Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance
The recurring themes in this issue revolve around the psychological and societal underpinnings of belief in the extraordinary, particularly UFOs and cultic movements. The editorial stance appears to be one of critical inquiry, encouraging scientific literacy and a deeper understanding of the societal factors that contribute to such beliefs. The magazine aims to provide a medically and scientifically informed perspective on phenomena that capture the public imagination, distinguishing between scientific evidence and popular mythology.
We need to ask why the people in Heaven's Gate saw the world as dead, as though the apocalypse had already happened. Is there something in our society, not only in them, that led to that sense of deadness?
Key Incidents
Suicides of 39 members of the Heaven's Gate cult, linked to UFO theories.
Alleged sighting of space aliens, later announced by the US Air Force to be anthropomorphic dummies used for parachute tests.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the connection between UFO theories and cults like Heaven's Gate?
The Heaven's Gate cult members who committed suicide apparently believed they would be transported by a UFO to a better world, embracing a prominent mythology of our time. Psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton suggests that people may 'pounce on ostensible evidence' when it fits a fiercely held prior ideology.
How do astronomers explain purported UFO sightings related to Comet Hale-Bopp?
Astronomers like Olivier Hainaut explain that most purported UFOs found by amateur astronomers are 'typical artifacts' in images created by detectors. He and a colleague proved one image was a fraud, and others are of questionable origin.
What was the US Air Force's explanation for the Roswell incident?
In June 1997, the US Air Force announced that alleged space aliens seen near Roswell, NM, 50 years prior were anthropomorphic dummies used to test parachutes. This was detailed in a 231-page document titled 'The Roswell Report: Case Closed'.
What advice does a JAMA contributor give to physicians regarding cult members?
Lynne Lamberg, quoting Lifton, suggests that physicians should advise relatives to stay in touch with cult members and invite them to talk, emphasizing that the physician is not an agent of the family or the cult. More knowledge about cultic behavior is needed for effective response.
In This Issue
People Mentioned
- Lynne LambergJAMA contributor
- Hal Weaverresearch scientist
- Olivier Hainautastronomer
- Robert Jay Liftonpsychiatrist
- John HaynesCol, deputy chief of the Air Force Declassification Review Team
Organisations
- Heaven's Gate
- Space Telescope Science Institute
- Johns Hopkins University
- US Air Force
- Roswell chamber of commerce
- International UFO Museum and Research Center
- Roswell Jaycees
Locations
- Baltimore, Md, USA
- Honolulu, USA
- Roswell, NM, USA
- Washington, DC, USA