Magazine Summary
Current Anthropology
Summary
This issue of Current Anthropology features an article by Valerii I. Sanarov examining the nature and origin of flying saucers and 'little green men' by analyzing folklore and historical accounts. Sanarov compares UFO sightings to 19th-century airship reports and ancient myths, suggesting they may be symbolic representations rather than literal phenomena. The issue also includes an article by Reed D. Riner on the supranational network of boards of directors and the evolution of global sociocultural integration.
Magazine Overview
This issue of *Current Anthropology*, Volume 22, Number 2, published in April 1981 by The University of Chicago Press on behalf of the Wenner-Gren Foundation for Anthropological Research, features two main articles. The cover headline highlights the lead article, "On the Nature and Origin of Flying Saucers and Little Green Men" by Valerii I. Sanarov.
On the Nature and Origin of Flying Saucers and Little Green Men
Valerii I. Sanarov's article delves into the persistent interest in flying saucers and unidentified flying objects (UFOs), exploring their nature and origin. Sanarov notes that the most popular theory posits an extraterrestrial origin, with UFOs being spacecraft from advanced civilizations. Other theories suggest UFOs are entities from other dimensions, Earth's interior, or the Earth's upper atmosphere. A contrasting view, proposed by Dmitriev, considers UFOs as atmospheric phenomena akin to ball lightning, explaining encounters as interactions with "chemiluminescent zones" that can cause adverse effects on humans.
Sanarov emphasizes that while the existence of UFOs as unidentified objects is a fact for scientific research, the concept of "UFOnauts" or "little green men" requires separate examination. He classifies stories of UFOs and UFOnauts as folkloric "memorates" and attempts to find connections through folklore studies.
The article examines historical accounts, starting with the 1897 reports of airships in the United States. One notable incident involved a crashed "Martian" airship in Aurora, Texas, and the alleged extraterrestrial origin of its pilot. Another account from Leroy, Kansas, described a large, cigar-shaped airship with occupants. Sanarov questions the veracity of these early reports, citing a confession from the editor of the Yates Center Farmer's Advocate that the Hamilton airship story was a hoax concocted with friends.
However, Sanarov argues that the widespread reports of airships in the late 19th century (1896-1897) across numerous states cannot be dismissed as mere hoaxes. These sightings often described "cigar"-shaped objects with powerful searchlights and unprecedented speeds. He suggests that these reports reflected an anticipation of the era of airship building, a collective dream of technological advancement.
Sanarov draws parallels between these airship tales and flying saucer reports, noting common elements such as occupants descending via ropes or anchors, and interactions with witnesses. He compares these elements to folkloric motifs, including the "rope trick" performed by Indian fakirs and the ancient "world-tree" tales, where a "little man" climbs a rope into the sky and sometimes disappears or is dismembered. The flying saucer is analogized to an eagle's nest, and "little green men" to the eagle's young or the fakir's boy.
Sanarov's central thesis is that flying saucers and "little green men" do not exist in objective reality but are symbolic images. The eagle's nest, airship, and flying saucer serve the same functional load, representing not literal beings but symbolic expressions influenced by the observer's "set"—social development, situation, and beliefs. He suggests that UFOs might represent archetypes of the human unconscious or serve to stabilize the relationship between human consciousness and the complexities of the world.
- Key incidents discussed include:
- The 1897 Aurora, Texas, airship crash.
- The 1897 Leroy, Kansas, airship sighting.
- A 1914 sighting of a luminous cigar-shaped object near Hamburg.
- A 1914 sighting of a spherical object on Lake Huron, Canada.
- A 1935 sighting of an upside-down bowl-shaped object in Belgium.
- The 1978 disappearance of pilot Fred Valentich over Bass Strait, Australia, after reporting a UFO.
Sanarov concludes that the meaning of these symbols is a task for specialists, potentially related to Jungian archetypes or serving to help humans understand their world.
The Supranational Network of Boards of Directors
Reed D. Riner's article examines the emergence of a "fifth level of sociocultural integration" created by the global network of large corporations and government agencies. This network is characterized by interlocking directorates, where individuals serve on multiple boards, forming a global organizational structure.
Riner traces the antecedents of this system to the collapse of feudalism in Europe, the rise of merchants and bankers, and the increasing importance of money and profit maximization. The capitalist system, he argues, brought new strategies of control that emphasized behavioral outcomes. Institutions adapted by reinforcing capitalist values like wage work, competition, and voluntary associations.
The article highlights the evolution of organizations from simple proprietorships to joint-stock companies, which became dominant by the late 17th century. By 1700, 140 English joint-stock companies controlled significant capital, enabling them to exploit resources and expand enterprises.
Riner defines the "unit of adaptation" in cultural evolution as the largest group that makes and implements decisions regarding energy exploitation. The network of interlocking directorates is presented as the core institution of this fifth-level organization, characterized by persistence beyond individual lives, adaptive structuring, predictable patterns, increasing dependency, internal differentiation, and enhanced control over energy resources.
Recurring Themes and Editorial Stance
This issue of *Current Anthropology* engages with broad anthropological and sociological themes. Sanarov's article positions UFO phenomena within the context of folklore, mythology, and psychological interpretation, suggesting that these are not necessarily literal events but symbolic expressions of human thought and societal anxieties. Riner's article focuses on the evolution of global economic and social structures, particularly the rise of multinational corporations and the concept of sociocultural integration. The journal's stance appears to be one of rigorous academic inquiry, analyzing complex social phenomena through historical, folkloric, and structural perspectives.
The conclusion goes without saying: flying saucers and little green men do not exist in objective reality. The eagle's nest, the airship, and the flying saucer are images that carry the same functional load. This can only mean that they are not real, but symbolic.
Key Incidents
Report of a crashed airship and the funeral of its pilot, who was concluded to be from Mars.
A rancher reported seeing a cigar-shaped airship descend, with six strange beings emerging.
A luminous cigar-shaped object with illuminated windows was seen, with four dwarves nearby.
Eight men saw a large, flat-topped spherical object with human-like creatures nearby.
A witness saw an upside-down bowl-shaped object with two dwarves inspecting it.
Pilot Fred Valentich vanished after reporting a strange aircraft hovering above him.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main argument of Sanarov's article on flying saucers?
Sanarov argues that flying saucers and 'little green men' are likely symbolic representations rooted in folklore and human psychology, rather than objective realities, drawing parallels with historical airship sightings and ancient myths.
How does Sanarov connect UFOs to folklore?
He classifies UFO and UFOnaut stories as 'non-fairy-tale prose or memorates,' allowing for comparison with a wide range of folkloric and mythological material, such as the world-tree tales and the rope trick.
What historical airship sightings are discussed?
The article discusses numerous 19th-century airship sightings reported across the United States, often described as cigar-shaped with powerful searchlights, and compares them to later flying saucer reports.
What is the 'supranational network of boards of directors' discussed in the issue?
Reed D. Riner's article describes this network as a fifth level of sociocultural integration, created by interlocking directorates of large corporations and government agencies, tracing its origins to 16th-century Europe.
In This Issue
People Mentioned
- Valerii I. SanarovAuthor
- Fred ValentichPilot
- Alexander HamiltonRancher
- Ethel L. ShawWitness
- AlbertFrench engineer
- TissandierEngineer
- RenardEngineer
- KrebsEngineer
- Santos-DumontFrenchman
- Arthur DeBaussetEngineer
- Edward J. PenningtonEngineer
- A. Leo StevensBuilder
- +5 more
Organisations
- CHICAGO JOURNALS
- Wenner-Gren Foundation for Anthropological Research
- JSTOR
- The University of Chicago Press
- Dallas Morning News
- Leroy, Kansas
- Yates Center Farmer's Advocate
- Buffalo Enterprise
- Ananias
- French engineer Albert
- Tissandier
- Renard and Krebs
- Thomas Edison
- Muscovy and Africa Companies
- +6 more
Locations
- New York, United States
- Bass Strait, Australia
- Aurora, Texas, United States
- Leroy, Kansas, United States
- Europe, Europe
- Canada, Canada
- Lake Huron, Canada
- Belgium, Belgium
- U.S.S.R., Soviet Union
- Alabama, United States
- Arkansas, United States
- California, United States
- Colorado, United States
- Illinois, United States
- +6 more